[00:00]
25 years ago, Microsoft teamed up with
[00:03]
Dwayne the Rock Johnson to announce the
[00:06]
Xbox. And it was a powerhouse with a
[00:09]
Pentium 3 processor and cuttingedge
[00:12]
GeForce graphics alongside a lean, mean,
[00:15]
slimmed down Windows-based operating
[00:17]
system that helped to push that hardware
[00:19]
to its absolute limit. Which got
[00:22]
everybody asking, why can't Windows be
[00:24]
like that on my computer? And that was
[00:27]
back then when Windows RAM usage idled
[00:29]
in the megabytes. Now you're lucky if
[00:32]
you can get it under four gigs. And for
[00:34]
what? Even the venerable start menu is
[00:37]
morphed into a bloated Reactbased web
[00:40]
app. So what? I can bing search my file
[00:42]
names. Hell no.
[00:44]
>> The good news is this seems to be
[00:46]
changing. Thanks in no small part to the
[00:48]
incredible contributions that Valve has
[00:51]
made to Linux PC gaming. They have done
[00:53]
what no one else could and forced
[00:56]
Microsoft to finally address the
[00:58]
elephant in the room. And to Microsoft's
[01:01]
credit, they've done it with Windows
[01:04]
Xbox mode, a lean, mean toggle that you
[01:07]
can just flip to strip away the bloat
[01:09]
and just focus on gaming. You don't even
[01:13]
need a keyboard and mouse anymore to
[01:15]
navigate. It's all controller all the
[01:17]
time, baby. At least in theory. In
[01:20]
practice, Xbox mode might not be quite
[01:23]
all it's cracked up to be. So before you
[01:25]
fire it up and take a look, why don't we
[01:27]
go through it together and have a look
[01:29]
at the labs testing that our team did to
[01:31]
see just how much bloat they managed to
[01:34]
remove. One bit of bloat they couldn't
[01:36]
remove is this segue to our sponsor
[01:39]
boot.dev. The best way to learn to code
[01:41]
in the subject of the award-winning
[01:42]
fantasy, the coding chronicles. For the
[01:45]
final episode and a special additional
[01:47]
discount code, keep a close watch during
[01:49]
the end of this video.
[02:01]
Performance aside, a key benefit of Xbox
[02:04]
mode is the ability to get a
[02:05]
console-like experience in a device that
[02:07]
we already own. So, why don't we see how
[02:09]
seamless it really is? Starting by
[02:12]
signing in, which um this is not
[02:15]
actually what I was expecting. Oh, okay.
[02:17]
We need to use a pin. There we go. Okay.
[02:19]
With the pin. Yeah, this is pretty cool.
[02:22]
So, there's bindings for your D-pad,
[02:24]
your shoulder buttons, and your face
[02:26]
buttons so that you can quickly enter
[02:27]
your PIN with a controller. Freaking
[02:29]
love to see it. And we're in Oh man,
[02:32]
it's good to see that logo again.
[02:34]
Obviously, not everyone wants to be
[02:35]
launched straight into a gaming
[02:37]
interface, but if you do, it's as simple
[02:40]
as toggling your system to launch
[02:41]
directly into Xbox mode. I've actually
[02:43]
been using this for a while on my
[02:45]
battery modded ROG Ally, and it's really
[02:49]
nice how much stuff you can do now
[02:51]
directly with your controller rather
[02:52]
than relying on a keyboard and mouse.
[02:54]
That's not to say that you can do
[02:55]
everything. And in fact, apparently
[02:57]
they've put together some challenges for
[02:59]
me. Uh, are you going to give me the
[03:00]
keyboard in case I fail?
[03:01]
>> You're going to have to get the keyboard
[03:02]
yourself. It's on that shelf up there if
[03:04]
you can reach it. But if you touch it,
[03:05]
you fail. Up here, I got my settings
[03:09]
where I can manage my subscriptions cuz
[03:11]
they really want you doing that. This is
[03:12]
nice. This is where you manage your
[03:13]
library. This is probably one of the
[03:15]
best things about the Xbox experience. I
[03:17]
know it's been done a hundred times in
[03:19]
the past, but this is probably the most
[03:21]
seamless that I've seen all of my
[03:23]
multiple game libraries just
[03:25]
automatically consolidated. First thing
[03:27]
they want me to do is adjust system
[03:28]
volume. Well,
[03:32]
all I said was I didn't have to touch
[03:33]
the keyboard. Normally, I would I would
[03:35]
have my, you know, system remote. So, I
[03:37]
think I won. Okay. All right. All right.
