[00:00]
- Can I tell you something I'm bad at?
[00:02]
I am terrible at making clickbait.
[00:05]
Up until two years ago,
[00:06]
my most popular video
[00:09]
being dropped from a dam
[00:12]
It takes off like a rocket and shoots out
[00:14]
way further than you'd expect.
[00:16]
This video was embedded
[00:18]
on literally hundreds of news websites.
[00:20]
And in its first week, it
[00:25]
but almost none of those views
[00:29]
Why?
[00:30]
Because I gave it this thumbnail
[00:32]
and I called it "Strange
[00:37]
This video is sponsored by KiwiCo.
[00:39]
More about them at the end of the show.
[00:42]
Now, I believe within YouTube,
[00:43]
I'm used as an example of how
[00:47]
As if to demonstrate just how bad
[00:48]
a title and thumbnail this is,
[00:50]
someone else re-uploaded the
[00:53]
"Basketball Dropped From Dam."
[00:55]
And within a few weeks,
[00:58]
tens of millions of views on YouTube.
[01:01]
This is when YouTube gave
[01:03]
That's the system that
[01:05]
when someone else re-uploads
[01:08]
but I still wasn't very good at clickbait.
[01:11]
So for this video, I called in an expert.
[01:14]
I wanted to see your reaction face.
[01:16]
Can you give me like a reaction face?
[01:17]
Like what's a good thumbnail face?
[01:19]
- Oh, I got you.
[01:20]
This is a thumbnail face.
[01:22]
(Derek laughs)
[01:24]
I have like 10, I go through
[01:28]
(Derek laughs)
[01:30]
And then we just take the best one,
[01:31]
I probably have like
[01:33]
and we can just Photoshop
[01:36]
That way, I don't have to do it anymore.
[01:38]
- When I started on this
[01:41]
clickbait was less important.
[01:43]
Subscribers were what mattered,
[01:45]
because most of the views
[01:47]
And videos went viral usually
[01:49]
by getting a lot of attention elsewhere,
[01:51]
like on Reddit or Facebook,
[01:53]
not due to the YouTube algorithm.
[01:54]
But once you had a big
[01:57]
well, then your next video
[02:00]
from those subscribers.
[02:01]
So YouTube would take that popular video
[02:03]
and share it with more people.
[02:04]
And so you'd get more subscribers
[02:06]
in a positive feedback loop.
[02:09]
But soon, YouTube realized
[02:12]
the best experience for the viewer.
[02:14]
They discovered that
[02:17]
from channels they were
[02:20]
less watch time and less engagement
[02:22]
with the site as a whole.
[02:24]
Plus, they knew that
[02:26]
to drive traffic to viral hits was risky,
[02:28]
since those other platforms might disable
[02:30]
the traffic at any time.
[02:32]
So they needed to make YouTube
[02:35]
They wanted people to come to YouTube,
[02:38]
see videos that interested them,
[02:39]
click on at least one of them
[02:42]
Ideally get sucked down
[02:45]
and spend hours on the site
[02:48]
The ultimate resource is people's time
[02:50]
and attention, and every platform
[02:52]
is trying to capture as
[02:56]
So, to make YouTube
[02:58]
they had decrease the
[03:01]
make it less like a podcast app
[03:03]
where you only get the
[03:05]
and more like Reddit,
[03:06]
where stuff with the most
[03:10]
But that necessarily meant increasing
[03:12]
the importance of clickbait.
[03:14]
Now, there seems to be a paradox
[03:17]
People almost universally
[03:21]
but you also see it everywhere.
[03:23]
So why is this?
[03:25]
Well, one of the problems
[03:27]
on the definition of clickbait.
[03:29]
When I google it, the top definition is,
[03:31]
on the internet, content
[03:34]
is to attract attention
[03:36]
to click on a link to
[03:39]
We could call this type I clickbait,
[03:42]
and there doesn't seem to
[03:44]
I mean, if you didn't
[03:46]
and get people to click on your links,
[03:48]
then you wouldn't really
[03:50]
But there is a second definition.
