[00:00]
- I feel like I can't go two weeks
[00:02]
without talking about another controversy
[00:04]
around PlayStation.
[00:06]
This time around,
[00:06]
they've raised the price
[00:09]
by a dollar.
[00:11]
Wait, that's it?
[00:12]
That's just a dollar.
[00:13]
Why are we making this video?
[00:14]
And of course, just a few hours
[00:16]
after we finished filming this video,
[00:18]
Sony actually pushed the
[00:22]
So initially when they announced it,
[00:24]
they positioned it as a $1 price hike
[00:27]
on the Essential tier.
[00:28]
However, when they
[00:30]
it also came with a $2 price hike
[00:33]
on the middle and the upper
[00:36]
So everything I'm about
[00:38]
double it, quadruple it.
[00:40]
Why the hell not?
[00:41]
And the real kicker is,
[00:42]
if you're an existing subscriber,
[00:44]
there's no change at all.
[00:45]
This is just a price hike
[00:48]
who aren't subscribed yet.
[00:49]
Now, my first instinct
[00:50]
when I heard the news was that who cares?
[00:53]
But the more I thought about this,
[00:55]
the more it really started to feel
[00:56]
like something different
[00:59]
Because here's the catch.
[01:00]
If you are on a grandfathered plan,
[01:02]
that rate is only yours as
[01:05]
you never pause,
[01:06]
you never let it lapse,
[01:07]
because the second you do,
[01:09]
you come back at the new price,
[01:10]
whatever they decide to
[01:13]
This feels less like a tiny price hike
[01:15]
that we're all numb to at this point
[01:16]
and more like the beginning of a trap.
[01:18]
A very, very clever one.
[01:20]
Now, to be fair,
[01:21]
Sony has had a rough year.
[01:23]
We spent a lot of time
[01:26]
and how it is driving up the prices
[01:27]
of everything in the gaming space.
[01:29]
So Sony at this point have
[01:32]
And in March, the PS5 hit $650,
[01:36]
and the PS5 Pro was sitting
[01:40]
Sales are down a full 46%
[01:43]
and the PS5 is falling behind the PS4
[01:46]
in overall sales.
[01:47]
So under serious pressure from investors
[01:49]
to right the ship on the gaming business,
[01:51]
raising the price of
[01:54]
that you basically need to play online
[01:56]
feels like a no-brainer.
[01:57]
If you need money,
[01:58]
you have tens of millions
[02:00]
I mean gamers, who are
[02:02]
about a price hike and then move on.
[02:05]
It's almost like every
[02:08]
"due to rising market conditions,
[02:10]
we have to adjust our price"
[02:11]
as an excuse for every
[02:14]
But changing the business model,
[02:15]
or at least testing it
[02:16]
as the way they're doing it here
[02:18]
with grandfathering
[02:21]
and only charging new subscribers
[02:23]
feels like it opens up
[02:26]
Here's the analogy that
[02:28]
Imagine you're renting an apartment.
[02:30]
It's maybe not great.
[02:31]
There's a weird stain on the ceiling
[02:33]
that's been growing for a year.
[02:35]
The elevator breaks every third Tuesday,
[02:37]
and your upstairs neighbor
[02:38]
seems to exclusively play
[02:41]
But the rent is just low enough
[02:43]
that you put up with it,
[02:45]
and then your landlord raises the rent.
[02:47]
Not by a lot, just a little bit,
[02:48]
but you know it's enough
[02:50]
to maybe think about leaving.
[02:51]
But then wait a minute,
[02:53]
how much are new tenants paying?
[02:54]
Whoa, well, that's a
[02:57]
Well, you're grandfathered
[03:00]
as long as you never move.
[03:01]
Now in this scenario, leaving feels crazy.
[03:04]
'Cause if you do move,
[03:06]
for the same kind of place.
[03:07]
The landlord doesn't need
[03:10]
'cause where are you gonna go,
[03:12]
pay double somewhere else?
[03:13]
I don't think so.
[03:14]
What seems like being nice
[03:16]
is arguably just making
[03:19]
You're not paying for
[03:21]
You're paying to not lose your rate.
[03:23]
Now I wanna be clear, it's early days.
[03:25]
I think they're just testing this,
[03:26]
but I think this is exactly
[03:28]
what PlayStation Plus are doing here
[03:30]
by introducing price
[03:33]
and grandfathering existing people in
[03:35]
on their original rates.