[03:39]
I'll try not cheating. I have to admit,
[03:40]
I've never tried to do this. My Ally
[03:42]
just has volume buttons on it. So, uh
[03:44]
Okay. Uh audio. I mean,
[03:50]
I can see the point you're trying to
[03:51]
make. That does seem like a fairly
[03:53]
straightforward thing, but also I can
[03:56]
see why it's not built in because in
[03:58]
almost no situation where I'm using a
[04:00]
full screen experience would I
[04:01]
necessarily need to adjust the volume.
[04:03]
Then again, Steam Big Picture can do it.
[04:05]
So,
[04:06]
>> is there a way to do it? Am I just
[04:08]
missing?
[04:09]
>> There is a way to do it. Did they pull
[04:10]
an Apple? Did they pull an Apple? Change
[04:13]
system settings. Oh, yeah, buddy. Oh
[04:16]
yeah, buddy. Let's go. This is not the
[04:18]
way. That's not the way that we
[04:20]
expected, but that works. This is
[04:22]
apparently this is not the way. Okay. Is
[04:25]
it in the game bar? I bet it's in the
[04:26]
game bar. Audio. Boom. Boom. There it
[04:28]
is. It's in the game bar. Found not one
[04:30]
but two ways. Accessibility and the game
[04:33]
bar. I got to confess that even in the
[04:36]
Xbox experience, the game bar remains
[04:39]
one of those aspects of using Windows
[04:41]
that I just find high friction with. All
[04:43]
right. Now, I got to connect to a Wi-Fi
[04:44]
network. Yeah. Once again, I guess it's
[04:46]
going to want me to use the Game Bar for
[04:48]
this. Oh yeah, buddy. Oh yeah, buddy.
[04:54]
Okay, get it together, Microsoft. This
[04:58]
This can't be a thing when I got this.
[05:01]
I'm not touching it, though. I'm going
[05:03]
to get close,
[05:06]
but I'm not touching it. Can't see what
[05:07]
I'm doing here. Oh man. Where the
[05:10]
devil's the O. Okay, here. What if I
[05:12]
click it? Okay, there. Yeah, let's go.
[05:15]
A Yeah, buddy. Next challenge. Try
[05:17]
running hardware info.
[05:19]
>> I'm going to assume that I can like add
[05:21]
it as a game.
[05:23]
Let's go. We'll play the hell out of
[05:25]
that game.
[05:27]
Okay. Was that something you guys were
[05:29]
expecting?
[05:29]
>> Yes.
[05:30]
>> Oh, more options. Edit. Oh. Oh. Okay.
[05:35]
Mhm. Okay. Close.
[05:38]
No, I do not want file picker. Close
[05:40]
there. Okay. All right. I cut out of
[05:43]
that without touching the keyboard.
[05:45]
Okay. I saw a thing here. More options.
[05:48]
Edit. This is an app. Okay.
[05:52]
Yes.
[05:54]
Okay, that's fine. That's fine. Close.
[05:57]
Okay. Uh,
[06:02]
and this is possible, right?
[06:03]
>> Yeah.
[06:04]
>> Okay. It's possible. Apparently,
[06:05]
Microsoft is adding a joystick to mouse
[06:08]
thing, but it hasn't rolled out to
[06:10]
everybody. I don't know what version of
[06:11]
this they installed. Is there like a
[06:13]
hardware info widget or something?
[06:16]
Remember
[06:17]
this is a game.
[06:20]
What does that mean?
[06:23]
Gamepad cursor. Oh, there it is. Oh,
[06:25]
sick. Oh, we're flying now. But now I
[06:28]
can do anything. I mean, yeah, that
[06:30]
should work.
[06:33]
Uh, I don't know. Say, do you mean to
[06:35]
count?
[06:38]
Is this really not going to work? The
[06:40]
request is not supported.
[06:42]
>> There's a way to do it inside of Xbox
[06:43]
mode.
[06:43]
>> There's a way to do it inside of Xbox
[06:45]
mode. Bring up a keyboard, you butt. Do
[06:47]
I really have to turn off gamepad cursor
[06:49]
in order to get a keyboard? Stupid.
[06:51]
Well, HW info is not in here. Um. Oh
[06:55]
man. Let me cook. Let me cook. Oh, hold
[06:58]
on. Wait. What is this? I mean, sure.
[07:00]
Let's try that. Okay, I'm installing it.
[07:02]
Sure. I'll install it better than you
[07:04]
guys did. And then it will open. Launch
[07:06]
hardware info. Here we go. Yes.
[07:10]
Let's go.
