[00:00]
- You've probably seen the ads,
[00:01]
Kalshi Polymarket.
[00:03]
The pitch is that you can bet on anything,
[00:06]
the election, the Super Bowl,
[00:07]
whether or not aliens will land in 2026.
[00:10]
Well, I put $1,000 of my
[00:13]
are prediction markets a scam?
[00:15]
(upbeat music)
[00:16]
with Polymarket.
[00:17]
Let's see what we got.
[00:18]
So there's $21 million in bets
[00:20]
on what will happen before GTA VI.
[00:22]
55% that there'll be a
[00:25]
We live in a world where
[00:26]
or not a war will have a
[00:31]
Actually, I'm kind on board with this.
[00:32]
I feel like some stuff is dumb,
[00:33]
but that's kind of funny.
[00:34]
How it works.
[00:35]
Buy yes or no shares
[00:37]
Odds shift in real time.
[00:39]
Place a trade, fund your
[00:41]
debit card, or bank transfer.
[00:42]
Oh, they don't take credit cards?
[00:44]
I mean, that's probably
[00:44]
for the best.
[00:45]
- But, okay.
[00:46]
Oh, "By trading you
[00:49]
"and attest that you are not a US person,
[00:51]
"you are not located in the US,
[00:52]
"and are not the resident of
[00:53]
"or located in a restricted jurisdiction."
[00:55]
Wait, I thought you could do this in US.
[00:57]
- [Alex] Well, remember how
[01:00]
different platforms being
[01:03]
- Polymarket aren't legal yet, are they?
[01:05]
- [Alex] Not in the US.
[01:05]
No, not really.
[01:06]
- I am not gonna be doing
[01:08]
I am a good, law abiding citizen.
[01:12]
Let's go to Kalshi. (coughs)
[01:13]
Okay, so quick context,
[01:14]
because while they're
[01:16]
Kalshi and Polymarket aren't
[01:20]
Polymarket's the one
[01:22]
and they're also the slightly more,
[01:23]
shall we say, problematic
[01:26]
- How do you feel about war?
[01:28]
- And as we've just seen,
[01:29]
they're technically illegal
[01:32]
Now Polymarket US, which is its own thing,
[01:34]
is coming, if you wanna
[01:36]
But for right now, if you're an American,
[01:38]
and you keep hearing about Polymarket,
[01:40]
well, you've been hearing about a website
[01:41]
that you're not supposed
[01:44]
Kalshi is the one I can use.
[01:46]
It is an actual CFTC regulated exchange,
[01:49]
meaning it's approved by
[01:51]
that oversees other futures trading.
[01:54]
Now how betting on aliens is
[01:55]
considered the same kind of futures option
[01:58]
as farmers hedging against a dry season is
[02:00]
a whole other question.
[02:02]
But that's besides the point.
[02:03]
So there were definitely a
[02:06]
So they needed email,
[02:08]
a phone number,
[02:09]
my name,
[02:10]
my address.
[02:11]
They wanted to scan my
[02:14]
And I also did have to give
[02:16]
But after doing Rent-A-Center,
[02:18]
I guess I'll just give that
[02:21]
So why don't we take a closer look?
[02:23]
I do have, as you can see here,
[02:25]
$1,000 in my portfolio,
[02:27]
which they apparently pay...
[02:29]
"Please check the information
[02:31]
"and try again."
[02:32]
What?
[02:33]
They take my money?
[02:33]
What do you mean information?
[02:34]
I gave you it all.
[02:35]
Give me some options.
[02:37]
What are we gonna bet on?
[02:38]
- Pokemon.
[02:39]
Where are we going
[02:40]
to financially make
[02:43]
- [Ken] Pokemon.
[02:44]
- I don't think...
[02:45]
Is there Pokemon?
[02:46]
Whoa.
[02:47]
Okay, so you can bet
[02:51]
- [Ken] This is right up your alley, dude.
[02:53]
Go. Go for it.
[02:54]
You don't even have to buy packs anymore.
[02:56]
- Who wants to buy
[02:58]
Why don't you just bet on
[02:59]
- [Ken] Exactly.
[03:00]
- My goal for this video is
[03:01]
not to just say, "These are dumb and bad."
[03:03]
Like, I wanna understand
[03:06]
I wanna understand how legal
[03:10]
how they've worked
[03:12]
and ultimately what it's
[03:18]
and money, and effort into,
[03:20]
can you win,
[03:21]
how does it work,
[03:22]
and what are the downsides?
[03:23]
Because I'm pretty skeptical.
[03:26]
But you can understand the pitch.
[03:28]
No house, no bookie.
