[00:00]
today on the Boost we're going to talk
[00:01]
about the ab thumbnail testing and
[00:03]
whether or not you should actually be
[00:04]
using it is it hurting your views we'll
[00:07]
talk about it here on the Boost by vid
[00:09]
IQ all right J we just got a text
[00:10]
message from one of our fans here let's
[00:12]
take a look at what it says sup Travis
[00:14]
and Jen I love you guys thank you for
[00:15]
being awesome I was wondering what you
[00:17]
guys think of the ab thumbnail testing
[00:19]
feature on YouTube I'm currently using
[00:20]
it on my new video and I'm afraid that
[00:22]
it might be giving me less views and
[00:23]
hurt my potential of the video going out
[00:25]
should I just end it early and let it
[00:27]
cook it's a good question Jen but do you
[00:30]
think about this do we let it cook I
[00:32]
have strong feelings about this actually
[00:34]
because I think this came out and we all
[00:37]
kind of ran with it because we were so
[00:40]
happy and so excited that I don't know
[00:42]
if we really set guidelines for
[00:45]
ourselves as to when to use it and when
[00:47]
not to use it cuz I do think there is
[00:51]
1,000% times where you should not use
[00:54]
this one of the things is we've been
[00:55]
testing this on the main channel for a
[00:56]
while nine times out of 10 the
[01:00]
percentages are so similar that it's
[01:02]
like irrelevant right like it's pretty
[01:03]
irrelevant if you go into making a video
[01:06]
knowing in advance uh what your
[01:09]
thumbnail title are going to be then
[01:10]
they're probably going to connect pretty
[01:11]
well and unless you're doing drastically
[01:14]
different thumbnail Styles which by the
[01:15]
way is kind of what AB testing is for
[01:18]
then it's kind of pointless right like
[01:19]
otherwise what's the point it's also
[01:21]
pointless to not have two really good
[01:26]
thumbnails like AB testing is not to
[01:28]
have one really good thumbnail that
[01:30]
you're like this is awesome and then
[01:31]
just you know another thumbnail to throw
[01:34]
in there no matter how different they
[01:36]
are because you have to think about it
[01:38]
that thumbnail is still going to be
[01:40]
surfaced to people and you will lose
[01:42]
that click if it's not a good thumbnail
[01:44]
just because it's adding you know it's
[01:46]
making the better thumbnail look better
[01:49]
doesn't mean the worst option of the two
[01:51]
is not still being shown to people and
[01:53]
potentially losing that click cuz
[01:55]
they're not going to get this video
[01:56]
resurfaced you know most likely with the
[01:59]
other thumbnail than shown yeah this
[02:01]
actually came up a couple of weeks ago
[02:03]
and I had to ask V Richie about like
[02:05]
what happens if the losing thumbnail the
[02:07]
people who did not click it uh will it
[02:10]
get resurfaced and after the thumbnail
[02:13]
is decided on on the winter and the
[02:14]
answer is kind of no not necessarily
[02:17]
like it could if it eventually does well
[02:19]
it could get resurfaced to those people
[02:21]
who didn't click on in the first place
[02:22]
but it doesn't automatically get
[02:24]
retested against those people despite
[02:26]
the fact that the newer thumbnail might
[02:27]
be better so does that mean you should
[02:29]
not use it no I mean I think there's
[02:31]
instances where you might have two
[02:33]
really good thumbnail ideas and you're
[02:34]
just not sure which one to go with
[02:36]
that's a great opportunity for it do you
[02:38]
need to use it on every single video no
[02:40]
and especially if you're a smaller
[02:41]
Creator a lot of times you'll get
[02:43]
inconclusive results because you won't
[02:44]
have enough Impressions it takes a lot
[02:46]
of impressions for the process to even
[02:48]
figure out which is quote better and the
[02:52]
other thing is thumbnail testing doesn't
[02:54]
end the first 48 or 72 hours after you
[02:57]
do it the reality is you get different
[02:59]
people coming to your channel over the
[03:00]
course of weeks and months Jen uh speak
[03:03]
to that if you want to really really get
[03:07]
into AB testing then you need to have
[03:09]
like three AB tests like set up you
[03:13]
should have that initial Community test
[03:16]
set up within those first like three
[03:18]
days you should have it set again for
[03:21]
when your casual audience the rest of
[03:23]
your subscribers are seeing it within
[03:25]
that you know the rest of the week and
[03:28]
then a highly highly disc able option
[03:31]
past that time of course this means the
[03:33]
video has to be getting views that
[03:34]
entire time and surfacing for that to
[03:37]
actually make sense so we're probably
[03:38]
talking about this with um larger
[03:41]
channels not necessarily a strategy for
[03:43]
smaller Channels cuz that first one
[03:45]
probably still won't even be done but
[03:47]
when we think about what makes a good
[03:49]
discoverable thumbnail versus what makes
[03:50]
a good Community thumbnail and when that
[03:52]
video is being shown to both those
[03:54]
thumbnails look entirely different so if
[03:56]
you have a thumbnail that has your face
[03:58]
on it and then you have a thumbnail that
[04:00]
doesn't within those first three days
[04:02]
most likely the thumbnail with your face
[04:04]
on is going to win because your audience
[04:06]
knows you and they're reacting to that
[04:09]
thumbnail but that doesn't necessarily
[04:10]
give us the answer that we maybe wanted
[04:13]
for the you know longevity of the video
[04:17]
if you will I love that that was that
[04:19]
was really well explained and and again
[04:21]
nothing is definitive just because the
[04:23]
thumbnail works today doesn't mean it's
[04:25]
going to work tomorrow to Jen's point it
[04:26]
doesn't mean even that the thumbnail
[04:28]
that YouTube tells you is the best one
[04:30]
is actually the best one especially when
[04:32]
you're thinking about the videos live on
[04:33]
YouTube potentially forever majority of
[04:35]
people who ever see that thumbnail are
[04:38]
actually would maybe potentially connect
[04:40]
more with the thumbnail you didn't end
[04:41]
up even using which I think is probably
[04:43]
the case more often than not but if you
[04:45]
like questions like that and getting
[04:47]
your answers from us Jen and Travis here
[04:49]
at the Boost check the link in the
[04:51]
description where you can check out the
[04:52]
entire podcast and some other answers
[04:54]
we've given see you next time