[07:12]
Hardware info launched. All right. Next
[07:14]
challenge. Openltd store.com. Well, this
[07:16]
is going to be too easy now. Oh, shut
[07:18]
up. Not a big fan of how I don't get a
[07:21]
keyboard when I have this enabled, but
[07:23]
this is still in beta. I'm sure they're
[07:24]
figuring that out. Well, here's a clunky
[07:26]
way to do it.
[07:29]
Boom. And was that how you expected me
[07:31]
to do it?
[07:31]
>> Honestly, no. Your solution was pretty
[07:33]
different from everything that Labs has
[07:36]
done to uh solve these.
[07:37]
>> Now, let's stop doing challenges and
[07:39]
let's see how seamless it is launching a
[07:41]
game. Starting with Cyberpunk. This is a
[07:43]
Steam game. Clearly, I think you guys
[07:44]
just saw it launch. And this is kind of
[07:47]
a worst case scenario because it's got
[07:49]
like a third party launcher thing and
[07:51]
and Steam and the Xbox experience that
[07:54]
you have to kind of fight your way
[07:55]
through. I can also see that they
[07:57]
helpfully reset it back to the initial
[08:00]
launch experience where you have to like
[08:02]
dismiss various pop-ups and whatnot. But
[08:04]
here we are. Oh, come on. Boom.
[08:08]
We're in. Consider your main frame
[08:11]
hacked. All right. All right, I got one
[08:13]
more challenge. Try enabling the game
[08:15]
bar performance overlay. Bonus point
[08:18]
options.
[08:19]
Options. Okay, here's all the metrics
[08:21]
and everything.
[08:26]
Microsoft honest bit of feedback. The
[08:29]
world does not need more iPhone like
[08:31]
experiences. Let's let back just be
[08:33]
back. Not goodbye everything. Home
[08:36]
button is home button. Back button is
[08:40]
back button. Okay, this is interesting.
[08:43]
Well,
[08:51]
okay. I've never seen it break like this
[08:54]
before. Shoot. I may have entered an
[08:56]
unreoverable state here. I can't believe
[08:59]
I'm going to lose. Going for the bonus
[09:02]
point. Okay, hold on. No, no, hold on.
[09:04]
No, I don't want to pin YouTube to the
[09:06]
taskbar. Not now, Windows. This is
[09:09]
exactly what people are using Xbox mode
[09:13]
to avoid Microsoft.
[09:18]
Ah, hold on. No, I just need to get my
[09:21]
mouse back. If I can get my mouse back,
[09:23]
I'm good to go.
[09:30]
Oh, I got my cursor. Okay. Okay. Okay.
[09:33]
Apparently, I was on the right path when
[09:35]
I did this. Like, it's got to be here.
[09:39]
Oh, not this again. For crying out loud.
[09:44]
We're in the performance widget. Hello.
[09:48]
Come on. Okay, so it's pinned. It's
[09:52]
compact. Yeah. And like
[09:54]
>> reopen Cyberpunk.
[09:56]
>> Reopen it. Wait, what the what the crap?
[10:00]
That's the way to That's crazy. So, if I
[10:04]
pin it and I have that, then it will
[10:06]
work. It should just work. That's crazy.
[10:09]
You know what? It doesn't matter. I
[10:10]
think at this point we've done enough to
[10:12]
talk about the overall experience.
[10:14]
Seamless?
[10:16]
No.
[10:17]
Somewhat intuitive?
[10:20]
Actually, other than the bugs, I would
[10:23]
say they're mostly on the right path for
[10:25]
the third time. Now, promise this is the
[10:27]
last time I'm going to mention it. They
[10:29]
need to fix home and back functionality
[10:31]
to be a clear home and back experience
[10:34]
within the Xbox app. Other than that,
[10:36]
bringing up the Xbox app interface,
[10:38]
overall pretty navigable. They do have
[10:41]
to get some functionality from the
[10:43]
non-compact mode baked into compact, but
[10:46]
in most of these cases, I can really see
[10:48]
where they're going with it. Keyboard
[10:50]
pop-ups do need to be usable when you're
[10:52]
using the cursor. Okay, there is quite a
[10:55]
lot that needs to be addressed. But on
[10:58]
the bright side, booting directly into
[11:00]
Xbox mode saved us about 7 seconds of
[11:02]
startup time. And we also found that by
[11:04]
killing the desktop UI on idle, we're
[11:07]
saving some memory compared to running
[11:09]
standard full-blown Windows with the
[11:12]
Xbox app on top of it. Now, let's see if
[11:13]
there's anything to gain while gaming.