[03:52]
One that I think more people ascribe to,
[03:54]
which is something such
[03:57]
to make readers want to
[03:59]
especially when the link leads to content
[04:01]
of dubious value or interest.
[04:04]
Wikipedia says, "A defining
[04:07]
is that it is sensationalized
[04:09]
And it also talks about teasers
[04:11]
that intentionally withhold information
[04:13]
to exploit the "curiosity gap."
[04:15]
They give you enough
[04:18]
but not enough to satisfy that curiosity.
[04:21]
Here are two actual titles
[04:25]
Nine out of 10 Americans
[04:27]
about this mind blowing fact.
[04:30]
And someone gave some kids some scissors.
[04:32]
Here's what happened next.
[04:34]
I think we can all agree
[04:36]
of bad type II clickbait.
[04:39]
Now, imagine a clickbait
[04:42]
you have how misleading
[04:45]
And on the other, how much information
[04:47]
is intentionally withheld
[04:50]
Well, then these two titles
[04:54]
And these are the zones
[04:57]
At the other extreme,
[04:58]
you have things that are so
[05:02]
You could call this the dead zone.
[05:05]
Now, here is where you would find
[05:07]
"Strange applications
[05:10]
I mean, I didn't tell you
[05:13]
Now, in the middle is where you
[05:17]
But honestly, I think type
[05:20]
are so different, that
[05:22]
the same word for them.
[05:23]
Instead of type I clickbait,
[05:25]
my friend and YouTuber, Brady
[05:29]
I mean, it might sound
[05:33]
Instead of type II clickbait,
[05:34]
we could use clicktrap,
[05:40]
What's important to recognize
[05:43]
there is no one true title and thumbnail.
[05:47]
Each video could have
[05:49]
of different legitbait titles.
[05:51]
For example, how does a zero-G plane work?
[05:55]
I went on a plane that does
[05:58]
What happens to fire on a zero-G plane?
[06:01]
Now, the most enticing
[06:04]
are found close to type II clickbait.
[06:07]
I'm reminded of the infographic
[06:09]
showing that on social media,
[06:11]
the greatest engagement
[06:13]
of what's allowable.
[06:14]
But remember that everyone's
[06:17]
is different, and everyone's perceptions
[06:19]
of words and images are different.
[06:20]
So these are not clear boundaries.
[06:22]
They're actually kind of fuzzy.
[06:25]
What for one person might be legitbait,
[06:27]
for someone else, could be a clicktrap.
[06:30]
What's clear is that on a site
[06:32]
where click-through rate is important,
[06:33]
clickbait of all types is inevitable.
[06:36]
How important to a video's success
[06:38]
is the title and thumbnail?
[06:40]
- Very important. Of course.
[06:41]
If they don't click on the video,
[06:42]
they don't watch it.
[06:43]
You can't get 10 million views
[06:45]
unless 10 million people
[06:48]
So, I mean, it's literally that simple.
[06:50]
They don't click on it,
[06:52]
- So, why is clickbait everywhere?
[06:55]
Well, because it works.
[06:57]
More enticing thumbnails get more clicks.
[06:59]
Despite some people's claims
[07:01]
that they won't click or they'll unsub,
[07:03]
it's just like evolution.
[07:04]
Whatever survives, multiplies
[07:09]
If you don't begrudge
[07:11]
so it can reach the highest leaves,
[07:13]
can you begrudge a YouTuber the red arrow
[07:16]
that allows them to
[07:18]
I talked about this in
[07:21]
To be successful as a YouTuber,
[07:22]
you need to optimize two things,
[07:24]
watch time and the click-through
[07:27]
That's the number of times
[07:28]
the title and thumbnail are clicked,
[07:29]
divided by the total number
[07:32]
That's the number of impressions.
[07:34]
Now at the time,
[07:34]
this was something of a revelation for me
[07:37]
because I always thought my
[07:39]
And then a title and thumbnail
[07:41]
that adequately represented
[07:43]
But now I've realized that
[07:46]
is at least half the job.
