The Secret Identity Twist in This Anime
41sThe reveal that the two women are the same person creates a surprising and engaging twist that viewers love to discuss.
โถ Play ClipThe video discusses the anime series 'Smoking Behind the Supermarket with You', which premiered quietly on Crunchyroll as 12 mini-episodes. The host analyzes its premise, characters, and the central mystery of a double identity, arguing that while marketed as a romance, the show works best as a slow, character-driven hangout series.
The anime scored 8.46 on MAL and was dropped as 12 mini-episodes without fanfare.
Sasaki (45) works at a black company and is cheered by Yamada, a supermarket clerk. He often smokes behind the supermarket with Tayama, who is actually Yamada off-duty.
The author created it as a writing exercise on Twitter, which got 200,000 likes; the manga now has 3 million copies in circulation.
Sasaki does not pursue either woman romantically; he is content simply having them in his life.
The host hates this trope because it only has two boring outcomes and prefers a different approach.
The 12 mini-episodes are halflength cuts of 6 full episodes; the series officially airs July 9th, but it's unclear if they will repeat or continue.
The host wishes the anime were just about two friends hanging out and smoking, without forced romance.
Sasaki is in his 40s, Yamada in her early 20s; the age gap feels problematic if a romance becomes explicit.
The anime replicates the feeling of taking a break and unwinding, focusing on stillness and character interaction.
The host enjoys the anime for its calm, repetitive formula and hopes it avoids romance, embracing its identity as a slow, adult hangout show. The final verdict depends on the back half of the series.
"The title is accurate and inviting, matching the video's content of a positive review and recommendation."
What is the premise of 'Smoking Behind the Supermarket with You'?
A 45-year-old office worker, Sasaki, finds solace in a smiling supermarket clerk (Yamada) and later befriends a mysterious woman (Tayama) behind the supermarketโwho is actually Yamada off-duty.
0:46
What score did the anime have on MAL at the time of writing?
8.46
0:10
How did the manga originate?
As a writing exercise on Twitter recommended by the author's editor, where it received 200,000 likes.
2:51
How many copies is the manga in circulation?
3 million copies
3:25
Why does the host hope the anime avoids a romantic angle?
Because Sasaki shows no romantic interest in either woman and is content with their friendship.
5:29
What is the host's main criticism of 'will they/won't they' plots?
It only has two boring outcomes (get together or not) and often doesn't explore the aftermath.
5:47
What is the form batch of episodes release schedule on Crunchyroll?
12 mini-episodes (halflength) that make up 6 full episodes.
6:27
When does the series officially air?
July 9th
7:03
What type of show does the host prefer?
A slow, character-driven hangout show without romantic tension.
8:48
What is the age gap between the main characters?
Sasaki is in his 40s; Yamada is in her early 20s.
10:13
What does the host compare the show's atmosphere to?
The cool-down moment of taking a break and unwinding, like going out back for a smoke.
12:00
What is the host's final hope for the show?
That the romance is just marketing hype and the show remains a simple hangout series.
15:34
Origin as a Side Project
It reveals how a small writing exercise grew into a popular manga and anime.
2:51Lack of Romantic Interest from Main Character
This challenges the romance tag and supports the host's anti-romance argument.
4:14Critique of Will-They-Won't-They Trope
Provides a clear, critical perspective on a common narrative device.
5:29Age Gap as a Deliberate Creative Choice
Highlights potential thematic implications if romance is pursued.
10:13[00:00] So, Crunchyroll quietly dropped the
[00:02] first half of a new anime series not too
[00:04] long ago. 12 mini episodes, no fanfare,
[00:08] and it's already got a score of what,
[00:10] 8.46 on Mal or did when I wrote this.