[11:17]
Under my desk are two systems. The one
[11:19]
on the left is running Xbox mode, and
[11:21]
the one on the right is using Steam Big
[11:23]
Picture mode on top of regular old
[11:25]
Windows 11. We're using Fortza Horizon 5
[11:28]
because we wanted a very mature native
[11:31]
Game Pass game to give Xbox mode its
[11:33]
best possible shot. Both of our systems
[11:35]
are running a 9600X paired with a 560Ti
[11:38]
and 16 gigs of RAM. So, these are
[11:40]
exactly the kinds of mid-range but
[11:43]
modern systems where we might expect
[11:44]
some gains. Let's fire it up, shall we?
[11:48]
Or both are running their own overlays,
[11:50]
so we can't really compare these. But
[11:53]
what we can compare is the results page
[11:56]
at the end. So, one moment please. And
[12:00]
they're the same. Or rather, they're not
[12:03]
the same. But as we've talked about in
[12:05]
the past, even if you buy the exact same
[12:07]
hardware these days, because of dynamic
[12:09]
frequency scaling, one system can
[12:11]
perform a little different from another.
[12:13]
And this one is about 3% faster than
[12:15]
this one. So, it's a wash, which is a
[12:18]
little disappointing to be honest with
[12:21]
you. We can actually prove this. By the
[12:22]
way, now everything's running in the
[12:24]
background. Here we can run it. We can
[12:25]
run it one more time. Now it's running
[12:26]
full fat Windows. And there you go. Not
[12:29]
what we were hoping for, but hey, maybe
[12:32]
it's different on some of the other
[12:34]
titles that Labs tested. Spoiler, maybe
[12:37]
it's not. The Labs team tested at both
[12:40]
1080p and 1440p resolutions. And
[12:43]
starting with F124 at ultra high preset
[12:45]
with RT and VRS disabled.
[12:48]
Yeah, my my thoughts exactly. we once
[12:51]
again see no performance gains. And
[12:54]
making matters worse, in exchange for
[12:56]
this big fat zero performance gain, labs
[12:59]
noticed occasional issues, including
[13:01]
window focusing problems and even
[13:03]
instances where F1 refused to boot in
[13:05]
full screen mode at all. And
[13:07]
unfortunately, Doom: The Dark Ages went
[13:10]
no better. On medium presets with no
[13:12]
upscaling, we found no performance
[13:14]
benefit between Xbox mode and the
[13:16]
standard experience within the Abyssal
[13:18]
Forest benchmark. A result that was
[13:20]
repeated yet again in Cyberpunk 2077 at
[13:23]
the ultra preset with no upscaling and
[13:26]
rate tracing off. Making matters
[13:28]
worseer, as you may have noticed earlier
[13:30]
when red launcher popped up, Cyberpunk
[13:32]
isn't native to Game Pass and you
[13:34]
actually need to use mouse emulation to
[13:36]
boot the game or you can reach for a
[13:39]
mouse. I guess that is an option, but
[13:41]
that wouldn't be very console gamer of
[13:43]
you. One reason for this could be that
[13:45]
Xbox mode in its current state doesn't
[13:48]
leverage known launch flags and it fully
[13:51]
opens game launchers in the background,
[13:52]
which kind of works against the idea of
[13:55]
a seamless console-like experience. If
[13:58]
you'd like to further review Lab's
[13:59]
findings, check out the Lab's companion
[14:01]
article linked down below. Before you
[14:02]
take off and do that though, it's worth
[14:04]
discussing the fact that while Xbox game
[14:06]
mode does not offer performance
[14:08]
benefits, I still believe that it is a
[14:11]
small step toward a larger goal that
[14:14]
will be positive for gamers. Not that
[14:16]
long ago, games were optimized for
[14:18]
console first, often leaving PC players
[14:20]
with buggy, unoptimized ports. That's
[14:23]
because the low-level code for consoles
[14:25]
needed to be rewritten into something
[14:26]
that Windows could actually understand.
[14:28]
This created the same kind of
[14:30]
compatibility wall that Linux gamers
[14:32]
faced before Proton came along. And PC
[14:35]
gamers often had to wait months, years,
[14:38]
or even forever for devs to manually
[14:41]
scale that wall. Microsoft alone had
[14:44]
three fragmented software development
[14:46]
kits that held many games hostage on one
[14:48]
platform until the devs had the time and
[14:50]
resources to port over their game. The
[14:53]
UniFi GDK now, at least from Microsoft,
[14:56]
can hopefully result in something
[14:58]
approaching console level optimization
[15:00]
and availability on the PC. And Xbox
[15:03]
mode on PC is a part of this same push
[15:06]
that Microsoft is making for platform
[15:08]
unification and treating their PC gaming
[15:11]
customers like first class citizens.
