[00:00]
As we swiftly approach the end of November...
[00:04]
oh, as December draws so near, it's here,
[00:07]
the holiday season is upon us.
[00:09]
And, as is tradition, many people will be stringing colorful electric lights all every which way.
[00:16]
Because why not?
[00:17]
And, as is tradition,
[00:23]
brought about by scientists
[00:27]
they never stopped to think if they should.
[00:30]
But before I launch into the tirade
[00:35]
here's an actual Christmas light storage tip I learned from a teacher in high school.
[00:41]
When it comes time to put the Christmas lights away for the season,
[00:44]
don't use the tried and true
[00:46]
"wrap them around your arm like an extension cord and then shove it all into a Jewel bag" method my dad taught me
[00:51]
because that's bad.
[00:53]
Sorry, Dad, they just get way too tangled up and tend to break.
[00:57]
Instead, take a rectangular piece of cardboard
[01:05]
Cut at least two slits with one on each
[01:08]
Then, and this is very important,
[01:10]
start with the female end of a strand of
[01:17]
Now, simply wrap the lights repeatedly around the cardboard until you're back to the male end, like so.
[01:26]
[a very high-pitched rendition of Entry of the Gladiators]
[01:37]
Okay,
[01:38]
now you can either stick the male end
[01:43]
simply slide it into the other slot and you'll
[01:48]
with all your Christmas lights on them.
[01:51]
If you do it this way, you will discover that they stack nicely into boxes while remaining completely tangle-free.
[01:59]
And so long as you remember
[02:03]
they function as a decent spool
[02:10]
I am a full-on convert to this method
[02:15]
So there you go!
[02:15]
And now back to my regularly scheduled tirade.
[02:19]
You see, I am old enough to predate
[02:26]
When I was a youngin', we were still mostly shoving electricity through tiny tungsten filaments
[02:31]
which caused those filaments to get incredibly hot such that they glow with a bright white light.
[02:38]
That's just how light bulbs worked.
[02:40]
And since the underlying technology
[02:45]
if we wanted to produce colored light, we'd need to use filters
[02:50]
which removed certain
[02:55]
This had two inevitable side effects:
[02:57]
One, the filtering wasn't perfect,
[03:00]
so the colors produced, while often quite
[03:07]
It does not look, for lack of a better word, electronic.
[03:11]
Secondly, this filtering from a wide
[03:17]
reduces how much light escapes the bulb,
[03:20]
causing those colored lights
[03:25]
particularly the cooler colors on the
[03:31]
Now, I am fully familiar with that
[03:35]
"Anything that is in the world when you're born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works."
[03:41]
And while I'm sure there's some
[03:46]
the part that follows about stuff which hit the scene in your teenage to early adult years being new and exciting
[03:53]
only sort of applies to me.
[03:56]
Because you see, while I absolutely love what the light emitting diode has done to make the world better,
[04:02]
it has made Christmas much, much worse.
[04:06]
Now, instead of decorating with
[04:10]
we are decorating with horrid points of flickering
[04:20]
And not even, like, a good one.
[04:22]
Why is this?
[04:24]
Well, because LEDs are actually only capable
[04:30]
This means they produce a single and very pure color.
[04:35]
Now, when it comes to
[04:39]
Every modern white LED you'll ever see is actually
[04:46]
good old fluorescent lighting technology.
[04:49]
The actual diodes produce blue (or as is increasingly common these days) a purplish near-UV light.
[04:56]
So to fill in the rest of the spectrum,
[05:03]
and converts the high frequency light
[05:08]
which cluster together well enough
[05:15]
We've gotten incredibly good at this.
[05:18]
While cheap and nasty LEDs
[05:22]
any decent LED fab these days is
[05:29]
that produce light which is
[05:34]
And of course, we're now able to embed
[05:40]
that we can make
[05:45]
This is all innovation I'm 100% on board with!