[00:13] Who knows what it is now. The show is
[00:15] called Smoking Behind the Supermarket
[00:17] with You. It's got a reasonably sized
[00:19] following behind it, and everybody is
[00:21] looking at it right now and calling it
[00:23] the best new romance of what will be the
[00:25] upcoming season. But, you know, now
[00:27] having watched this mini episode series,
[00:31] which is really just like half of what
[00:33] the actual series is going to have, it's
[00:35] slightly complicated. This is new
[00:36] territory here. Having watched it, I
[00:39] almost don't want to call it a romance,
[00:42] and I think it would be better if it
[00:43] wasn't. So, here's the general premise.
[00:46] You got this guy, Sasuki. He's like 45
[00:48] years old. He works at one of those
[00:50] Japanese companies that you may have
[00:51] heard of, black companies, the kind of
[00:53] place that like grinds you into the dust
[00:55] and overworks you to death. But the
[00:58] thing that gets him through the day,
[00:59] that gets him to survive this grind and
[01:02] working in this environment, is that
[01:04] almost every day on his way home, he
[01:06] stops by the supermarket and he gets to
[01:08] see the wonderful smile of one of the
[01:10] employees there, a young woman named
[01:13] Yamada. and she's always there, always
[01:16] smiling, and it just brightens his day.
[01:18] But on one particular night, he goes to
[01:20] the supermarket and she's not there.
[01:23] He's feeling terrible. He's not doing so
[01:25] well. And he's trying to find a place to
[01:28] smoke because there's not many public
[01:30] places to smoke in Japan. It's a thing.
[01:32] And he runs into this woman, Tayama.
[01:34] She's got a leather jacket. She's got
[01:36] piercings. And she goes to him and is
[01:37] like, "Hey, want to share this spot
[01:39] behind the supermarket where the
[01:41] employees smoke?" And so he does and
[01:43] they talk. And I would say that that's
[01:46] the show except it's kind of missing the
[01:48] key important part in that Yamada and
[01:51] Tayyama are the same person. Yamada is
[01:55] her customer service face. She's very
[01:57] polite. She is sweet. She's
[01:59] professional. But as soon as she's off
[02:01] the clock, she's back to her more quote
[02:03] unquote real self. She's sharp. She's
[02:06] teasing. She doesn't give a about a
[02:08] lot of things. And Sasuki
[02:11] doesn't realize this. It's basically the
[02:14] whole Clark Kent is actually Superman,
[02:15] but Lois Lane doesn't realize it sort of
[02:18] shindig. All of the clues that they are
[02:20] the same person are right there.
[02:22] Sometimes it feels like he clocks it,
[02:24] but it's all part of the humor that he
[02:27] never will. That's the whole bit, right?
[02:29] He puts this woman Yamada on this
[02:31] pedestal as an angelic figure that
[02:34] brightens his day and makes it worth
[02:36] living. But then also he goes behind the
[02:38] supermarket to smoke with this other
[02:40] woman. This cool stranger he's just
[02:43] happens to be lucky enough to know and
[02:45] be able to share a smoke with despite
[02:47] the fact that they are the exact same
[02:50] woman. So the whole series started
[02:51] apparently as a side project. And that's
[02:53] how I first heard of it. The author was
[02:55] working on a fantasy manga at the time
[02:57] and like his editor told him, "Hey, as a
[02:59] writing exercise, you should do just
[03:01] something completely different, a
[03:03] different genre entirely." And and so he
[03:05] did. He created this this more modern
[03:07] setting with a guy that just goes out
[03:09] and ends up having to smoke with a
[03:11] supermarket employee behind the building
[03:13] and he released it to social media on
[03:16] Twitter and then you know it got like
[03:18] close to 200,000 likes and everybody
[03:21] looked at that and it was like huh there
[03:23] may be something here and now the manga
[03:25] has like 3 million copies in circulation
[03:28] and you know now we're here with an
[03:30] anime adaptation and it's it's being
[03:32] touted as a slowburn romance and I can
[03:34] see why it would be because there is at
[03:37] least a little bit of tension there. You
[03:39] think that Yamada actually likes the
[03:42] guy. She's teasing him. She doesn't
[03:44] really She enjoys the relationship that
[03:46] they have, but she doesn't really want
[03:48] to push further. It It is that like
[03:51] almost common trope of I don't want to
[03:53] ask out my best friend despite actually
[03:56] wanting to be in a relationship with
[03:57] them because what if they say no and
[03:59] then this relationship that I have been
[04:01] enjoying just crumbles to dust. it it's
[04:03] relatable from that perspective. But the
[04:05] thing to me that shows that I would much
[04:07] rather this not be a romance is because
[04:11] Sasaki doesn't seem to actually want to
