[00:00]
do we need this that question hangs
[00:02]
around HBO's adaptation of the hit video
[00:04]
game The Last of Us like a noose there
[00:07]
was a tendency among a fair portion of
[00:08]
fans of the game to roll their eyes at
[00:11]
every new bit of news about this
[00:13]
adaptation because of that question and
[00:15]
grappling with that question seems to be
[00:16]
one of the main things the showrunners
[00:18]
themselves were preoccupied by do we
[00:20]
need this obviously obviously not right
[00:23]
so then why do this okay yeah Fair The
[00:27]
Last of Us was a game that was already
[00:28]
as close to a movie or a television show
[00:31]
as a video game could possibly be it's a
[00:34]
linear narrative experience and a pretty
[00:36]
much linear gameplay experience too it
[00:38]
was technically a video game but in
[00:41]
contrast to the rest of the industry it
[00:43]
was not one sold on the appeal of the
[00:45]
player getting to shape the narrative I
[00:47]
suppose you have the choice over
[00:48]
precisely how or maybe if you murder
[00:51]
each group of enemies as you progress
[00:53]
through the game but the corridors
[00:54]
themselves Lead You inevitably from
[00:56]
point A to point B you will watch all
[00:58]
the same cutscenes listen to this same
[01:00]
banter see the same ending as anyone
[01:02]
else who plays the game it actually kind
[01:04]
of melted people's brains at the time
[01:05]
because of just how much it went against
[01:06]
the grain of what so many other major
[01:08]
video game Publishers were doing in
[01:10]
2013. in an era where so many other
[01:12]
games let you do a Choose Your Own
[01:14]
Adventure pick blue for boring pick red
[01:16]
for psychopath style gameplay this
[01:18]
sequence at the end of The Last of Us
[01:19]
was legitimately surprising and that it
[01:22]
uses all of the conventions of those
[01:24]
kinds of games and leads up to a moment
[01:25]
where you expect to have a choice only
[01:27]
to not have a choice Joel kills the
[01:31]
Doctor Joel always kills the doctor it's
[01:34]
a linear experience and not for nothing
[01:36]
a good one so why do this
[01:40]
the motivation for adapting a story or
[01:42]
at least the most like pure motivation
[01:44]
for adapting a story is that you think
[01:45]
the story will benefit from the shift in
[01:47]
mediums to explore parts of the story
[01:49]
that the original just couldn't an audio
[01:51]
visual medium provides storytellers new
[01:53]
ways to enhance a story told previously
[01:55]
as a book or as a comic book music can
[01:57]
create a different emotional reaction to
[01:59]
a scene and bringing something that was
[02:01]
only previously in the realm of
[02:02]
imagination into real life can be
[02:04]
extremely satisfying but the last of us
[02:06]
was already in an audio visual media and
[02:09]
it used that Medium to its fullest or
[02:11]
rather it used it in a way that ape the
[02:13]
conventions of film the composition of
[02:15]
its shots the editing the music its
[02:17]
motion capture performances all of it
[02:19]
working in tandem to create a
[02:21]
well-crafted experience that kind of
[02:23]
feels like
[02:24]
well it kind of feels like a Prestige
[02:26]
HBO drama Naughty Dog Games stand up
[02:28]
from the rest of the video game industry
[02:29]
for this reason when two characters have
[02:31]
a conversation in a naughty dog game
[02:32]
it's either happening in gameplay or
[02:34]
it's a performance captured cutscene
[02:36]
that emphasizes the subtleties of each
[02:38]
character's emotions they never just
[02:40]
have two characters cycle through four
[02:42]
or five generic animations while the
[02:44]
player chooses from four or five
[02:45]
dialogue options that's not a criticism
[02:48]
of games that do that but an observation
[02:50]
that those games want you to feel like
[02:53]
you're interacting with the story while
[02:55]
The Last of Us wants you to feel like