[03:37]
Now I know plenty of people
[03:38]
who hop in and out of
[03:40]
I mean, just think about it.
[03:41]
How many subscriptions do you have
[03:42]
at any one time?
[03:44]
Probably more than you want.
[03:45]
So maybe you just want PlayStation Plus
[03:48]
for a few months.
[03:49]
Or maybe you just wanna
[03:51]
So normally it's easy,
[03:54]
save some money, and then
[03:56]
oh wait, what?
[03:57]
I have to pay a higher price now?
[03:59]
What?
[04:00]
Now, sure, it might only be a dollar,
[04:01]
but if this works, you've gotta assume
[04:04]
that they're gonna keep
[04:06]
It's a dollar more today,
[04:07]
but it's $3 more next year,
[04:09]
$5 more the year after that, right?
[04:11]
Like, you kind of see where this is going.
[04:12]
So the logical move is you stick around
[04:14]
to not lose your price.
[04:16]
You just leave that autopay on,
[04:18]
which is exactly what they want.
[04:20]
This is what's called a dark pattern.
[04:23]
(voice laughing)
[04:24]
You have activated my trap card.
[04:27]
My dark pattern card
[04:28]
will keep you trapped in subscription hell
[04:30]
for four turns.
[04:32]
I'll now place four
[04:35]
No Kuribohs Kuribohs!
[04:36]
No, not Chocobos!
[04:38]
(Austin laughs)
[04:40]
Keep it in there.
[04:41]
That was almost cool.
[04:42]
(Austin laughs)
[04:44]
- Dark patterns, also
[04:47]
are user interfaces and user experiences
[04:49]
meticulously crafted to trick, manipulate,
[04:53]
or nudge you into doing things
[04:54]
you might ordinarily not want to do.
[04:56]
Dark patterns exploit
[04:59]
like our tendency to skip text,
[05:01]
our desire to avoid friction,
[05:03]
or our fear of missing out,
[05:05]
all to benefit the company
[05:06]
at the expense of the consumer.
[05:08]
And it's not exactly new,
[05:10]
but I'll say that companies
[05:11]
are getting really, really sophisticated
[05:13]
at taking advantage of these.
[05:14]
The elephant in the room here
[05:15]
is absolutely what's been
[05:19]
So you probably remember last October
[05:21]
when Microsoft cranked
[05:23]
from $20 to $30 a month,
[05:25]
a full 50% hike overnight.
[05:28]
And the reaction was,
[05:29]
shall we say, not great.
[05:31]
Tons of subscribers canceled.
[05:33]
Xbox hardware revenue has
[05:36]
I mean, the whole thing
[05:39]
for everything that was
[05:41]
Now, I don't think Microsoft did this
[05:43]
because they're cartoon villains
[05:44]
and they're tying your credit card
[05:46]
to the train track of subscription fees
[05:48]
and twirling their mustache and laughing.
[05:50]
I mean, my understanding
[05:53]
corporate Microsoft demanded the Xbox team
[05:55]
to hit a much higher profit margin,
[05:58]
supposedly around 30%.
[06:00]
And when you can't push sales up,
[06:01]
the only lever you've got left
[06:03]
to play with is to raise the price.
[06:05]
Then Xbox hit a massive reset
[06:09]
Phil Spencer retired.
[06:10]
Asha Sharma stepped in as the new CEO,
[06:12]
and one of her first
[06:15]
Game Pass Ultimate came
[06:19]
Finally, someone did the thing
[06:21]
and actually lowered
[06:24]
But wait, hang on.
[06:25]
$23?
[06:26]
That's still more expensive
[06:28]
than the $20 price this
[06:31]
And they pulled day-one Call of Duty
[06:33]
out of the deal at the same time.
[06:35]
So while there's no doubt
[06:37]
that this is better
[06:39]
ultimately we end up
[06:42]
unless you really like that Fortnite Crew,
[06:45]
and somehow everyone is stoked about it.
[06:47]
It's a hell of a magic trick.
[06:49]
But corporate machinations aside,
[06:51]
here's the part I
[06:53]
The reason this price cut happened at all
[06:55]
is because the price hike was visible,
[06:57]
and presumably someone took a look
[06:58]
at the dashboard of
[07:01]
People could see the price hike.