[07:49]
This is not just because
[07:51]
get you more clicks,
[07:52]
but because better titles and thumbnails
[07:54]
will get you way more impressions.
[07:57]
YouTube has limited real estate
[07:59]
with which to show you
[08:02]
And so it's not enough
[08:04]
even if people watch all of it,
[08:06]
you also have to make
[08:08]
that gets clicked,
[08:10]
with other really good
[08:12]
That's the only way you can expect YouTube
[08:14]
to give you more impressions.
[08:16]
Now, the big development
[08:19]
is YouTube introduced real-time metrics
[08:21]
like views, impressions
[08:24]
Now, I suggested this
[08:26]
So what you can bet will happen
[08:28]
is that creators will launch a video
[08:30]
and then they'll be sitting there
[08:31]
with all these different
[08:33]
and they'll be swapping them out
[08:35]
and looking at what that
[08:38]
and then going with the one
[08:39]
that leads to the greatest
[08:42]
And this is basically what has happened.
[08:45]
Let me give you my favorite example.
[08:47]
Last year, I made a video about asteroids,
[08:50]
which I thought was really good.
[08:51]
I called it "Asteroids:
[08:54]
which is something Stephen Hawking said.
[08:56]
And people were very
[08:58]
They thought it was maybe one of my best,
[09:01]
but the performance
[09:03]
In its first day,
[09:06]
out of my previous 10 videos.
[09:09]
It was probably on target
[09:10]
for about one and a half million views.
[09:13]
So I tried different titles and thumbnails
[09:15]
like, "Asteroid Impact:
[09:18]
Or "Asteroid Impact: What Could We Do?"
[09:20]
But none of these changes
[09:23]
And then on day three after launch,
[09:25]
I changed the title and thumbnail
[09:27]
to "These Are the
[09:30]
And immediately the video
[09:33]
It quickly shot up from almost
[09:36]
to my best.
[09:38]
It now has 14 million views.
[09:42]
Nothing about the video changed,
[09:43]
just that one image and 38 characters.
[09:47]
But because of that, the video has reached
[09:49]
nearly 10 times as many people
[09:52]
And the title and thumbnail
[09:55]
what the video is about.
[09:56]
I mean, sure, there's a curiosity gap,
[09:58]
but you couldn't explain the whole concept
[10:00]
in the length of the title.
[10:02]
So if you see a YouTuber
[10:05]
this is why.
[10:07]
Because that effort can be
[10:10]
I've seen people
[10:12]
because they think the creator
[10:13]
is trying to dupe their audience,
[10:14]
get them to click on the
[10:16]
but that's not it.
[10:18]
The whole point is to get YouTube
[10:20]
to show the title and
[10:22]
We're trying to increase
[10:25]
which is heavily dependent
[10:28]
Now, a lot of my recent videos
[10:32]
There's an initial spike
[10:34]
and then a dip, and then a second bump
[10:37]
after I have figured out a
[10:40]
I change the title and thumbnail
[10:41]
and I watch the real time view graph.
[10:44]
What I'm looking for is a
[10:47]
Sometimes there's no change,
[10:51]
but on occasions, when you
[10:53]
well then, you know you've found a winner.
[10:56]
This is something all the
[10:58]
Not even Mr. Beast knows exactly
[11:00]
which thumbnail will work best beforehand.
[11:02]
Have you ever changed
[11:05]
and then the video did better?
[11:06]
- Oh, of course.
[11:07]
So everybody, I usually make
[11:10]
and then if it's not
[11:12]
we usually just swap 'em out
[11:15]
'cause the thing is like,
[11:17]
I mean, you could know if you
[11:21]
that could just predict what
[11:23]
but you know, usually...
[11:25]
Like, you can do hide and seek.
[11:26]
You don't really know if
[11:28]
and then someone walking
[11:30]
Or if you hiding a trash can and
[11:33]
So, you know, just do both
[11:34]
and then see which one interests
[11:37]
- I feel the same way,
[11:38]
but I do feel like you have a better sense
[11:40]
of this than like most people.
