[00:00]
I make a lot of videos related to
[00:02]
virtual desktop, like a lot. But one
[00:04]
question keeps coming up repeatedly.
[00:07]
Which is the best codec to use? So today
[00:10]
I'm going to address this question with
[00:12]
a comparison under the same strict
[00:15]
testing regime where all settings are
[00:17]
the same and the only variation is the
[00:20]
actual codec itself. Let's get straight
[00:23]
into it then. And remember, we're born
[00:24]
to respawn.
[00:27]
the test. My PC is running a 12th gen i9
[00:31]
CPU and RTX 4080 GPU with 64 gig of DDR5
[00:36]
RAM. I run a TPLink Archer AXC75 Wi-Fi
[00:40]
6E router in access mode exclusively for
[00:43]
virtual desktop to maximize wireless
[00:45]
performance which sits at a steady 2.4
[00:48]
Gbits pers on the 6 GHz channel. Virtual
[00:51]
desktop's PC streamer app settings are
[00:53]
as follows. On the options tab, open XR
[00:57]
runtime. I am using virtual desktop's
[01:00]
own VDXR runtime. Adaptive quantization
[01:03]
and two pass encoding are off as they
[01:06]
only support the 10- bit codeex.
[01:08]
Automatically adjust bit rate is off. I
[01:11]
have manually set each bit rate to its
[01:13]
maximum allowed so that there are no
[01:16]
anomalies. On the advanced tab, I have
[01:18]
the horizontal and vertical tangent
[01:20]
sliders at 100% with the FOV stencil
[01:24]
ticked just to ek out a bit more
[01:27]
performance. In headset, VR graphics
[01:29]
quality is at ultra. VR frame rate is 90
[01:32]
fps. Bit rate is set to the maximum
[01:34]
allowed by the codec. For example, H.264
[01:38]
allows up to 500 megabits per second.
[01:41]
Synchronous spacew walk is off.
[01:43]
Snapdragon game super resolution is off.
[01:45]
and video buffering is also off. These
[01:49]
settings are purely to eliminate any
[01:51]
interference and keep the test as pure
[01:54]
as possible. I made sure that Virtual
[01:57]
Desktop was running the latest build and
[01:59]
that there were no interfering apps
[02:01]
either. I am using my MetaQuest 3
[02:04]
headset and all footage you will see was
[02:06]
recorded internally so that you could
[02:08]
see the virtual desktop performance
[02:10]
overlay in real time. All in-game
[02:13]
graphics were on the ultra preset except
[02:16]
for trackside TV displays which are
[02:18]
turned off and the grid was restricted
[02:20]
to 20 cars. That's it for the settings.
[02:22]
As I stated, all these will remain the
[02:25]
same throughout all five tests and the
[02:28]
codec will be the only variable. I will
[02:31]
do one lap of Monza in my favorite
[02:34]
McLaren GT3 car at midday with the same
[02:37]
weather for each test. I will show the
[02:39]
whole lap with the virtual desktop
[02:41]
performance overlay showing in real time
[02:43]
so that you can see how each codec
[02:46]
performed. Then I will run the same laps
[02:48]
side by side for a direct comparison.
[02:51]
The final part of the video will be my
[02:53]
conclusion which if you haven't fallen
[02:56]
asleep by then will be less
[02:58]
science-based and more on the feeling of
[03:00]
which codec delivered the best balance
[03:03]
of latency and visual performance for
[03:04]
me. So, if you're a proper geek like me,
[03:09]
make sure to stay till the end of the
[03:10]
video for that. Ready? Let's go.
[03:15]
H264,
[03:17]
the oldest codec here, running at 200
[03:20]
megabits pers. It should deliver the
[03:23]
lowest latency, but with video quality
[03:25]
compromised. Let's see how it does.
[03:31]
Yeah.
[03:36]
[Music]
[03:44]
[Music]
[03:54]
Heat.
[03:58]
Heat.
[04:00]
[Music]
[04:12]
[Music]
[04:17]
Heat.
[04:21]
[Music]
[04:34]
Heat. Heat.
[04:46]
[Music]
[05:02]
[Music]
[05:07]
[Music]
[05:13]
H264
[05:15]
Plus. This is a modification of the
[05:18]
H.264 codec, allowing for better
[05:20]
compression efficiency and can run up to
[05:24]
500 megabits per second.
[05:27]
[Music]
[05:40]
Hey,
[05:42]
hey,
[05:45]
[Music]
[05:54]
hey.
[06:02]
Heat. Heat.
[06:03]
[Music]
[06:13]
[Music]
[06:22]
Heat. Heat.
[06:24]
[Music]
[06:40]
[Music]
[06:42]
Heat. Heat.
[06:46]
[Music]
[07:01]
[Music]
[07:12]
HVC,
[07:14]
sometimes referred to as H.265.
[07:17]
This is the successor to H.264 and
[07:20]
should allow better compression and
[07:22]
quality over its predecessor.
[07:25]
[Music]
[07:28]
Hey,
[07:34]
[Music]
[07:40]
hey,
[07:44]
hey.
[07:47]
[Music]
[07:55]
Heat.
[07:58]
[Music]
[08:07]
[Music]
[08:14]
Heat.
[08:16]
[Music]
[08:19]
Help.