[04:14] court either of these two women. He
[04:18] doesn't look at Yamada as a oh, she is
[04:20] like out of my league. If only I were
[04:23] like a braver person or uh had my life
[04:27] together more, maybe I would propose to
[04:29] her or ask her out or do any of these
[04:32] things. But he doesn't think that way
[04:34] because he has been presented with her
[04:38] best friend as Yamada has positioned
[04:41] herself. And like if he really did want
[04:44] an inn with her, he'd only have to ask
[04:47] his new smoking buddy if a there was a
[04:51] chance, b more about her. He doesn't
[04:53] like grill her to try and find
[04:55] information about his idol. He's just
[04:58] very content in being able to come here
[05:01] and see the smiling cashier to brighten
[05:04] his day or go to the back and smoke with
[05:07] this other woman. He's perfectly fine
[05:09] with this situation and this setup. If
[05:11] there is romantic tension, it's entirely
[05:13] from her side. There is still enough
[05:16] there to have the will they won't they
[05:18] because, you know, she could confess and
[05:21] then maybe he would start thinking about
[05:23] it and deciding whether or not that's
[05:25] something that he actually wants. BUT I
[05:27] HOPE NOT. I would I actually wish that
[05:30] they got away from the will they won't
[05:31] they. Will they, won't they? One of the
[05:33] my most hated things about romance
[05:36] because as someone who says that the
[05:38] ending of any story is paramount. How
[05:40] you end a thing is very very important
[05:42] to how you perceive the entire thing as
[05:45] a whole after it is all done. The will
[05:47] they won't they only has two answers.
[05:49] They will or they won't. And that's
[05:51] really boring to imagine from an ending
[05:54] because you're like okay well they will.
[05:55] Then why don't we get there? We don't
[05:57] get there very often. We don't have a
[05:59] lot of stories that like to do the whole
[06:02] after story very much. That would be
[06:04] great if we did, but we don't. And then
[06:07] if they if they don't, if they won't, if
[06:10] the will they won't they is the won't
[06:11] they, then what are we here for? That's
[06:14] why I hate will they won't they. And I
[06:16] really hope that it's not like it
[06:18] doesn't become like the bedrock of this
[06:20] entire series. We haven't seen the whole
[06:21] series. So that's that's the other
[06:23] thing. This is a mini episode series and
[06:24] I haven't seen a show released like this
[06:26] pretty much before. So, Crunch World
[06:28] just dropped it on their service. And
[06:31] essentially what this miniseries is is
[06:33] 12 episodes, but they're all halflength.
[06:36] So, really what it is is they've
[06:37] released six episodes. They've just cut
[06:39] everything up into 12, added the OP and
[06:42] ED every time. And I'm assuming that
[06:45] when the new season starts proper,
[06:47] they're going to air it or release the
[06:50] proper episodes that are just combined
[06:54] in total. I don't know if it'll change
[06:56] or have any differences from the mini
[06:58] episode or if this is I don't understand
[07:00] this release schedule is basically what
[07:02] I'm saying because it's supposed to air
[07:03] on July 9th. That is when we have been
[07:05] told this show is airing. But I haven't
[07:08] been able to fully nail down whether or
[07:10] not airing means that they're going to
[07:11] be starting with episode 1 and then
[07:13] we're going to have 6 weeks of just
[07:15] essentially repeated content of what
[07:18] we've already seen. Or maybe what we're
[07:20] going to get is in July they're going to
[07:21] drop episode 7 and we're going to
[07:24] continue on from there and we're only
[07:26] going to go half the series. That
[07:28] doesn't make sense. A lot of this just
[07:29] feels really weird and off. I'm thankful
[07:32] that we've gotten all of this material
[07:34] early. It's quite nice. I feel like it's
[07:36] a nice little package of info because
[07:39] like six episodes isn't all that much in
[07:42] the grand scheme of things. And I know
[07:44] why the show is considered a romance
[07:47] because hey, you can't have a male and a
[07:49] female character interacting with one
[07:52] another and not hope or pray that it's
[07:55] going to go down the romantic route. But
[07:57] having not read the manga, and I'm sure
[07:59] the manga leans into it far more, at
[08:01] least past a certain point, cuz there's
[08:03] only so much of this particular gag that
[08:05] you can handle at once, uh, having not
[08:08] read the manga, I really hope that it
[08:10] doesn't. Sasaki isn't trying to flirt
[08:14] with either of these women. He is just
[08:16] happy to be in their lives and to have
[08:18] them in his life. And that's enough. We
[08:21] don't need romantic tension. I'm fine
[08:23] with the level of just comfort here.