[11:42]
- Of course.
[11:42]
I mean, no one gets 40
[11:45]
(both laughing)
[11:47]
- But what is the point
[11:50]
If you're cynical,
[11:51]
you might say it's all
[11:53]
And while there are certainly
[11:56]
to getting more views,
[11:58]
As an educational YouTuber,
[12:00]
I think there are two very good reasons
[12:02]
for using excellent type I clickbait
[12:04]
over more straightforward packaging.
[12:07]
To understand the first reason,
[12:08]
let's consider two
[12:10]
for my most recent video.
[12:12]
I called it "The Simplest Math
[12:16]
but it's a video about
[12:18]
So perhaps a more straightforward title
[12:20]
would have been simply to call it that.
[12:22]
The problem is, if I publish a video
[12:24]
called the Collatz conjecture,
[12:26]
the most likely people to click on it
[12:28]
are those who already know
[12:31]
And the vast majority of people
[12:34]
So for them, the title is meaningless
[12:37]
and only the very curious
[12:39]
or those who really like
[12:41]
In contrast, calling it
[12:44]
No One Can Solve,"
[12:46]
about the video to everyone.
[12:48]
And this means more
[12:50]
most of whom will never have heard
[12:52]
of the Collatz conjecture.
[12:53]
So I get to teach them something new.
[12:55]
And since the video has a
[12:58]
YouTube shows it to even more people.
[13:01]
So if my aim is to increase
[13:04]
in the world by the
[13:06]
this is the way to do it.
[13:09]
The second reason we need to
[13:12]
is to support the major
[13:14]
We are trying to make
[13:17]
on every topic we tackle.
[13:19]
That means traveling to meet
[13:22]
hiring people to build props,
[13:24]
make spectacular animations,
[13:28]
We hire expert consultants
[13:30]
to double and triple check our work.
[13:32]
I don't wanna make vlogs.
[13:34]
I wanna make science
[13:36]
that put broadcast to shame.
[13:38]
And to make this possible and sustainable,
[13:40]
the videos have to get
[13:43]
And to do that, we have to make
[13:44]
the best titles and thumbnails we can.
[13:47]
YouTuber and Patreon CEO, Jack Conte
[13:49]
has talked about adjusting your packaging.
[13:52]
The idea is know what
[13:54]
what you won't compromise on
[13:56]
and that stuff goes in the box.
[13:58]
All the rest, like what
[14:00]
that's the packaging.
[14:02]
So the video is my focus
[14:04]
are the packaging that
[14:07]
so I can make the type of
[14:10]
Now, is it ironic that a
[14:12]
is to promote a true seeking mindset
[14:14]
has to experiment at the
[14:17]
in order to fulfill that purpose?
[14:18]
It is something that I
[14:21]
You know, when I did like
[14:24]
it's like, well, what probability of death
[14:26]
does there have to be for
[14:28]
Like 50%?
[14:29]
- I love how he always overthinks things.
[14:32]
(laughs)
[14:33]
He's like, is my life risked enough
[14:36]
where I can put I risked my life?
[14:38]
I only had a 9% chance of dying
[14:40]
and I need at least a 13% chance.
[14:42]
You're so funny.
[14:43]
He was the same way two years ago
[14:44]
when he asked me all this stuff.
[14:46]
I was like, "Dude, just do
[14:49]
- Yeah, I mean, obviously
[14:52]
are not good.
[14:53]
But what I realized
[14:54]
is that I don't have
[14:57]
This problem of getting the
[15:01]
well, it's a scientific problem.
[15:03]
We're just asking which accurate
[15:06]
will get the most clicks
[15:09]
And that's a problem we can use
[15:10]
the scientific method to solve.
[15:12]
So I've hired a couple
[15:14]
and we spend a lot of time brainstorming
[15:16]
and making titles and
[15:19]
For example, on Twitter and Patreon.
[15:21]
Varitasium titles and
[15:24]
not because I'm better at it,
[15:25]
but because of my team and our testing.