[05:49]
And when people care, we can even do stuff like combine diodes of different color temperatures into a single product
[05:55]
for producing a fixture or bulb
[05:59]
Or, as is my favorite application,
[06:02]
automatically shifting the color temperature
[06:07]
to mimic the warming effect
[06:11]
You can build that directly into a light bulb
[06:14]
which means you can use old-fashioned
[06:19]
and you don't even need an app!
[06:21]
Philips used to shove that tech
[06:25]
but not enough people seem to notice how good
[06:30]
Even their own website filter doesn't work.
[06:33]
You people need to start caring about lighting more than you do!
[06:37]
I'll rant more about that later, but back to Christmas lights.
[06:41]
While we have had the capability
[06:46]
and while the market clearly understands that there are lots of people who want the energy efficiency and long life benefits of LEDs
[06:54]
but who also want to have the aesthetics
[06:59]
that memo just never gets received
[07:03]
Because year after year they end up putting Christmas lights on the market which look like these old ones.
[07:09]
Now, instead of taking a
[07:14]
each light produces its own wavelength,
[07:19]
but especially in the case of multicolored
[07:24]
overly bright colors which overwhelm the rest
[07:31]
while admittedly a matter of taste,
[07:37]
It's Christmastime, not the Enchantment Under the Sea Dance.
[07:43]
Now, the really frustrating thing here
[07:48]
Do what everyone already does with regular old light bulbs and make old-fashioned looking things using modern technology.
[07:58]
Produce Christmas lights with warm white diodes
[08:03]
like we used to have to do with incandescent lights.
[08:07]
For years, I was making YouTube videos where I would buy cheap warm white LED sets of Christmas lights
[08:13]
and color them by hand
[08:17]
A) this could be done and
[08:22]
I was never completely happy
[08:26]
but this was just a silly thing I did every year to hopefully prove a point and inspire someone with an R&D budget to take action.
[08:34]
And as many of you know, this is finally starting to happen.
[08:37]
A few years ago, I learned about Tru-Tone bulbs, the passion project of a designer who had the exact same bugbear as me,
[08:45]
but who actually bothered to do something about it.
[08:48]
True Tone started out
[08:53]
which actually looked
[08:57]
And they are truly great products
[09:01]
I love them.
[09:03]
But they weren't making mini lights... yet,
[09:07]
so I just kept making the same video year after year.
[09:11]
Then last year, my friend Dan
[09:15]
and these were almost perfectly argeted at me specifically.
[09:19]
This is my preferred color combo
[09:23]
and they executed the idea much better than any of my experiments could.
[09:28]
I did have a few nitpicks, but well...
[09:34]
those have all been taken care of.
[09:35]
This is a set of generation 2 Vintaglows,
[09:39]
and they are a near spot-on perfect match
[09:46]
Also of note, for those of you who would prefer the more
[09:52]
Now, I do want to point out that in a dozen sets of my Gen 1 Vintaglows, I did find one where a strand lost a section.
[10:00]
I'm sure it's fixable, and each set included some spare bulbs,
[10:06]
and I haven't gotten around to it right yet.
[10:08]
I might do that for Connextras but it'll be a couple of weeks.
[10:11]
But since so many of you know
[10:15]
I tend to be alerted to the existence
[10:19]
And this year there were
[10:23]
This puts me in a bit of an odd spot because I very much want Tru-Tone and the Vintaglow line from Merry Co to succeed as businesses.
[10:32]
But both of them are carving out a very specific niche
[10:36]
and that makes their products relatively unattainable both from a cost perspective and simply where to get your hands on them.
[10:44]
I've had correspondence with both founders now and have learned some very interesting things about the Christmas light industry.
[10:52]
It's clear that the actual creative direction which is producing these better lights is coming from them.
[11:00]
The biggest problem with Christmas lights today is that nobody at the big box stores who is in charge of ordering them for the year
[11:08]
really cares that much and simply takes whatever options the overseas factories that barf them out present to them that year.
[11:17]
But Tru-Tone and Merry Co are quite a lot more persnickety,
[11:21]
so I want to make sure they get the credit for sparking much of what has happened and I'm sure will happen in the future.
[11:28]
But I also get the sense that both of them will
[11:32]
if the broader Christmas light market gets a little less...