[08:27] It's a very comfy series, even if it
[08:29] involves smoking, which is something
[08:31] that I just don't like. I know smokers
[08:34] say that you just get used to it after a
[08:35] time. And I mean the addiction and the
[08:37] nicotine kicks in eventually, but like
[08:39] I've never like being around smoking. So
[08:41] I just try to like not imagine that
[08:43] particular aspect of the series as I
[08:44] watch. I would much prefer if this was a
[08:48] essentially just a hangout show, just
[08:49] friends hanging out, chatting, having
[08:52] their own normal lives and then
[08:56] hopefully all of the romantic stuff was
[08:57] just stapled on for marketing purposes.
[08:59] I would find that much more interesting
[09:01] than a will they won't they. We don't
[09:02] get many uh boy girl essentially boy
[09:05] girl or manw woman relationships that
[09:08] don't have a romantic bent and I wish we
[09:10] had more of that. But I do worry that
[09:12] that's not going to be the case going
[09:14] forward because you know there's the
[09:16] Clark Kent problem. He's going to find
[09:18] out eventually but it's one of those
[09:20] questions of once he finds it out is
[09:22] that the end of the show is like the
[09:23] whole framework of the show. the fact
[09:25] that he doesn't know and he is able to
[09:27] interact with these two women and that's
[09:29] the bit and you know once he finds out
[09:32] we're done and then he's like oh well
[09:34] I've been friends with you now now let's
[09:36] go out let's go get married or something
[09:38] I don't know none of that seems like it
[09:40] fits these characters at all because
[09:41] like when he when he does find out what
[09:43] what happens then if the answer is
[09:45] romance suddenly this entire premise
[09:48] well not only does it disappear but it
[09:49] becomes less interesting cuz it's like
[09:50] oh okay then then they just get together
[09:52] and we're done or the does that just
[09:54] like somehow build their relationship
[09:57] further. Not in a romantic sense, but
[10:00] just like he's been essentially able to
[10:02] see two sides of the same person and he
[10:05] appreciates different things about them.
[10:07] And that could be interesting to look
[10:09] into. Not everything needs to be a
[10:10] romance. And I mean, there's the awkward
[10:13] part of the romance thing, too, cuz he's
[10:14] in his 40s. She's what, in her early to
[10:18] mid20s. The age gap is a is a bit of a
[10:21] thing if it's in the context of just two
[10:23] people having a smoke or and talking
[10:25] with one another back behind the
[10:26] supermarket. Like that's fine. There's
[10:28] no problem to that context. It only gets
[10:30] a bit dicey if you start wanting to
[10:32] shove the romantic context in there a
[10:34] bit. And it's also why I think like
[10:36] Sasaki doesn't seem to have that mindset
[10:38] in his mind at all. He probably
[10:40] perfectly clocks and identifies that
[10:42] this angel that smiles at him every day
[10:44] is far younger than he should be
[10:46] considering for an actual relationship.