[15:13]
Also, even if it doesn't have much
[15:15]
benefit today, I do still think that
[15:17]
there's hope for ongoing optimization. I
[15:20]
wouldn't blame you for thinking. I mean,
[15:22]
how in the Sam Hill is Xbox mode
[15:24]
different from Steam big picture mode?
[15:25]
But there is a difference and it's in
[15:28]
being a system versus an app level UI.
[15:31]
Xbox mode replaces the traditional
[15:34]
Windows interface. All the icons, the
[15:36]
start menu, everything, poof. On the
[15:38]
other hand, big picture mode is simply
[15:40]
an app that is sitting on top of Windows
[15:43]
and has no ability to shoe away
[15:45]
background processes. So with that in
[15:48]
mind, you would think that there would
[15:50]
be a benefit to using it already, but
[15:52]
hey, this is Microsoft. So we actually
[15:54]
found that when we were playing a Steam
[15:56]
game in particular, we ended up using
[15:59]
more RAM in Xbox mode than in Steam big
[16:03]
picture mode, just running over top of
[16:05]
regular Windows. This is most likely
[16:07]
because Steam opens up anyway on Xbox
[16:09]
mode, and Big Picture users don't need
[16:12]
to open up the Xbox app. The other
[16:15]
difference is that big picture mode is,
[16:17]
if we're being honest, quite a bit
[16:19]
cleaner to use. So, even though we're
[16:21]
hoping for the best for Xbox mode, and
[16:24]
we expect it to continue to get better,
[16:27]
you're probably going to want to stick
[16:28]
with big picture mode for the time
[16:30]
being. That is, unless you really value
[16:32]
Xbox mode's automatic detection of both
[16:35]
Steam and non- Steam games, and you are
[16:38]
a-okay with not being able to use more
[16:40]
than one display while Xbox mode is
[16:42]
Xboxing. In conclusion, while Xbox mode
[16:44]
is most certainly halfbaked today,
[16:47]
Microsoft is trending towards a world
[16:49]
where it will be even more likely that
[16:51]
the game you want to play will be
[16:53]
available on the platform you already
[16:54]
own, regardless of whether it's an Xbox
[16:57]
or a PC. So, the attitude has improved.
[17:00]
They just need to get their act together
[17:02]
before people try this thing, realize
[17:04]
it's not worth it, and then never try it
[17:07]
again. Just like people realize that
[17:09]
it's never worth hearing this segue to
[17:11]
our sponsor, but they were wrong. It is
[17:14]
about to start
[17:17]
all the way. The coding chronicles.
[17:21]
>> Hi counselors, please spare me. No
[17:30]
boots. Help me.
[17:34]
And what was her crime? spreading the
[17:37]
lie that learning to code can be fun.
[17:40]
Only the strong are worthy of this
[17:42]
power.
[17:43]
>> And the lucrative career it unlocks.
[17:47]
>> You are mistaken. Isn't that right?
[17:50]
>> Uh yeah, learning Python seemed super
[17:52]
hard until boot.dev made it fun. I even
[17:55]
used it to get Boots's hat back.
[17:58]
>> You defeated Gerald the giant.
[18:00]
>> Yeah, he was like PRETTY CHILL,
[18:01]
ACTUALLY.
[18:02]
>> SILENCE. I WON'T HAVE YOU PROFANE these
[18:04]
chambers with such untruisms. Learning
[18:06]
to code is hard.
[18:09]
>> Untruisms.
[18:11]
It's a word. Larry, enough of this. Let
[18:15]
go.
[18:17]
No.
[18:23]
>> You must go, child.
[18:25]
>> Grown man. But no, I can't leave you.
[18:27]
Uh, plus I have more to learn.
[18:30]
>> Yes. in the real world WHERE YOU CAN GET
[18:33]
THAT HIGHPAYING JOB.
[18:36]
>> Thanks for everything, Boots. Love you.
[18:38]
>> Love you, too. Now go.
[18:47]
>> It's just a dream.
[18:49]
What?
[18:51]
Wait.
[18:53]
Don't forget to click the link in the
[18:54]
description box and use code LT to get
[18:56]
25% off your first month or year with
[18:58]
boot.dev dev and an additional discount
[19:00]
using this code.
[19:02]
>> GET THAT HIGHPAYING JOB.
[19:04]
>> OKAY, BOOTS, I will.
[19:10]
If you guys enjoyed this video, why not
[19:12]
check out the one we did recently
[19:13]
talking about what has finally prompted
[19:16]
Microsoft to take action, even if that
[19:18]
action is a little slower and a little
[19:20]
less effective than we'd like so far.