[11:39]
So with that, let's look at this copycat.
[11:43]
I was a little too late, as you might have been able to tell,
[11:48]
pretty far away Target to get these and the only option
[11:55]
But there now exists a Sylvania-branded
[12:01]
pretty good!
[12:03]
These appear to actually be made of glass,
[12:05]
so this is pretty much the best way to create traditional looking mini-lights with LEDs rather than filaments.
[12:13]
But the green...
[12:16]
the green's not great.
[12:18]
It's more like a jade or forest green
[12:24]
Honestly though, that's really the only problematic color.
[12:28]
This is not my favorite color combo,
[12:33]
but it's a very standard one
[12:38]
And it's a good sign that these are sold out already while there are plenty of other options still available in the store.
[12:45]
So perhaps signals will get to the appropriate people
[12:51]
And speaking of sold out copycats, I was also alerted to this vintage option for sale at the Home Depot this year,
[12:58]
which is, as far as I know,
[13:05]
Now, this is as good a look as you're going to get.
[13:07]
I would have absolutely bought a set to compare them,
[13:13]
Which I will take as a very good sign.
[13:16]
People know this looks better,
[13:22]
But while these are at least getting the concept correct, the quality of the color coating doesn't look that great.
[13:30]
The blue is extremely faded.
[13:33]
That might as well be a cool white.
[13:36]
Now, it's possible that it was a darker blue
[13:41]
but if the color was able to fade
[13:48]
For comparison, this set of Tru-Tone Jewel Tone lights
[13:55]
And now, a small diversion on nomenclature.
[13:59]
Of course I checked out my mostly Midwestern mega merchandise mecca, Menards, to see what they might have in store.
[14:05]
And I have one positive thing to say,
[14:11]
I got excited by the packaging,
[14:13]
which had been revised for 2025 and which was
[14:18]
but that was just pure lies.
[14:21]
This is the same product I got my hands on last year, though I can't remember if there was a twinkling option or not.
[14:27]
I checked the steady version and it had identical colors and their clear colored C7s and C9s are just as horrendous as before.
[14:34]
So, whoever your supplier is isn't getting the memo.
[14:41]
Or else you haven't figured out how to write that memo yet.
[14:44]
So, what's my positive thing to say?
[14:47]
Well, Menards is rolling out the term
[14:53]
And I think they might have stumbled upon a great way to distinguish between monochromatic LED Christmas lights
[14:59]
for you freaks which like that for some reason
[15:01]
and the more pleasant vintage versions I'm yearning for.
[15:06]
They need to actually get their vintage line
[15:12]
But I think vivid versus vintage is a good distinction.
[15:16]
Though I also think the "traditional glow" works well.
[15:21]
I'm starting to think a big issue with modern lighting
[15:24]
is that many people simply don't have
[15:31]
So, while they can describe something
[15:36]
it can be difficult to communicate the specific reasons.
[15:39]
A simple distinction like
[15:44]
And now, a second diversion on color combinations.
[15:48]
For this video, I checked out a different
[15:53]
Meijer.
[15:54]
For those who aren't familiar with Meijer,
[15:58]
it's essentially Walmart
[16:02]
Now, they didn't have anything really notable except they are still selling incandescent twinkling light sets -
[16:09]
branded as Phillips, oddly enough.
[16:12]
my first Christmas light video was about these things and I love them a lot, so I was happy to see them for sale.
[16:18]
And bought some, many more than two of them.
[16:22]
But then I discovered that the
[16:27]
were a color combo
[16:32]
Red, yellow, green, blue, and purple -
[16:36]
though you might call it magenta.
[16:39]
This is the color combination of my grandparents' Christmas tree, and it hit me right in the nostalgia.
[16:46]
And it also made me realize something.
[16:48]
In the past, I have said I want none of those purples or pinks.
[16:53]
But that's not strictly true.
[16:56]
I am actually completely cool with there being a fifth color so long as it's distinct from the rest.
[17:03]
That's why I don't like these sets with red, orange, and pink.