[10:48] And maybe that's fine. Maybe it's just
[10:50] the marketing people that want to push
[10:53] this forward. It's just really odd to me
[10:55] because from a writer's perspective, if
[10:57] you wanted to get them together, you
[11:00] didn't need to write Yamada as someone
[11:02] in her early 20s. You could have had her
[11:04] in her late 20s or early 30s and not
[11:06] much probably would have changed. Or you
[11:08] could have had Sasuki in his mid30 in
[11:12] his early 30s to mid-30s. you could cut
[11:14] 10 years off of his lifespan and the
[11:16] show would probably still land. So, the
[11:18] age gap's there on purpose and I have to
[11:21] question why. And and I'm really hoping
[11:24] the answer is because the romance is not
[11:26] going to be a thing. But, you know, I
[11:27] bet like 50 people in the comments have
[11:29] already told me about the manga and how
[11:30] I'm absolutely wrong. And no, this is
[11:32] fine. Actually, you just don't get it,
[11:34] old man. But that's not what I like
[11:36] about it. I'm enjoying the series. I
[11:39] mean, it's kind of cliche to say that
[11:40] it's my favorite show of the next season
[11:42] because nothing's nothing else has aired
[11:44] yet. So, of course, it is, but I like
[11:46] that it's slow. I've always loved more
[11:48] slice of life, more calm and like
[11:51] reflective, and then just just like not
[11:54] narrative driven shows, but plot and
[11:58] charact, but but character-driven shows.
[12:00] Those are some of my favorites. And
[12:02] that's what this is. It's slow. It's
[12:04] deliberately slow. Each episode has the
[12:06] same general formula and it's nice and
[12:08] comfy. They arrive, they smoke, they
[12:11] talk, they leave, and that's enough. I
[12:14] don't feel like there needs to be drama
[12:16] or tension. At least not at the moment.
[12:17] We might need to get there in some
[12:20] respects just to like keep up the keep
[12:24] the interest happening because yeah,
[12:26] yeah, there are a lot of people that
[12:27] will not like it if that's literally all
[12:30] it is. And we already have that for just
[12:32] six episodes. So, the other six probably
[12:34] need to do something before the end of
[12:36] the core, but like I feel that's the
[12:39] vibe that should be maintained. They're
[12:42] both having a smoke out back at the
[12:44] supermarket. Now, he doesn't work at the
[12:46] supermarket, but if he did, like the
[12:48] action and the fast-paced and the drama
[12:50] and the tension, that's when you're
[12:51] working at the supermarket. When you
[12:53] take your break and you go out back and
[12:55] you light up a smoke, that's supposed to
[12:57] be the downtime.
[12:59] That's the the cool down moment. And
[13:02] that's what this show is. It's a cool
[13:04] down moment. It doesn't need the other
[13:06] things. We'll probably get it because
[13:08] it'll be that's what society and and
[13:10] narratives have demanded, but we don't
[13:12] need it. It's rare in anime to have like
[13:15] the focus on that stillness that um that
[13:19] that quiet downtime. It's basically
[13:21] asking you, the viewer, to sit with them
[13:24] and just be right. You don't need to be
[13:28] carried on by the plot or the drama or
[13:32] what have you. You just need to pull up
[13:34] a crate, sit on it, and have a smoke or
[13:38] not have a smoke. Get a drink. I I have
[13:40] whiskey. That's what I was doing. You
[13:42] just need to unwind with the show.
[13:44] That's all you need. You don't need to
[13:46] It doesn't need to be more than that. I
[13:48] don't want it to be more than that. So,
[13:49] the show is basically four people. I
[13:51] want to say like me. That's the thing.
[13:53] It it just these first six episodes.
[13:56] Yes. 12 mini episodes. This first six
[13:58] episodes of what the final show is going
[14:00] to be is just so slow and comfy. And
[14:04] maybe it's because I'm getting older.
