Manga Company Caught Forcing Ideology
45sStarts with a shocking accusation of forced gender politics in a manga, sparking controversy and curiosity.
▶ Play ClipA manga licensing company, 7C's Entertainment, issued an apology for mistranslating a series by inserting gender politics and trans ideology into a story that originally had none. The controversy resurfaced after the anime adaptation was announced, sparking debate over the character's identity.
7C's Entertainment apologized for forcing gender politics and trans ideology into a manga that had nothing to do with it.
The anime announcement this morning brought the 2022 mistranslation controversy back into focus.
The main male character who crossdresses is being called a trans icon, but the official translation apologized for this misrepresentation.
The translators involved are linked to Katrina, known for butchering translations in gaming and manga.
Reddit's r/manga community was upset with 7C's translation years ago, highlighting the ongoing issue.
The manga is a BL (boy love) story, and the speaker defends the author's right to write such stories without forced ideology.
Crossdressing does not equate to being transgender; there are distinct terms like 'otoko no ko' for feminine males.
The speaker advocates for creating a toxic environment to discourage companies from pushing politics into manga.
The mistranslation has damaged the series' reputation and sparked unnecessary drama, highlighting the broader issue of ideological interference in manga and anime.
"The title accurately reflects the content: a Western manga company apologized for mistranslations that disrespected the author."
What did 7C's Entertainment apologize for?
For mistranslating a manga by forcing in gender politics and trans ideology.
When did the mistranslation controversy originally happen?
In 2022.
0:15
What genre is the manga in question?
BL (boy love).
2:46
What term is used for a feminine male character in Japanese otaku culture?
Otoko no ko.
3:43
Why does the speaker say crossdressing does not mean someone is trans?
Because a guy may just want to look feminine, not become a woman.
3:36
What is the speaker's proposed method to counter ideological hijacking in manga?
Create a toxic environment to make it unacceptable for companies to push politics.
5:27
Mistranslation Apology
Highlights the core issue of forced ideology in manga translations.
Defense of Author Intent
Emphasizes the importance of respecting the original story and genre.
2:46Crossdressing vs. Trans Identity
Clarifies a common misconception in anime/manga fandom.
3:36Call for Toxic Environment
Controversial strategy to combat ideological interference.
5:07[00:00] 7C's Entertainment, an official manga
[00:02] licensing company, had to officially
[00:03] apologize for mistransations of a manga
[00:06] series where they forced in, and I'm not
[00:07] joking, gender, politics, and trans
[00:10] ideology into a manga that had nothing
[00:13] to do with it. This was something that
[00:15] happened back in 2022. However, the
[00:17] reason why this is relevant today is
[00:19] because the anime just got announced
[00:22] this morning. And now the main
[00:24] conversation on this is this that the
[00:28] main male characters of this story, the
[00:31] one that is crossdressing in particular
[00:33] is a trans icon. when that is so far
[00:37] from the case because even the official
[00:40] translations had to basically go out of
[00:43] their way and apologize that they were
[00:45] forcing in politics where it did not
[00:47] belong within a manga and butchering the
[00:50] original author's intentions and words
[00:52] and language just to be able to force in
[00:55] their own ideology. And who would have
[00:57] figured that the individuals behind
[00:58] this, the translators and localizers
[01:01] would be side by side with Katrina,
[01:03] which I have showed her in the past many
[01:05] times, but this is a very famous
[01:07] individual that has absolutely butchered
[01:09] gaming translations for like different
[01:11] Japanese games, but also manga and anime
[01:13] as well. So, this individual already
[01:15] knowing the translator and basically
[01:17] giving the seal of approval for the
[01:18] butchering of this series and then 7C's
[01:21] having to apologize for the butchering,
[01:23] I think really puts in perspective the
[01:24] type of situation that we're currently
[01:26] in. And so, after this colossal screw up
[01:29] that 7C's made and they basically just
[01:32] they left it to the wolves. threw the
[01:33] series to the wolves. We now have the
[01:35] entire discussion riddled with drama and
[01:39] basically misunderstanding from an
[01:41] improper translation that was released
[01:43] many years ago. And it's really
[01:45] infuriating because obviously there's a
[01:46] lot of breadcrumbs about this. I mean,
[01:48] even Reddit r/manga was outright upset
[01:52] with 7C's Entertainment's translation. I
[01:54] mean, when you have Reddit calling you
[01:56] out years ago about this, which is just
[01:58] insane. Yeah, now you screwed up pretty
[02:00] big. And I think this is incredibly
[02:02] annoying cuz this just really goes to
[02:04] show that there is legitimate parasites
[02:07] that legit are hijacking manga and anime
[02:11] and using it as a vessel to push the
[02:14] same type of politics and ideology that
[02:17] we see in gaming from the west and media
[02:19] from the west, from Hollywood, from
[02:20] Disney, from Marvel. It is absolutely
[02:23] freaking annoying. This is literally