[17:08]
Those three colors are simply too similar, and it means you end up with what blurs into an orangey red mess
[17:15]
with scant pops of blue and green.
[17:18]
This combo swaps orange
[17:23]
And rather than a pink, which is simply a lighter red,
[17:30]
So, it also stands out as a separate color.
[17:34]
Here's a comparison between the more intense
[17:40]
I realize most of what I'm doing here is rationalizing a subjective opinion,
[17:45]
but I really do think it's important to have very
[17:52]
I like the red, yellow, blue, green combo
[17:58]
But the much more common red, orange, pink, blue, green has three warm colors which all just smear together.
[18:05]
This five color combo with yellow rather
[18:10]
manages to have five colors
[18:15]
and so the addition of that purple doesn't bother me.
[18:18]
In fact, I like it!
[18:21]
And since the multicolored twinkling sets also have that combo,
[18:25]
well, you know, I bought a bunch.
[18:27]
I put them in my tree this year, though,
[18:34]
There is a thin line between
[18:41]
I'll see how my opinion changes
[18:45]
So, there's really not a whole lot more to this video,
[18:51]
If you're after the sorts of Christmas lights that I am,
[18:58]
I know the folks at these companies are the reason the situation is starting to improve,
[19:04]
and they're even more persnickety than I am.
[19:07]
I've purchased products from both companies
[19:12]
Links to their store pages are in the description,
[19:18]
I'm not a very good Christmas lights influencer,
[19:21]
but I am apparently enough of a Christmas lights influencer to get the inside scoop on some new products they have in the pipeline.
[19:30]
However, once again, I'm in a bit of an awkward spot
[19:37]
I like what both of them are doing,
[19:39]
and since Merry Co focuses primarily on mini lights
[19:47]
I feel like they complement each other quite well
[19:53]
So, I will just say they both have some really cool new stuff coming which I am excited to see.
[20:00]
And if you've been afflicted with Christmas light issues similar to mine,
[20:04]
or perhaps even ones I don't have, such as a sensitivity to flicker,
[20:09]
I think it would be worth signing up for their newsletters.
[20:12]
They really are the epicenter of good nostalgic Christmas light innovation and are actually getting it done.
[20:19]
So kudos to everyone at both companies.
[20:23]
But I will take it as good news that other brands and stores are finally starting to get it.
[20:29]
Slowly but surely.
[20:32]
People genuinely want Christmas lights that look like this!
[20:36]
But you have to make it clear that it's something special
[20:42]
So many people have sent me hopeful things
[20:49]
You can't just put the word vintage on the
[20:54]
People can see what's wrong with modern Christmas lights,
[21:01]
If some actual effort is put into creating
[21:08]
But it has to be real effort.
[21:11]
These Sylvania lights are close,
[21:16]
And their white strands, while solidly above average,
[21:22]
This white is too pink and color rendering is poor.
[21:26]
Vintaglow proved last year that you can source
[21:32]
Genuinely, their clear mini lights are incredibly good and nearly indistinguishable from incandescent.
[21:38]
But it takes a lot of work to keep overseas suppliers from cheapening out just a little too much...
[21:44]
and the big box stores don't seem too inclined to do that work.
[21:48]
And now I'm going to finish this video up
[21:51]
with an unscripted section where I talk about some of my other LED-related complaints.
[21:56]
I've written down a list of things to cover, and here we go:
[21:59]
We'll start with a call back.
[22:02]
"You people need to start
[22:05]
I meant two things by that.
[22:08]
First, we are now in a place where LEDs are so good and so efficient
[22:13]
(as well as cheap to operate)
[22:15]
that overlighting your environment is very easy to do.
[22:20]
One of the reasons I don't like modern
[22:27]
No lights like this are very bright at all
[22:35]
This is supposed to be in your line of sight.
[22:37]
So, the thing you're looking at needs to be very dull.
[22:43]
And a lot of modern Christmas
[22:48]
I got caught off guard by someone who decorated way before Thanksgiving on my drive home and, geez,
[22:54]
it was like they had a billboard in their front yard.
[22:56]
That's not good!