[14:06] I'm in my mid30s now. So yeah, I'm much
[14:09] more likely to relate to a guy in his
[14:10] early to mid-40s than anyone in their
[14:13] younger 20s. I like having characters
[14:16] that are adult and they're dealing with
[14:19] adult exhaustion problems that teenagers
[14:22] won't have. You're not going to have
[14:24] Japanese high school students have these
[14:25] types of scenes, are able to uh relate
[14:28] in these ways. The atmosphere around how
[14:31] they act and interact with one another.
[14:33] That's the point. And it's very specific
[14:35] and we don't get it very often. Now, it
[14:37] might be frustrating to you if you don't
[14:38] like the the repetitive nature to it cuz
[14:41] again, all it is is arrive, smoke, chat,
[14:43] leave. That's kind of it for almost
[14:45] every episode. There's a little bit of
[14:47] variety there when like her manager
[14:49] finds out and is like, "What are you
[14:51] doing? Why? Why does this guy think that
[14:53] there's another employee here that
[14:56] happens to look like you do when you're
[14:57] on your time off? What What is What is
[14:59] your game here? But then she also like
[15:01] loves romance, so she's just like
[15:03] totally in for it. And maybe maybe
[15:06] that's why it's heading that way. And
[15:08] I'm like, but why though? I wanted to be
[15:10] closer to the vibe of things like
[15:11] Bartender where it's just you just have
[15:13] adult characters doing a very adult
[15:15] thing just smoking or in bartender's
[15:17] case drinking and they have lives and
[15:19] they discuss it and you're fine with
[15:21] that. You have a good evening and then
[15:24] you go home and your home can be
[15:26] whatever. That can be where you watch
[15:27] your shownen. That's fine. This is the
[15:28] anime equivalent of going out back and
[15:30] having a smoke cuz that's all it is and
[15:32] that's all I want it to be. The
[15:34] interesting thing about this show should
[15:35] not be to me it should not be whether
[15:38] these two get together. It's a question
[15:41] of does the show even need them to. Cuz
[15:44] right now we're halfway through. It's
[15:46] just a show about this quiet comfort and
[15:49] having someone to share a cigarette with
[15:51] after a bad day. That's enough. Whether
[15:54] it stays enough, well, that's a question
[15:56] for the back half of the series to
[15:58] answer. We will have to see. I've given
[16:00] you my hopes. I'm sure the manga readers
[16:03] will tell me otherwise and tell me how
[16:05] wrong and how I'm not actually enjoying
[16:07] the series properly, but that's uh
[16:10] that's for future Tristan to find out.
[16:12] So, if you want to go and watch the the
[16:13] mini episode, the 12 mini episodes,
[16:15] which will make up the first six
[16:17] episodes of the series proper, they're
[16:18] go they're over available on uh
[16:20] Crunchyroll. The manga is probably
[16:21] available from whichever app hosts
[16:23] Square Enix's content. I think it's
[16:25] Manga Up is the one that they own. So,
[16:27] you can go check that out if you want to
[16:29] read ahead. I'm not because I already am
[16:30] pretty sure I know what the answer is
[16:32] and I'm not going to be happy with it.
[16:33] Uh I I'm hopeful that I'm wrong and that
[16:36] whatever answer the show has I am happy
[16:38] with. But you know, we're going to find
[16:40] out. We're all going to find out
[16:42] together. Except not because manga
[16:44] readers already know. So So thank you
[16:46] for watching. Subscribe if you haven't.
[16:48] Click the like button if you enjoyed the
[16:50] video. Thank you to my patrons who uh
[16:52] allow me to make these videos and these
[16:54] rants and to just wish I could have more
[16:58] of this show in the way that I want. And
[17:01] a very special thank you of course to my
[17:03] patrons Rifen Bonapart Omar Showman Ross
[17:06] Emerson Hector Monttoa Aiden City Yamako
[17:11] and Geekwig. I can't do this without
[17:13] you. So however much you are able to
[17:15] help I am immensely grateful. And until
[17:18] next time, whenever that may be, ladies,
[17:20] gentlemen, and others, watch more anime,
[17:22] watch this anime, and stay frosty.
โก Saved you 0h 17m reading this? Transcribe any YouTube video for free โ no signup needed.