[02:57]
you're watching a story The Last of Us
[02:59]
did all of this extremely well pretty
[03:00]
much better than any other video game it
[03:03]
created dozens and dozens of really
[03:05]
effective moments between characters
[03:07]
that have stuck in my mind for a decade
[03:10]
you're not my daughter
[03:14]
and I sure as hell ain't your dad
[03:17]
so if you're adapting a story like this
[03:19]
you're in an extremely tough spot
[03:21]
because you don't just want to
[03:22]
thoughtlessly Echo something like this
[03:24]
and yet the scenes are so good on their
[03:26]
own your story would be less good if you
[03:28]
didn't include them right you're right
[03:32]
you're not my daughter
[03:34]
I'm not sure as hell ain't your dad oh
[03:37]
my God they shot it from a different
[03:39]
angle
[03:40]
which means that any adaptation of The
[03:42]
Last of Us is destined to instantly be
[03:44]
cut up by the internet into shot by shot
[03:46]
comparisons The Last of Us season one
[03:48]
side-by-side scene comparison The Last
[03:49]
of Us episode 1 TV show versus game
[03:51]
comparison The Last of Us episode 2 TV
[03:54]
show vs game comparison episode three
[03:56]
four five six seven eight nine TV show
[03:58]
versus game comparison so why do this
[04:00]
and more importantly how and more
[04:03]
importantly why for a moment I just want
[04:05]
to set aside the obvious answer to this
[04:07]
which is money The Last of Us is an
[04:10]
extremely recognizable IP and any
[04:11]
adaptation of it good or bad was bound
[04:13]
to make HBO a tidy profit but that
[04:16]
doesn't really answer why these specific
[04:18]
creatives would want to be involved with
[04:20]
this Craig Mason the showrunner for The
[04:23]
Last of Us was fresh off a huge success
[04:25]
with Chernobyl a show that won or was
[04:27]
nominated for all of the awards he could
[04:31]
presumably have been part of whatever he
[04:33]
wanted to make he chose this so why
[04:36]
fungal infection of this kind is a real
[04:38]
but not in humans true true fungi cannot
[04:41]
survive if its host's internal
[04:43]
temperature is over 94 degrees and
[04:46]
currently there are no reasons for fungi
[04:48]
to evolve to be able to withstand higher
[04:50]
temperatures but what if that were to
[04:51]
change what if
[04:52]
for instance the world were to get
[04:55]
slightly warmer unlike the game the TV
[04:58]
show opens with a lengthy interview
[04:59]
scene between a TV show host and a pair
[05:01]
of doctors which in my mind immediately
[05:03]
seeks to answer the question at the top
[05:05]
of this video in the scene one of the
[05:07]
doctors outlines how a fungal pandemic
[05:09]
could be orders of magnitude worse than
[05:10]
a viral pandemic he explains how the
[05:12]
fungi could burrow into people's brains
[05:14]
and turn them into puppets handling a
[05:15]
bunch of the World building for the rest
[05:17]
of the show but he also reframes the
[05:19]
central Catalyst of the Apocalypse from
[05:21]
what it was in the game tying it
[05:23]
directly to climate change that Craig
[05:25]
Mason would do this is not that
[05:26]
surprising when you compare this to what
[05:28]
he did in Chernobyl the guest that show
[05:30]
is about telling a story around the
[05:31]
Chernobyl nuclear disaster but it's not
[05:34]
just about that it's about climate
[05:35]
change hot take guys Chernobyl had
[05:37]
climate change themes institutions
[05:38]
repeatedly ignored the warnings of an
[05:40]
environmental disaster because of their
[05:42]
own political agendas and then in the
[05:44]
midst of the crisis attempted to
[05:45]
continuously downplay how bad things
[05:47]
could get but nuclear radiation doesn't
[05:49]
care about International politics or
[05:50]
what's happening inside the Kremlin so
[05:52]
you know can we please deal with this
[05:53]
thing before it kills us all in The Last
[05:55]
of Us video game there was no
[05:57]