[15:28]
If you have ideas about
[15:30]
please get in touch.
[15:32]
The results have often
[15:34]
I mean, this video seemed
[15:37]
when we excluded the word
[15:40]
So it became simply The
[15:44]
I thought these two titles
[15:47]
but Patreon had a strong
[15:51]
What's interesting about this research
[15:52]
is that the more clickable
[15:55]
often better represent
[15:57]
Let me give you some examples.
[15:59]
One thing I didn't expect
[16:01]
the real time analytics tools
[16:03]
and allowed title and thumbnail changes
[16:04]
to affect impressions,
[16:06]
was that it would also
[16:09]
So here is an old video
[16:12]
"Why the Neutron is the
[16:15]
In hindsight, it's a weird,
[16:18]
So I changed it to, "Why Einstein Thought
[16:21]
Nuclear Weapons Impossible."
[16:23]
It's clearer, more accurate.
[16:25]
And this is what happened
[16:30]
I changed "Strange Applications
[16:33]
to "Backspin Basketball Flies Off Dam."
[16:36]
Again, more accurate.
[16:37]
And the video is now
[16:40]
Probably 10 million more views
[16:42]
than it otherwise would have had.
[16:44]
Even anti-clickbait has proven effective.
[16:47]
Here's a video I originally titled,
[16:49]
"Are Negative Ions Good For You?"
[16:51]
Which is a question nobody asked ever.
[16:55]
Now, I changed it to,
[17:00]
Seriously.
[17:01]
And here's the result:
[17:04]
One and a half million more views.
[17:07]
I think looking at these examples,
[17:09]
you could easily make the case
[17:10]
that YouTube has made
[17:13]
It has improved the clarity and accuracy
[17:16]
of my titles and thumbnails.
[17:18]
what is interesting to my audience
[17:19]
and how to encapsulate
[17:22]
and fewer than 50 characters.
[17:24]
For those of you who worry that a focus
[17:26]
on titles and thumbnails will prevent me
[17:27]
from picking challenging science topics,
[17:30]
well, I simply ask you
[17:33]
from the last year or two,
[17:34]
like the ones on Gödel's
[17:36]
general relativity, Penrose tilings,
[17:38]
the logistic map, Newton's
[17:41]
the one way speed of light.
[17:43]
Good titles and thumbnails
[17:45]
to tackle these topics
[17:48]
who have heard of them before.
[17:50]
There is a symbiotic relationship
[17:52]
between views and video quality.
[17:55]
The more views we get, the more people,
[17:56]
locations, props and equipment
[17:59]
and research we can invest in.
[18:01]
This makes the next video
[18:04]
If we can be good at
[18:06]
the ultimate outcome is better videos.
[18:09]
That is something I think
[18:17]
Hey, this video is sponsored by KiwiCo,
[18:20]
a long time supporter of the channel.
[18:22]
Now KiwiCo makes awesome
[18:24]
including big kids like me.
[18:26]
They have eight subscription lines
[18:27]
targeted at different age groups,
[18:29]
all the way down to newborns.
[18:31]
What I love about KiwiCo crates
[18:32]
is that they make learning fun
[18:33]
and something to look forward to.
[18:35]
I mean, when I pull out a crate,
[18:36]
my kids just jump at the
[18:39]
And all the materials you
[18:42]
So there's no need to run to the store.
[18:43]
You just open it up and go.
[18:45]
My kids and I just built
[18:48]
which, who knows, might be
[18:52]
Now, the big idea is that
[18:55]
kids learn about STEAM concepts.
[18:57]
That is science, technology,
[19:00]
And in addition to the project,
[19:02]
there's a magazine with a lot
[19:04]
So I think this is the best way to learn.
[19:06]
By doing something
[19:09]
it's how education should be.
[19:11]
So if you wanna try it out,
[19:12]
go to Kiwico.com/veritasium50,
[19:14]
and you'll get 50% off your
[19:17]
I will put that link
[19:19]
So I wanna thank KiwiCo
[19:22]
and I wanna thank you for watching.