[22:57]
But it's not just Christmas lights.
[23:00]
One thing that has also happened is I think LEDs have changed standards people have for lighting in a largely bad way.
[23:09]
I've talked about this before when I
[23:14]
we are now very used to having central
[23:20]
And that means a lot of people these days will look at more traditional lighting environments where you have things like
[23:26]
table lamps and task lighting and
[23:33]
Whereas what I think is really the case is
[23:40]
I challenge you to figure out the difference between a single overhead saucer light and a bare light bulb hanging on a string.
[23:48]
It's not actually that different.
[23:50]
The saucer light is probably a little more aesthetically pleasing,
[23:53]
but the pattern of light that it shines in the
[24:00]
And I think you would agree that's not good enough.
[24:04]
But because LEDs are now so bright, you can have enough light to see in the room with a single point of light.
[24:11]
And, uh, I honestly think people are
[24:17]
It's really bad.
[24:18]
One thing I've seen a lot of people complain about is hotel rooms because hotel rooms generally don't have overhead lighting -
[24:25]
and they might have a light by the entrance
[24:30]
I think that is actually a much more pleasant environment.
[24:33]
But again, when you're used to having a single overhead light that illuminates the entire room from the center,
[24:40]
oh well,
[24:41]
then the room can look underlit.
[24:44]
But I would challenge you to change your mindset to ask,
[24:47]
"Well, what actually needs to be lit?"
[24:50]
Here's a great example:
[24:51]
I changed the light fixture above my dining room table to this.
[24:55]
Not only because it's
[24:59]
but these light fixtures only direct light down.
[25:03]
The previous light fixture had the bulbs able to shine in all directions, which meant the room was very, very bright,
[25:11]
but it also meant I was
[25:16]
This fixture, by directing light only down
[25:22]
There's almost no light
[25:26]
That's the sort of stuff I would really encourage
[25:33]
Lighting impacts your environment so much,
[25:36]
but if all you want is enough light to see, you're probably going to end up with environments that are very harsh and very overlit.
[25:46]
But continuing on that train of thought,
[25:48]
there is a weird twist which I think has happened
[25:54]
I no longer get that hung up on people who claim to prefer daylight balanced
[25:59]
I still say "claimed to" because of what I'm about to say -
[26:02]
But I am increasingly convinced
[26:08]
(in some contexts - I'm not going to say you can't prefer it)
[26:11]
but I'm increasingly convinced that a lot of that is
[26:18]
like for example, you lived in a house which had a single boob light in the center with two 60W bulbs in there,
[26:25]
then the only thing you have experienced with
[26:33]
and if you swap those warm lights
[26:39]
So I think something that has happened
[26:45]
I don't want to say unawareness but poor awareness of the virtues of task lighting and directed lighting
[26:52]
and having more sources of lighting
[26:56]
and not recognizing that it's not the color temperature
[27:03]
it's the fact that there isn't enough light in enough places.
[27:06]
What I'm trying to say here is that
[27:13]
but it has ended up changing our expectations
[27:18]
One of the things that we still have is wattage equivalents.
[27:22]
We still look at light bulbs and say
[27:26]
And that's because it was, in the incandescent days, a fairly consistent amount of light output per watt.
[27:34]
And now that LEDs have broken way beyond that level of brightness,
[27:39]
I think it's just quite easy for us to expect
[27:45]
rather than expecting more lights spread out to have a more pleasant environment which is more evenly lit.
[27:53]
I'll just put it like that.
[27:54]
How am I doing for an unscripted section?
[27:56]
I'll tell you, I don't think I'm doing pretty great because my next thing is a thing I already talked about.
[28:00]
But to reiterate I guess
[28:03]
I really feel like people these days
[28:08]
like using additional lamps or directional light.
[28:12]
And this has resulted in a lot of overlit environments,
[28:20]
One example, there's a house that I drove by that was built in the last couple years and they've got some exterior eaves lighting,
[28:27]
like uh basically can lights in the eaves and my god,
[28:32]
they are just way too bright!