explanation for the apocalypse it was
[05:58]
just something that happened but I think
[06:00]
you can make a compelling case about the
[06:02]
original Last of Us that while it is
[06:03]
never explicitly stated to be about
[06:05]
climate change that it was subtextually
[06:07]
about climate change it's a game where
[06:10]
most of the settings are Urban
[06:11]
environments that have been reclaimed by
[06:13]
Nature where the main enemies are a kind
[06:15]
of fungi and where the central themes
[06:17]
are all about pitting individual needs
[06:19]
against what is good for society as a
[06:22]
whole a theme that has some extra
[06:24]
resonance when seen through the lens of
[06:27]
climate change in the show a guy just
[06:29]
says it what if the world was to get
[06:31]
slightly warmer he just tweeted it out
[06:34]
and it's in this way this method like
[06:36]
not just the scene but this way of doing
[06:38]
things that the show justifies its own
[06:40]
existence if it can't tell the story of
[06:42]
The Last of Us better than the last of
[06:43]
us already did then it can at least tell
[06:46]
the story more explicitly it can make
[06:48]
the subtext text I want to make a
[06:51]
distinction here for the kind of subtext
[06:52]
and talking about I'm not talking about
[06:54]
what we could call conversational
[06:55]
subtext so in many a well-written scene
[06:58]
in both versions of The Last of Us two
[07:00]
characters are talking to one another
[07:01]
and because they are human beings and
[07:03]
not robots when they say things they
[07:04]
don't always say everything they mean so
[07:07]
Time Heals all wounds I guess
[07:15]
Jules puppy dog eyes fill in the blanks
[07:18]
of what his words imply the text is it
[07:20]
wasn't time that healed his trauma the
[07:22]
subtext was that it was meeting and
[07:23]
bonding with Ellie that healed his
[07:25]
trauma both versions of the story have
[07:26]
moments like this which are very good
[07:28]
because both versions are very good so
[07:31]
when I say HBO is The Last of Us turns
[07:33]
the subtext of Sony's The Last of Us
[07:34]
into text I don't mean everyone starts
[07:36]
saying what they mean literally I'm
[07:38]
talking more about the themes and plot
[07:40]
points that the game originally left
[07:41]
ambiguous cordyceps mutated
[07:44]
someone that got into the food supply
[07:46]
probably a basic ingredient like flour
[07:49]
sugar example number one Joel and Tess
[07:52]
now if you're a freak like me when
[07:54]
you're playing the original game there
[07:55]
are probably a bunch of times during
[07:57]
scenes with Joel and Tess when you
[07:58]
thought to yourself they [ __ ] come on
[08:02]
make this easy for me
[08:04]
canonically the answer is probably
[08:06]
probably like probably not definitely
[08:09]
but but when you watch the show one of
[08:11]
the first times you see them together is
[08:13]
they're together
[08:17]
in the original game there was something
[08:18]
ambiguous that players wondered about
[08:20]
and now in order to give this new
[08:22]
version of the show some kind of
[08:23]
identity that is different from the game
[08:25]
but which doesn't outright contradict
[08:26]
the game the show gives a solid textual
[08:29]
answer to that thing that was previously
[08:31]
ambiguous example number two communism
[08:33]
hey isn't it kind of funny that in the
[08:35]
post-apocalypse the healthiest most
[08:38]
productive most just and safe place in
[08:40]
the entire game is kind of a
[08:42]
narco-communist like Tommy and his Pals
[08:44]
over here are communists aren't they and
[08:46]
isn't it you know doubly funny that we
[08:48]
put this location in Jackson Wyoming the
[08:51]
state with the heaviest Republican lien
[08:52]
in the country 20 years of Apocalypse
[08:54]
turned all these Macho conservative
[08:56]
Cowboys into Macau bakunan well uh in
[08:58]
the show everyone pitches in we rotate
[09:00]
patrols food prep repairs hunting
