[00:00]
why is this akai so popular
[00:03]
seriously no don't get me wrong i
[00:05]
understand why there's a lot of appeal
[00:06]
for it one of the biggest being that
[00:07]
it's kind of a wish fulfillment fantasy
[00:09]
where you get to be the self-insert
[00:11]
who's surrounded by pretty girls and has
[00:13]
cool powers and gets to go on quests and
[00:15]
the like there's nothing wrong with that
[00:17]
i'm not saying that all isakai's are bad
[00:18]
in fact i've even watched some
[00:20]
shows that are isikai like konasuba and
[00:23]
re zero
[00:23]
and love them but what kind of confuses
[00:25]
me is the sheer
[00:26]
volume of it it honestly feels like
[00:29]
every new anime
[00:30]
season there's like another 50 isakai
[00:32]
shows just
[00:33]
there and people keep watching it and
[00:35]
that's fine
[00:36]
i'm not judging you watch as much as you
[00:38]
want but the thing that confuses me
[00:40]
about all of this
[00:41]
is the fact that it's so popular despite
[00:43]
the fact that on
[00:44]
a purely conceptual level isakai
[00:48]
is kind of boring to me
[00:53]
now what do i mean by that now usually
[00:54]
when you think of anisakai they have
[00:56]
several qualities
[00:57]
in common there's an overpowered hero
[00:59]
who's ridiculously strong from the start
[01:01]
he's also ridiculously generic
[01:03]
in both his looks and personality he's
[01:05]
quickly surrounded by a harem of girls
[01:07]
and he gets transported to this world to
[01:09]
just
[01:11]
do stuff maybe maybe there's a demon
[01:13]
lord in the end he needs to defeat i
[01:14]
don't know
[01:15]
i have many problems with these a lot
[01:18]
first off why are the main characters
[01:19]
always overpowered
[01:20]
yes i get it it's a power fantasy but
[01:22]
having characters who are ridiculously
[01:25]
powerful from the start
[01:26]
are a lot harder to make interesting
[01:29]
than if they were underpowered
[01:31]
stories need conflict characters
[01:34]
and conflict are the two main driving
[01:37]
forces behind stories behind
[01:39]
all stories and if you don't have those
[01:41]
things you
[01:42]
don't have a story and yet isakai seems
[01:45]
to love
[01:45]
not doing those things having an
[01:48]
overpowered character
[01:49]
can very easily drain the conflict and
[01:51]
in most cases in isakai this
[01:54]
is exactly what it does if every time
[01:56]
he's going to fight we know he's going
[01:58]
to win
[02:00]
then what's the point of the fight in
[02:02]
the first place
[02:03]
i'm not saying there's something wrong
[02:04]
with creating overpowered characters
[02:06]
there are plenty of them that are done
[02:08]
well i'm just saying that it takes a lot
[02:10]
more effort to create
[02:11]
interesting and lasting conflicts with
[02:14]
overpowered characters
[02:15]
it's a lot easier for me to lose
[02:17]
interest in these characters because i
[02:19]
feel like they don't have any stakes
[02:20]
whatsoever seriously there are so many
[02:22]
isakai premises out there that i read
[02:25]
and it and all it is is just wow
[02:29]
look how overpowered this character is
[02:33]
and that's it what's the story where's
[02:35]
the plot do they have any actual goals
[02:38]
here i just don't see what's so
[02:40]
interesting about a character being
[02:42]
crazy powerful for no reason
[02:44]
uh i mean maybe it's a comedy but
[02:47]
so far i don't really see what the joke
[02:49]
is now you'd think it'd be more
[02:51]
interesting for both the writer and the
[02:53]
audience to have an underpowered main
[02:55]
character instead
[02:56]
one who starts off weak but through hard
[02:58]
work and training gets stronger
[03:00]
and eventually is able to defeat the
[03:03]
demon king
[03:04]
and save the day in a satisfying way
[03:07]
you know like most video games but nah
[03:09]
we need that instant gratification don't
[03:11]
we boys
[03:12]
i mean seriously could you imagine if
[03:14]
video games work the same way
[03:15]
like you start the game only to be given
[03:19]
the most powerful item straight away
[03:21]
like
[03:23]
what's even the point of playing the
[03:25]
game anymore okay but
[03:26]
it's not just the fact that they're
[03:27]
super powerful there are ways to make
[03:29]
overpowered characters interesting which
[03:31]
i
[03:31]
talked about in my mary sue video which
[03:33]
i will link up in the corner but a lot
[03:35]
of the time isakai's don't do this
[03:37]
all they do is that they just kind of
[03:40]
get this huge and powerful monster
[03:42]
and have the main character defeat them
[03:44]
in a cool way
[03:45]
also the writer can show off how cool
[03:48]
they are from an ability that was
[03:50]
given to them i don't get it another
[03:53]
thing that the main characters always
[03:54]
seem to have
[03:55]
is the exact same personality the
[03:58]
personality of none
[03:59]
now in theory it's supposed to be that
[04:01]
they're as generic as possible so that a
[04:04]
wider range of audience members could
[04:06]
relate to them they're supposed to be as
[04:08]
relatable to as many people
[04:09]
as possible but that's not how stories
[04:12]
work
[04:13]
i don't really relate to a character's
[04:15]
personality in fact if i saw myself as
[04:17]
an anime character i'd probably hate him
[04:19]
what i do relate to are situations
[04:23]
if i see a character go through a
[04:25]
situation even in a fantasy world
[04:28]
that i feel like i can relate to that