[08:21]
[Music]
[08:37]
[Music]
[08:39]
Heat.
[08:43]
[Music]
[08:57]
[Music]
[09:09]
HEVC 10bit. An evolution of HEVC where
[09:13]
the 10 bit refers to each color red,
[09:16]
green, and blue being represented by 10
[09:18]
bits and evolution required for higher
[09:21]
resolutions like 4K and 8K.
[09:32]
[Music]
[09:38]
Heat.
[09:40]
[Music]
[09:47]
[Music]
[09:49]
Heat.
[09:59]
Hey,
[10:09]
heat.
[10:16]
[Music]
[10:28]
Hallelujah.
[10:35]
[Music]
[10:38]
Heat.
[10:41]
[Music]
[10:58]
[Music]
[11:07]
AV1 10 bit offering better compression
[11:10]
and color than older codecs. This is
[11:13]
currently the most modern codec used by
[11:15]
virtual desktop.
[11:18]
Heat.
[11:20]
[Music]
[11:30]
[Music]
[11:40]
Heat.
[11:43]
[Music]
[11:54]
Heat.
[11:57]
[Music]
[12:07]
Heat.
[12:15]
Heat.
[12:17]
[Music]
[12:26]
Heat.
[12:33]
[Music]
[12:54]
[Music]
[13:02]
Right, let's sit back and run them all
[13:05]
side by side for a direct comparison.
[13:11]
[Music]
[13:19]
[Music]
[13:27]
Heat. Heat.
[13:29]
[Music]
[13:44]
[Music]
[13:54]
[Music]
[13:56]
Conclusion. Unsurprisingly, all the
[13:59]
codecs performed well with consistent
[14:01]
frame rates and manageable latency with
[14:03]
my PC and wireless setup. As expected,
[14:06]
H.264 264 at 200 megabits per second
[14:09]
consistently gave the lowest latency
[14:11]
overall between 31 to 48 milliseconds
[14:15]
with good frame rate between 87 and 90
[14:17]
and an average across most of the lab of
[14:20]
90 fps with 37 milliseconds latency. But
[14:23]
to me the visual fidelity was clearly
[14:26]
lower. H264 plus at 500 megabits per
[14:29]
second had higher latency between 34 to
[14:32]
55 milliseconds. probably due to the
[14:34]
higher bit rate. A good frame rate
[14:36]
between 86 to 90 with an average 90 fps
[14:40]
across most of the lap with 40
[14:42]
milliseconds latency. And like H.264,
[14:45]
my opinion is that the visual clarity
[14:47]
wasn't as good. HEVC at 200 megabits per
[14:51]
second had slightly higher latency at 37
[14:54]
to 52 milliseconds. Frame rate between
[14:56]
84 to 90 with an average across the lap
[14:59]
at 90 FPS with 48 milliseconds latency.
[15:02]
However, the visuals were a definite
[15:05]
step up from H.264 and 264 Plus. HEVC
[15:09]
10bit and AV110 bit had an almost
[15:12]
identical performance with both
[15:14]
latencies between 32 to 56 milliseconds.
[15:17]
Frame rates between 86 to 90 with an
[15:19]
average across the lap at 90 FPS with 37
[15:24]
milliseconds latency. In my opinion,
[15:27]
both these codecs gave a sharper, more
[15:29]
colorful image than the three previous
[15:31]
codecs. And if I had to choose between
[15:33]
them, it's a difficult one as the
[15:36]
differences are very very marginal. For
[15:38]
me, after this test, I would choose HEVC
[15:43]
10 bit just for the tiny difference in
[15:45]
consistency. But of course, this is my
[15:48]
opinion. At the end of the day, it is
[15:50]
your choice. Prefer latency, pick H.264,
[15:53]
which consistently had the lowest
[15:55]
latency overall. prefer graphical
[15:57]
sharpness and better colors, then either
[16:00]
HEVC 10bit or AV110 bit would have you
[16:04]
covered. Plus, for consistency across
[16:06]
the test, I had no adaptive
[16:09]
quantization, no two passing coding, no
[16:13]
adjustment of the horizontal field of
[16:15]
view sliders, plus synchronous spacew
[16:17]
walk and snapdragon game super
[16:19]
resolution were turned off. These
[16:21]
settings can have a massive influence on
[16:24]
performance, but can also cause issues.
[16:26]
I have done a full video on this subject
[16:28]
here. So, if this video has piqu your
[16:31]
interests, go check it out for some
[16:33]
serious performance gains with just a
[16:35]
few little tweaks. As always though,
[16:38]
what do you think? Do you prefer lower
[16:40]
latency over graphical fidelity, or are
[16:43]
you like me, a massive graphics tart who
[16:46]
must have all the shiny things? You know
[16:49]
the drill. Get involved and comment down
[16:51]
below. Well, that's it for today. If you
[16:54]
enjoyed this content, please hit the
[16:55]
like button. The algorithm loves the
[16:57]
likes. If you love this content, please
[17:00]
join my channel membership like these
[17:02]
lovely people did. You get custom
[17:04]
badges, emojis, and early access to most
[17:06]
of my content. If you want to watch more
[17:09]
content from me, please click here or
[17:11]
here. Thanks for watching. I'll see you
[17:15]
on the other