[09:03]
harvesting everything you see in our
[09:05]
town
[09:06]
greenhouses livestock all shared
[09:08]
Collective ownership
[09:11]
so uh communism
[09:13]
ah I didn't like that it is that
[09:16]
literally this is the commune we're
[09:17]
communists
[09:19]
example three David is well even worse
[09:23]
than than the game says okay so in the
[09:25]
game Joel gets injured and the player
[09:27]
gets to play as Ellie for a little bit
[09:28]
where she Encounters this guy David who
[09:30]
manages to gain Ellie's trust before she
[09:32]
learns that he and his gang are a bunch
[09:34]
of cannibals who are going to eat her
[09:35]
but there are a couple of moments in the
[09:37]
game that make you feel like David is
[09:38]
even worse than a cannibal like this
[09:40]
moment when he tries to regain Ellie's
[09:42]
trust and they hold hands or in the
[09:44]
final fight scene which can be read as
[09:45]
merely David attempting to murder her or
[09:48]
is he trying to
[09:49]
you know the fighting is a part I like
[09:52]
the most there's no fear in love oh okay
[09:55]
so he's just full-on pedophile okay got
[09:57]
it
[09:59]
example four Bill and Frank now I take
[10:01]
the master stroke of the series is how
[10:03]
they handle its queer representation in
[10:05]
the game Joel and Ellie meet one of
[10:06]
Joel's old friends a complete [ __ ]
[10:08]
named Bill Bill lives in almost total
[10:10]
isolation and has protected himself from
[10:12]
the outside world with a series of booby
[10:14]
traps in his level of the game the three
[10:15]
of them work together to make it to the
[10:17]
other side of town so that they can
[10:18]
acquire a car battery bill has exactly
[10:20]
one friend named Frank who lives on that
[10:22]
side of town but they find that he has
[10:24]
hanged himself when they get there for
[10:25]
many players it's pretty easy to miss
[10:27]
the fact that bill is a gay man because
[10:28]
that fact exists mostly in the subtext
[10:31]
of how Bill reacts to Frank's death
[10:32]
which could imply a romantic connection
[10:34]
between the two of them but can also
[10:36]
very easily be read by a straight
[10:38]
audience as just a man mourning his
[10:41]
friend
[10:42]
he was my partner but Bill squaredness
[10:44]
also exists as non-mandatory content in
[10:47]
Frank's house the player might find a
[10:49]
note from Frank to bill which expresses
[10:51]
Frank's growing resentment towards bills
[10:53]
stuck in his Way's Behavior again the
[10:55]
player needs to read between the lines
[10:56]
here to understand that this is a queer
[10:58]
relationship
[11:00]
I'm sure your friend will be missing
[11:02]
this tonight
[11:04]
the only tangible piece of evidence of
[11:05]
Phil's homosexuality is when Joel and
[11:07]
Ellie are driving to Pittsburgh and
[11:09]
Ellie starts looking at a magazine she
[11:10]
got from Bill's house which is a male
[11:12]
porn magazine in each case it does
[11:14]
require the player to think about what
[11:16]
they're seeing in order to come to the
[11:18]
conclusion that bill is gay now this is
[11:20]
all a bit
[11:23]
problematic the fact alone that Bill's
[11:25]
queerness is hidden to this degree is
[11:27]
worth criticizing and it was like in a
[11:30]
game which again was almost entirely
[11:32]
linear the one important character
[11:34]
detail that's consigned to optional
[11:36]
content or blinking you'll miss its
[11:38]
story beats being the pieces of evidence
[11:40]
that lets you know that there's a queer
[11:42]
relationship going on here at all is not
[11:44]
exactly what you'd call good queer
[11:46]
representation it's the kind of
[11:47]
representation that is slipped in so
[11:49]
that it's not noticed by most
[11:51]
heterosexual audiences because that way
[11:54]
the game avoids a reactionary backlash I
[11:56]
guess but come on is that really
[11:58]
something to worry about oh yeah I guess
[12:00]
so now arguably this moment of queer