[04:31]
makes me connect with them because i
[04:33]
feel like
[04:33]
yes i totally get that i understand what
[04:36]
you're going through and this still
[04:38]
applies
[04:38]
even if they have a completely different
[04:40]
personality to me sato kazma has a very
[04:43]
different personality to me
[04:44]
if i went to an isakai world suddenly i
[04:47]
would not have the guts to do any of the
[04:49]
things that he does
[04:50]
and yet he's one of the most relatable
[04:52]
protagonists
[04:54]
i've ever seen wanna know why it's
[04:56]
because he suffers
[04:57]
he is constantly landed with tons of
[05:00]
debt and bills he needs to pay he needs
[05:02]
to work his butt off just to be able to
[05:04]
start adventuring he has to live at the
[05:06]
stables in the beginning he has trouble
[05:07]
making companions who are basically
[05:09]
problem children who he constantly needs
[05:11]
to keep in line he feels and dies
[05:13]
constantly he has no real skills or
[05:15]
advantages
[05:15]
and he has a terrible reputation to be i
[05:18]
don't care
[05:19]
if kazuma is exactly like me or not but
[05:21]
when i see him have to go
[05:23]
through these mundane yet painful parts
[05:27]
of life
[05:28]
i can't help but feel like i get him so
[05:31]
knowing this there really is no excuse
[05:33]
to not give isakai protagonists real
[05:35]
personalities
[05:36]
now they obviously don't need to be as
[05:37]
exaggerated or as cultured as cosma is
[05:40]
but you can still make them feel more
[05:42]
like an actual person
[05:44]
than a cardboard cutout there is no
[05:46]
excuse for lazy characterization
[05:49]
the last thing that i wanted to mention
[05:50]
was about the entire reason they were
[05:52]
transported here in the first place
[05:54]
what are they supposed to do like they
[05:57]
get
[05:57]
reincarnated into this new world
[06:00]
now what i mean you could fight monsters
[06:03]
and get stronger
[06:04]
but there's no point because you're
[06:05]
already an overpowered badass so
[06:08]
most of the time all the main character
[06:10]
has in mind is i don't know
[06:12]
i guess i'll just explore and then they
[06:14]
do until they
[06:15]
stumble upon some kind of plot if the
[06:18]
main character doesn't have
[06:20]
any real goals from the beginning then
[06:22]
how can you expect me to care
[06:23]
like how is that interesting to anyone i
[06:26]
mean in many cases yeah sure there's
[06:28]
like
[06:28]
also a demon lord or whatever or
[06:31]
something like that who
[06:32]
has an army who's causing trouble
[06:34]
throughout the world
[06:35]
and that's who we need to stop but the
[06:37]
thing about that is that there's no real
[06:39]
motivation or reason for why the main
[06:41]
character would want to do that
[06:43]
in the first place other than just it's
[06:45]
the right thing to do
[06:46]
which in itself just makes them feel
[06:49]
even less relatable since
[06:50]
what teenager would ever actually have
[06:52]
those kinds of goals now in some older
[06:54]
shows with similar premises
[06:56]
yes you've got the entire transported
[06:58]
another world thing but the main
[06:59]
character has a clear goal
[07:01]
from the start to get back to their
[07:03]
original world to get back home
[07:05]
ready that's way more interesting
[07:07]
because they have a solid goal
[07:09]
with an understandable motivation and
[07:11]
you can already picture how as they go
[07:13]
throughout the story they get closer and
[07:15]
closer to that goal
[07:16]
even sword art online gets this step
[07:19]
right there is a reason why so many
[07:21]
people were intrigued by its original
[07:23]
premise
[07:23]
and it's for this reason i mean yeah it
[07:25]
still falls into the other pitfalls i
[07:27]
mentioned before but
[07:28]
at least the idea is good all stories
[07:31]
need conflict of some kind it doesn't
[07:33]
matter what genre it is
[07:34]
and yes that includes slice of life
[07:36]
might make a video about that if i feel
[07:38]
like it
[07:39]
but when it comes to isakai as a whole
[07:41]
not individual shows
[07:43]
for some reason all the tropes that it's
[07:46]
known for
[07:47]
seem to do nothing but drain the
[07:49]
conflict and a story without conflict
[07:52]
is kind of boring to me that's why it
[07:55]
confuses me that despite all of this
[07:58]
isakai is still so popular now i haven't
[08:01]
really watched a whole lot of izakaya at
[08:03]
this point and the reasons are because
[08:04]
of everything i mentioned beforehand and
[08:06]
combine that with the fact that pretty
[08:07]
much every izakaya synopsis i read
[08:09]
sounds almost the exact same
[08:11]
except for one major difference i can
[08:13]
never really bring myself to be
[08:15]
all that interested maybe i'm just the
[08:17]
wrong audience i don't know
[08:18]
clearly there's something that i'm
[08:19]
missing that everyone else seems to be
[08:21]
enjoying
[08:22]
so to all the izakaya fans out there
[08:24]
who's watching this video
[08:26]
tell me why do you enjoy isakai as a
[08:28]
genre is it the comedy
[08:30]
is it the characters or is it something
[08:32]
else that i just don't get
[08:34]
i'm not asking this to be sarcastic i i
[08:36]
genuinely want to see your responses
[08:38]
or you can just tell me i'm wrong that's
[08:41]
fine too
[08:41]
my name is brenda reilly and that is why
[08:44]
i think that isekai
[08:45]
is kinda boring thanks for watching
[08:55]
you