[02:25] everything I talk about. Like everything
[02:28] I have been warning about for a long
[02:30] time now when it comes to this, this is
[02:33] exactly it. This is the damage that
[02:36] mistransations do for a series. And so,
[02:39] let's explain this. Let's really break
[02:41] this down really quick. Why this is just
[02:43] so insane to me. First off, this is a BL
[02:47] manga. Like, that means boy love. Now,
[02:49] I'm just going to outright say this. I
[02:51] don't care about boys love manga. I will
[02:53] defend it. It has a right to exist. I
[02:56] say the same thing for Yuri manga and
[02:57] anime and stuff like that. They both
[02:58] have a right to exist. If the author and
[03:01] writer wrote a Yuri story, a boy's love
[03:04] story, even a trans story, I would
[03:07] defend it. It is a story if that's what
[03:09] the author wants to write with their own
[03:10] story. That's it. But the problem here
[03:12] is is I have a huge issue when you have
[03:14] individuals taking a series and
[03:17] butchering the author's original
[03:19] intention and changing it for their own
[03:21] politics. Outright despicable. The other
[03:24] thing is is that this is already a boys
[03:26] love progressive work. It is literally
[03:28] two guys falling in love. Okay? And on
[03:31] top of that, it's that just because a
[03:34] guy wants to crossdress doesn't mean
[03:37] that he wants to be a woman. He just
[03:39] maybe wants to look feminine. There is a
[03:41] thing called, you know, uh the word the
[03:43] proper word, hopefully I don't butcher
[03:44] this, otto no that there is a word for
[03:46] that that is exactly this type right
[03:49] here. You have crossdressing as well. I
[03:52] mean it nowadays it's considered a slur
[03:54] to say but I mean trap is also an
[03:57] original weeb otaku term and so when you
[03:59] look at this type of situation it's
[04:01] legitimately insane that how anytime
[04:04] there is a character like a male or
[04:06] female character that dresses into the
[04:08] opposing gender's attire suddenly they
[04:11] are a trans person and that that's not
[04:13] how it works. It's not. There's so many
[04:15] different layers, different namings and
[04:17] types and stuff and it just honestly it
[04:19] it it it's messed up. Like it it really
[04:21] is infuriating because it's already a
[04:24] progressive manga. It it's a boy love.
[04:26] It's Yahi. That that's what it is. And
[04:28] I'm just like dude, you are absolutely
[04:32] damaging this series and already
[04:34] slandering discussion when you're
[04:36] mistransating this. I it is so shameful
[04:39] what 7C's did years ago and the fact
[04:42] that this straight up just butchering
[04:44] has now caused this series to be in
[04:47] nothing but drama. You have people
[04:48] getting community noted about this. You
[04:50] go and scroll into the comments, you
[04:51] already see people talking about this
[04:53] situation and how, you know, it is. Some
[04:55] are excited obviously, but you get to
[04:57] see just like people really uh just like
[05:00] there there's a lot of crazy stuff going
[05:02] on here. All I'm going to say is is that
[05:07] this is what I've been talking about.
[05:08] This these are the individuals that have
[05:10] been hijacking anime to forcing their
[05:13] politics and then they get upset with
[05:16] you when you call it out. And I I'm done
[05:20] with this, man. Like, as I've said
[05:22] already, the only way to counter stuff
[05:24] like this is to be just outright toxic.
[05:27] You got to you got to really just be you
[05:29] got to make a toxic environment and make
[05:31] it to where this is just completely
[05:32] unacceptable where these companies don't
[05:34] even want to touch the topic. I mean, to
[05:36] be fair, if the story was about a trans
[05:38] character, I would defend it. I would.
[05:40] Okay. What I'm saying is don't change a
[05:43] an offer story for your own ideology.
[05:46] That is and I hate that. That
[05:48] is annoying. And I hate this because it
[05:51] is the same that ruined any form of
[05:55] like media within the West and they are
[05:58] doing it to manga and anime. It is so
[06:02] annoying. It is really freaking
[06:04] annoying. And I
[06:07] Okay, I got to calm. Uh, anyways, what
[06:09] I'm going to say here, I'm just going to
[06:11] just straight up say it that I
[06:14] personally I hope this series is
[06:16] successful. I do. I think that is
[06:18] probably going to be a very cute and
[06:20] sweet series for individuals that
[06:21] probably like free and other BL type
[06:23] stories, but I feel like the entire
[06:26] discussion around this is going to be
[06:28] just absolute dog because you're
[06:32] going to have the actual real enjoyers
[06:33] of the series that like BL for instance,
[06:36] they're going to watch this, they're
[06:37] going to enjoy it, and they're going to
[06:38] have that little parasite in the ear
[06:41] basically regurgitating the
[06:42] mistransation saying, "Oh, the character
[06:44] is actually trans and all that." in just
[06:46] uh basically spreading false information
[06:48] and it's going to be just extremely
[06:50] annoying. Like it really is. But I'm I'm
[06:52] going to leave it at that. I
[06:54] Oh, dude. I'm so tired of this, man. I
[06:57] really am. Anyways, you all have a
[06:58] fantastic day or night, wherever you
[07:00] live. Be safe. Stay healthy. Subscribe
[07:03] if you enjoy my content. She be outs.
⚡ Saved you 0h 07m reading this? Transcribe any YouTube video for free — no signup needed.