[03:30]
You're not betting against Kalshi,
[03:31]
you're betting against other people.
[03:33]
Kalshi just takes a cut of every trade.
[03:35]
To learn more,
[03:36]
I spoke with Dr. Robin Hanson,
[03:38]
the father of modern prediction markets.
[03:40]
- I worked with this group called Xanadu,
[03:42]
trying to invent the World Wide Web.
[03:43]
And their vision, in part,
[03:45]
was that the web would make
[03:47]
and that would make public
[03:50]
And I started to have doubts.
[03:51]
And so I wondered, what
[03:54]
You know, those of us
[03:55]
that many public consensus were stupid,
[03:58]
and misinformed, and misdirected.
[04:01]
The idea was accessible to me that,
[04:03]
why not have betting markets?
[04:04]
And couldn't the betting
[04:06]
healthier context in which
[04:09]
to form a consensus.
[04:11]
That was my initial
[04:14]
- So that's the theory at least.
[04:15]
Now, Kalshi and Polymarket aren't
[04:17]
really what Dr. Hanson had in mind,
[04:19]
but the core concept is here.
[04:21]
In a market where people put their money
[04:23]
where their mouth is,
[04:24]
the prices are likely to reflect
[04:25]
what the crowd actually believes,
[04:27]
not what they say they do.
[04:29]
- And of course,
[04:29]
I started to read more about
[04:30]
the state of literature
[04:32]
and I learned that the standard story
[04:34]
on financial markets is that,
[04:35]
in fact, it's hard to find
[04:38]
And then when we've had
[04:40]
of financial markets to other institutions
[04:42]
at the same time, same
[04:45]
the markets just consistently do better.
[04:46]
- Look, I'm not a huge fan of gambling.
[04:49]
I personally believe
[04:50]
that some friction in
[04:52]
A trip to Vegas is a very
[04:55]
casually tapping a few
[04:57]
But let's do this.
[04:58]
$1,000 to see how this actually works.
[05:01]
(screen whooshing)
[05:02]
I don't know if this is for me.
[05:03]
(Austin laughing)
[05:05]
So I've been using Kalshi
[05:09]
and I just don't know what
[05:13]
because look, I think what
[05:17]
they take bets on things
[05:19]
that they're really passionate about.
[05:20]
But not only am I trying to
[05:24]
but even the things that
[05:26]
I feel like are really boring, right?
[05:28]
Like, so I've made some bets.
[05:29]
I'll actually show you
[05:31]
which I am exclusively down
[05:34]
So I bet on some F1 stuff.
[05:36]
But the problem is, there's
[05:39]
and most of the bets
[05:40]
you know, what's gonna happen
[05:42]
So they're not really exciting.
[05:44]
I bet on a Pikachu card going up,
[05:46]
which I am making some money on.
[05:48]
I've taken a massive hit
[05:52]
which at this point,
[05:53]
at least as I'm recording right now,
[05:54]
seems like they're about to,
[05:55]
like, bring out a new
[05:58]
So I'm way down on that.
[06:00]
The one that I was doing
[06:02]
betting on aliens.
[06:04]
That's also not exciting.
[06:05]
Like, I understand there's
[06:10]
but to me,
[06:13]
it doesn't click on betting
[06:17]
I'm trying to get it,
[06:19]
but I'm not really getting it.
[06:21]
(screen whooshing)
[06:22]
Here's what I keep getting stuck on.
[06:24]
It's not that I don't personally
[06:26]
resonate with this stuff so much.
[06:27]
I mean, I get it. Gambling is fun.
[06:29]
The bigger question is,
[06:30]
why are prediction markets
[06:33]
The ads all over sports on TV.
[06:35]
The integrations on cable news.
[06:37]
I mean, somebody decided this needed to be
[06:39]
in front of all of our faces all the time,
[06:42]
and it's working.
[06:43]
Kalshi and Polymarket combined did about
[06:44]
$50 billion in trades last year.
[06:47]
They did that much again in just March
[06:49]
and April of this year.
[06:51]
Something else was going on here.
[06:53]
So I reached out to a good
[06:56]
who is an independent sports journalist
[06:58]
and who has done some great reporting
[06:59]
on the rise of sports betting.
[07:01]
- At the beginning it felt like the small,
[07:03]
kind of niche thing.
[07:04]
And then,
[07:05]
especially over the course
[07:06]
it's really exploded in a way
[07:08]
that I think it's been kind of surprising.
[07:10]
I think that people within the industry,
[07:11]
both on the sports gambling side
[07:13]
and on the prediction market side,
[07:14]
I think have been surprised
[07:16]
And I think the breaking point moment
[07:18]
for me was not even in sports.