[28:34]
There's way too much light being fired
[28:39]
It does not look good.
[28:41]
But I really think more and more people are just expecting cannons of light now that the LED can do that for us.
[28:50]
But maybe we shouldn't.
[28:52]
And for another great example of
[28:56]
if you haven't already run across these, there are now really convincing LED alternatives to neon tubes.
[29:03]
And I'm talking like traditional
[29:07]
I'm a little sad for what that's doing to the neon industry,
[29:09]
but it's a lot easier to work with
[29:15]
However, so many of these products, while they look great,
[29:18]
are way too bright!
[29:21]
It's as if nobody who makes them
[29:26]
And the trouble with making it brighter is that, especially when you think of something like a neon sign,
[29:31]
the contrast is against a dark background, the night sky.
[29:36]
And if you have something with an ornate shape
[29:44]
There's a lot of new Christmas decorations that are coming out that have that sort of LED neon look to
[29:50]
And the thing is, they're so freaking bright that if you have them outside, you're never going to be able to tell what that is.
[29:57]
Like, uh, I've seen a Santa head, which is just going to look like a red and white blob from any reasonable difference*
[30:03]
They only look correctly
[30:09]
So, this is what I mean about the LED is great
[30:14]
in really small spaces,
[30:18]
And I wish more people were thinking about that as a possibility.
[30:23]
And for my last LED hot take,
[30:25]
this is something that is more vibes based than anything else,
[30:30]
I truly believe that when you have too much
[30:36]
One of the things that the LED is letting us do now
[30:39]
is create these incredibly interesting light fixtures and whole new kinds of light fixtures which are very cool.
[30:45]
But when you have that completely unlimited freedom,
[30:49]
sometimes you end up making
[30:53]
Whereas on the other hand, when we used to have to design around standardized light bulbs,
[30:59]
that led to a lot of really interesting creations.
[31:02]
And so in a sense, I am truly bummed by what the LED has done because it's now so cheap, so easy, and so reliable
[31:11]
(for the most part)
[31:12]
that we have made some really visually interesting things that just don't actually work that well as light fixtures.
[31:22]
And uh I've had this thing going on where I feel like a lot of sectors of the economy and industries etc.
[31:29]
are losing their sense of purpose.
[31:32]
And I think that the LED is a great example of that where now that we have brighter, faster, cheaper, stronger,
[31:38]
we just do that rather than thinking about what would actually be a really good application for this technology.
[31:44]
And thus explains why it's taken 10 years for
[31:56]
Yeah.
[31:57]
Okay. Well, that's the end.
[32:00]
I didn't write anything for the outro either,
[32:02]
so hopefully uh the music is fading pretty well.
[32:05]
I think we're going to do that jazzy
[32:10]
And I guess the only thing left to do is to cut the black.
[32:13]
♫ a jazz version of We Wish You a Merry Christmas ♫
[32:19]
just like I promised!
[32:20]
...and string it - shove it more appropriately.
[32:24]
[laughs]
[32:26]
...better, so long as you remember to start wrapping at the female end,
[32:31]
then they become a nice and functional spool...
[32:35]
And you'll notice on this one,
[32:40]
[angry sigh] Or did I?
[32:43]
No, I did. I just got tangled up.
[32:45]
Wait, did I?
[32:48]
No, I did not. Darn it.
[32:50]
Here, watch watch me do it again because last year me made a boo boo.
[32:58]
Which is why I am being very...
[33:02]
...I did - I did this on several of these and that is why I am making sure I point out start with the female end
[33:09]
or you will regret it.
[33:11]
They glow with a bright white light.
[33:16]
That doesn't work
[33:17]
[laughs]
[33:18]
which caused those filaments to get so incredibly hot they glew with a bright white light.
[33:25]
Glew? Heh.
[33:28]
So here's a fun fact:
[33:31]
I wrote this end-of-video captions gag in the middle of Kansas.
[33:34]
Just passed a billboard
[33:38]
This isn't what you were expecting for an end-of-video captions gag, huh?
[33:42]
Well, me neither.
[33:44]
Merry Christmas!