The One Plant I'd Choose (Not Tomatoes!)
42sContrarian take on common garden favorites sparks curiosity and debate.
▶ Play ClipAI Summary
The video argues that if you could only grow one thing in your garden, the most cost-effective choice is the allium family—onions and garlic. These plants are not heavy feeders, can be densely planted, require minimal upkeep, and provide food at every stage of growth, from early greens to cured bulbs for winter storage.
Chapters
[00:03]
The Question
The creator is often asked what single crop they would grow if limited to one, ruling out potatoes, tomatoes, and cucumbers.
[00:16]
Alliums as the Answer
Alliums (onions and garlic) are identified as the most cost-effective plant, because they are not heavy feeders and can be packed densely into a single bed.
[00:29]
Dense Planting
The creator plants nine garlic cloves per square foot and nine onions per square foot, maximizing yield in a small space.
[00:43]
Low Maintenance and Continuous Harvest
Alliums require no pruning or upkeep, and can be harvested at any point in their growth cycle, providing food within weeks by picking the tops of onion plants.
[00:55]
Garlic Scapes and Storage
Mature garlic plants produce delicious garlic scapes. After harvest, the bulbs can be cured for a few weeks, providing food through the winter months.
Growing alliums like onions and garlic is a highly efficient, low-maintenance strategy that yields food continuously and stores well, making them the ideal single crop for a productive garden.
Study Flashcards (5)
What plant family does the creator recommend as the most cost-effective to grow?
easy
Click to reveal answer
What plant family does the creator recommend as the most cost-effective to grow?
easy
Click to reveal answer
Alliums (onions and garlic).
00:16
How many garlic cloves and onions are planted per square foot?
medium
Click to reveal answer
How many garlic cloves and onions are planted per square foot?
medium
Click to reveal answer
Nine garlic cloves and nine onions per square foot.
00:29
What are two reasons alliums are considered low-maintenance?
medium
Click to reveal answer
What are two reasons alliums are considered low-maintenance?
medium
Click to reveal answer
They don't need pruning or upkeep.
00:43
What can be harvested from garlic plants when they mature?
easy
Click to reveal answer
What can be harvested from garlic plants when they mature?
easy
Click to reveal answer
Garlic scapes.
00:55
How long are garlic bulbs cured after harvest?
medium
Click to reveal answer
How long are garlic bulbs cured after harvest?
medium
Click to reveal answer
For a few weeks.
00:55
💡 Key Takeaways
💡
Alliums as the most cost-effective plant
Provides a clear, evidence-based answer to the central question, backed by practical experience.
00:16
🔧
Dense planting technique
Offers a specific, actionable planting density that maximizes yield in small spaces.
00:29
📊
Continuous harvest capability
Highlights a unique advantage of alliums: food available at every growth stage, reducing food insecurity.
00:43Full Transcript
[00:03] grow. All right, so one question I get all of the time is, if I could only grow one thing, what would it be? >> It certainly would not be potatoes. >> It definitely wouldn't be tomatoes. It wouldn't be cucumbers. It wouldn't be
[00:16] >> The most cost effective plant I have found by far are aliums. >> I'm talking about your onions and your garlic. And here's why. First off, these plants aren't heavy feeders, so you can absolutely pack them into one bed. I
[00:29] planted nine garlic cloves per square foot and nine onions per square foot. for some additional greens. And what I love most about the alium family is and they don't really need any pruning or upkeep. You can also harvest and eat
[00:43] aliums at any point in their growing cycle, meaning food within weeks of that you can pick from the top of the onion plants that you would ever need. And of course, you get those delicious garlic scapes when the garlic plants
[00:55] have matured, I can harvest them all and cure them for a few weeks. And now I've winter. So, I've been eating off this same crop for the past few months. And now I have all of this food for the next few months.