[07:19]
But I live in New York City
[07:21]
and I was walking around during
[07:22]
the Democratic primary of
[07:25]
between Andrew Cuomo and Zohran Mamdani.
[07:27]
And you would see these massive billboards
[07:30]
on the sides of the subway basically,
[07:32]
being like, "Look at the live ads
[07:34]
"for the race between Andrew
[07:37]
It felt like a kind of
[07:40]
because it was like,
[07:41]
"Oh, this is such a dangerous,
[07:42]
"slippery slope when
[07:46]
"and applying it to
[07:48]
"which affects all of our
[07:50]
"even if we don't want to think about it."
[07:51]
- Yikes!
[07:52]
The whole pitch is that these things are
[07:54]
supposed to be different from
[07:58]
You know, it's more transparent
[07:59]
when you're betting against people,
[08:00]
and not the house.
[08:02]
Dr. Hanson's whole vision
[08:05]
not about late-stage capitalism.
[08:08]
But it never quite works
[08:10]
Polymarket and Kalshi aren't blowing up,
[08:12]
'cause people are finding so much value
[08:14]
in the information they provide.
[08:16]
It's because of a serious marketing push.
[08:19]
- Well, the marketing
[08:21]
that the sportsbooks
[08:23]
Kalshi is decentralized.
[08:25]
You're betting against the people.
[08:26]
The reality of that is
[08:27]
that a lot of these kind of private equity
[08:30]
and, like, venture capital,
[08:31]
like, these major financial firms
[08:32]
that control Wall Street are
[08:35]
actually setting the markets for it.
[08:36]
And so the odds on these
[08:39]
aren't any different from
[08:41]
what you would see on a sportsbook.
[08:43]
But the marketing campaign,
[08:45]
because of kind of the less centralized,
[08:47]
less regulated nature of
[08:51]
it kind of pushes people towards this idea
[08:54]
that you're just betting
[08:56]
when in actuality you're betting against
[08:58]
these massive Wall Street firms.
[08:59]
And so-
[09:01]
opened my eyes to the biggest
[09:04]
sports betting.
[09:06]
By some estimates,
[09:06]
it's around 90% of the
[09:09]
which is far above betting on,
[09:11]
if the president's gonna say
[09:13]
or if those aliens are
[09:16]
or not.
[09:17]
So since I'm not having a lot
[09:18]
of luck betting on the boring stuff,
[09:21]
I have an idea.
[09:22]
(screen whooshing)
[09:24]
Let's see how it works, shall we?
[09:26]
So right now the Angels
[09:30]
So as always,
[09:32]
especially when it comes to sports,
[09:33]
there's 1,000,000 different
[09:35]
the first five innings,
[09:36]
a bunch of other stuff.
[09:37]
I'm just gonna do something simple.
[09:39]
So 2.3 times payout.
[09:41]
So if I put $200 down,
[09:42]
and the Angels win,
[09:43]
I make $468.
[09:45]
Sure.
[09:46]
I guess with that,
[09:48]
well, let's see how it goes.
[09:49]
This is a lot of fun,
[09:50]
but it helps it's a good game.
[09:52]
Again. (laughs)
[09:54]
(audience cheering)
[09:55]
One inning left.
[09:56]
Right now we're at 93%,
[09:59]
so I'm feeling pretty good.
[10:00]
I'm feeling pretty good.
[10:01]
The score is five to seven.
[10:02]
It got a lot closer than it was before.
[10:04]
Okay, I'm gotta put my phone away,
[10:05]
I've gotta put my phone away.
[10:05]
I've gotta lock in here.
[10:06]
I've gotta lock in.
[10:07]
- [Announcer] On 13 is your agent.
[10:11]
- That was a ton of fun honestly.
[10:13]
I think it really
[10:16]
that I was a little bit
[10:18]
I still have somewhat
[10:20]
and Polymarket,
[10:23]
but it definitely did
[10:25]
for the way you can enjoy sports,
[10:27]
if I'm honest with you.
[10:28]
It was interesting for sure,
[10:29]
but...
[10:31]
I've gotta think on this a little bit.
[10:32]
I don't know.
[10:33]
Look, the numbers don't lie.
[10:36]
It's not just people against each other.
[10:38]
Maybe Kalshi and Polymarket
[10:40]
I mean, that's the whole legal argument
[10:42]
for why these things exist.
[10:44]
But the people you are betting against are
[10:46]
not just regular people.
[10:48]
More than 70% of users
[10:51]
and only 0.1% of accounts take
[10:56]
Just the same way you're probably
[10:57]
not gonna pick better stocks than
[10:59]
the big Wall Street firms
[11:01]
The same thing goes
[11:04]
- It's not just about kind
[11:07]
that things actually work in the world.