[12:01]
representation is better than nothing
[12:03]
but the showrunner is wisely understood
[12:05]
that they had to do more than this in
[12:07]
the adaptation so in the third episode
[12:08]
of the show they raised the queer
[12:10]
subtext to queer text it's the biggest
[12:12]
narrative departure from the game by far
[12:15]
the writer's craft an entire episode
[12:16]
that is almost completely separate from
[12:19]
Joel and Ellie's Journey telling a
[12:21]
positive impactful story worry about
[12:23]
Bill and Frank falling in love with one
[12:24]
another it's a very good episode but
[12:27]
it's also a little irritating that in
[12:29]
order for them to tell a good queer Love
[12:30]
Story it seems it has to be entirely
[12:32]
sequestered away from the rest of the
[12:34]
narrative so what are we to make of all
[12:37]
these decisions in the case of the bill
[12:38]
and Frank episode the show adds so much
[12:40]
more to the story than anyone expected
[12:42]
that it sort of ceases to be an
[12:44]
adaptation of The Last of Us and more of
[12:46]
a standalone one-hour movie that happens
[12:48]
to cross over with the last of us with
[12:50]
that exception though the general
[12:51]
strategy of raising the subtext up to
[12:54]
the level of the text is pretty much the
[12:56]
only way that this adaptation is able to
[12:58]
establish its own identity separate from
[13:00]
the game but are these really ideal
[13:03]
changes I sometimes vote while watching
[13:05]
the show that I was less watching HBO's
[13:07]
Last of Us than I was reading Craig
[13:09]
Mason's PhD level thesis on the Last of
[13:12]
Us The Last of Us climate change and the
[13:14]
decay of American Community The Last of
[13:16]
Us querying the post post-apocalypse the
[13:19]
last of subtexts oh wait that's mine in
[13:21]
calling out all of the sub text of the
[13:23]
original story though HBO is The Last of
[13:25]
Us doesn't have much subtext of its own
[13:27]
all of its Mysteries are thoroughly
[13:28]
explained all of its character
[13:30]
relationships explicitly detailed and I
[13:33]
don't know it's it's fine or whatever
[13:35]
but like do we need this
[13:39]
one of the things I love about the last
[13:41]
of us is its unique World building all
[13:43]
these interesting fungal creatures in a
[13:45]
world with different factions it's just
[13:48]
a well-realized post-apocalyptic story
[13:50]
for me World building is one of the most
[13:52]
enjoyable parts of writing and if you're
[13:54]
a writer who needs a little help
[13:55]
organizing their ideas then I recommend
[13:58]
checking out World Anvil the sponsor of
[14:00]
this video World Anvil is an
[14:02]
award-winning tool set used by millions
[14:03]
of writers that helps you to create
[14:05]
store and organize the setting for your
[14:08]
world you can track timelines family
[14:10]
trees diplomatic relationships and more
[14:12]
for me the hardest part of World
[14:14]
building is keeping all the different
[14:15]
elements connected to one another and in
[14:18]
World Anvil you can link from one idea
[14:20]
to the next pretty easily it's a great
[14:22]
solution to get your next story
[14:23]
organized you can check out World Anvil
[14:25]
right now absolutely free for a limited
[14:28]
time you can also receive 40 off any
[14:30]
annual membership by using the code just
[14:32]
right 40 off wow we thanks sage no thank
[14:37]
you because using that code supports
[14:39]
this channel wouldn't you know it once
[14:41]
again that's code just right for 40 off
[14:44]
any annual membership a big thank you to
[14:46]
all of my patrons for supporting me on
[14:47]
patreon including Michael Moss Mitch
[14:49]
mcarat Zachary Gidding and dog best dog
[14:52]
if you want to help me make more videos
[14:53]
like this one then head over to
[14:55]
patreon.com just right and keep writing
[14:58]
everyone
[15:17]
[Music]
[15:25]
thank you
[15:27]
[Music]
[15:42]
laughs