[11:09]
It's how these systems are applied
[11:12]
to kind of the existing
[11:14]
and the emotions,
[11:15]
and feelings that we have towards sports,
[11:17]
and the romantic idea
[11:19]
- Who could have guessed?
[11:21]
The odds are stacked
[11:23]
(upbeat music)
[11:24]
I have definitely seen enough.
[11:26]
I closed all of my positions,
[11:27]
and cashed out of Kalshi yesterday.
[11:30]
And wouldn't you know it,
[11:31]
the second I went to withdraw the money,
[11:33]
Kalshi flagged my account
[11:37]
'cause of course they did.
[11:38]
So I now need to contact customer service
[11:40]
to get things withdrawn.
[11:42]
But regardless,
[11:43]
I've already donated the $265
[11:47]
to the National Council
[11:50]
Prediction markets didn't
[11:52]
to $50 billion in trading volume.
[11:55]
They exploded.
[11:56]
Two years ago,
[11:57]
this is a niche thing.
[11:58]
But today there's subway billboards,
[12:01]
ads all over YouTube and TV.
[12:03]
I mean, we are looking at
[12:04]
two of the biggest platforms in the world
[12:06]
with valuations in the tens of billions.
[12:09]
The idea of a prediction market,
[12:11]
it's not necessarily a bad one.
[12:13]
Dr. Hanson had some of the right ideas,
[12:15]
but what Kalshi and Polymarket are doing,
[12:18]
allowing anyone to bet
[12:20]
it's just problematic.
[12:22]
It enables truly wild stories like
[12:24]
the soldier who bet on the
[12:27]
to capture the President
[12:30]
I mean, sure he got caught
[12:33]
but I think it's a good snapshot
[12:35]
of just how out of control things can get
[12:37]
when there are no adults in the room.
[12:40]
I am not gonna dance
[12:42]
The rules have essentially been abandoned.
[12:45]
The Commodity Futures Trading
[12:49]
is the federal agency that's
[12:51]
supposed to regulate futures,
[12:53]
which is where prediction
[12:55]
They're a small agency designed to ensure
[12:57]
that nefarious behavior
[13:00]
According to a New York
[13:02]
the CFTC really has been
[13:05]
I mean, there's so much here.
[13:08]
People being fired for speaking out.
[13:10]
There's only a single commissioner left
[13:12]
who used to be a lawyer for crypto
[13:14]
and prediction market firms.
[13:15]
And there's also this.
[13:18]
- Why did you guys make Donald Trump Jr
[13:20]
a strategic advisor?
[13:21]
- (gulps) We have a lot of advisors.
[13:23]
- Mm-hmm.
[13:24]
What kind of advice does he give you?
[13:26]
- So it really is again about
[13:30]
- What's his role?
[13:31]
I mean, this is the son of the president.
[13:33]
- Again, I mean, we
[13:34]
The people-
[13:36]
He has a direct line to the White House.
[13:39]
- We have a lot of advisors.
[13:40]
(speaker booming)
[13:41]
- Well, I think that kind of
[13:46]
So, are prediction markets a scam?
[13:49]
Honestly... (sighs)
[13:52]
Kalshi will let you bet on aliens.
[13:54]
Polymarket will let you bet on
[13:55]
whether the president says
[13:58]
And those bets will resolve fairly.
[14:01]
I mean, the platforms aren't lying about
[14:03]
what they're selling.
[14:04]
But these are not designed
[14:06]
to make information more freely available.
[14:08]
They might as well be casinos
[14:11]
pretending to be a financial
[14:14]
they're just growing as fast as they can,
[14:17]
because the regulator who is
[14:19]
asleep at the wheel.
[14:21]
What do you think is more likely,
[14:22]
humanity benefits
[14:23]
from the information on
[14:26]
or it all turns into Biff
[14:29]
- Hello.
[14:30]
- Hello. Anybody home?
[14:31]
Huh? Think, McFly.
[14:33]
Think
[14:33]
- I know which one I'd bet on.
[14:35]
If you enjoyed,
[14:36]
make sure to subscribe to the channel,
[14:37]
and ring-a-ling that ding-a-ling button.
[14:39]
You can check out our deep dive
[14:40]
on why AI has become such a huge problem.
[14:43]
I probably need to go take a shower
[14:45]
or something after this one.
[14:47]
"Who?
[14:48]
"The son of the president?
[14:50]
"He's just an advisor.
[14:52]
"Don't worry about it.
[14:54]
"Meh."