[07:03]
They could complain about it.
[07:04]
They could cancel, and they did.
[07:06]
Microsoft listened kind of
[07:08]
because they had no other choice.
[07:10]
This is the way that things should work.
[07:12]
When a company pushes too far,
[07:13]
consumers should be able to push back.
[07:16]
Which brings us to Sony,
[07:18]
because I think Sony,
[07:21]
learned a very different lesson.
[07:23]
A $10 price hike?
[07:24]
What are you, crazy?
[07:25]
People hate that.
[07:27]
Terrible idea.
[07:27]
But what if, and we're just
[07:30]
what about a small hike on no one at all
[07:33]
besides "future customers?"
[07:35]
What if the price increase is so quiet,
[07:37]
it's so targeted
[07:39]
that there's nothing for anyone to do
[07:41]
besides grumble on Twitter for a minute
[07:42]
and move on?
[07:44]
Existing subscribers, we love you.
[07:45]
We're keeping your special rate protected.
[07:48]
There's nothing to see here.
[07:50]
But meanwhile, every new subscription
[07:51]
from now until forever pays more.
[07:54]
And every existing subscriber,
[07:55]
they probably think twice
[07:57]
We're just a bunch of
[08:00]
with a boil so slow
[08:02]
Now this stuff absolutely
[08:05]
The grandfather rate trick
[08:08]
Companies are just sharpening it up
[08:09]
for the modern era.
[08:10]
So back when the original iPhone launched,
[08:12]
AT&T offered a truly unlimited data plan
[08:15]
for $30 bucks a month.
[08:17]
This was back when data was expensive,
[08:19]
so it was a hell of a deal.
[08:20]
Then smartphones got really good
[08:22]
at burning through data
[08:23]
when, you know, apps were invented,
[08:25]
and AT&T realized that
[08:28]
were absolutely cooking their network.
[08:30]
Now, they couldn't just kick
[08:32]
So instead, they made
[08:36]
progressively more miserable,
[08:37]
basically not allowing you
[08:40]
without removing that unlimited data,
[08:42]
not allowing new features
[08:45]
that they actually ended up
[08:47]
And then there's the king of all of this:
[08:50]
Adobe.
[08:51]
Now this is probably worth
[08:52]
a whole video on its own,
[08:53]
but Adobe basically rewrote
[08:56]
They aggressively push everyone
[08:58]
into year-long subscriptions
[08:59]
with brutal cancellation fees
[09:01]
or even higher monthly rates.
[09:03]
They magically discover a discount
[09:05]
the moment you try to leave.
[09:06]
They crank the prices
[09:09]
that no longer has any buy-it-once option.
[09:12]
Now look,
[09:13]
Adobe have made some great
[09:15]
but at this point,
[09:16]
it's hard not to see them
[09:19]
Now take a second
[09:20]
and look through PS
[09:23]
The grandfather clause isn't a feature.
[09:25]
It's a lock-in mechanism.
[09:26]
You're not getting protected.
[09:27]
You're getting trapped.
[09:29]
And once they've got everyone trained
[09:30]
to stay subscribed continuously,
[09:33]
that's when the bigger hikes come
[09:34]
'cause then the cost of
[09:37]
Now, sure, I understand you
[09:40]
and be like, Austin, they
[09:43]
Feels small.
[09:44]
Who cares?
[09:44]
And it is small.
[09:46]
But by only targeting new subscribers
[09:48]
and making it seem like
[09:50]
the entire concept of
[09:53]
They looked at what
[09:55]
and saw the huge backlash,
[09:57]
and they found a really
[09:59]
And at the same time,
[10:01]
they're locking you in more and more
[10:02]
'cause today it's, yeah,
[10:05]
to our existing subscribers.
[10:06]
But tomorrow it's,
[10:08]
yeah, sure, you wanna cancel
[10:09]
and lose that great rate, buddy?
[10:11]
This lower tier doesn't even
[10:14]
It would be a shame if we
[10:17]
(Alex laughs)
[10:22]
(somber music)
[10:26]
- Are you sure you want to leave
[10:28]
this great rate, buddy?
[10:30]
It would be a shame
[10:31]
if we broke your PS kneecaps.
[10:34]
(beep)
[10:35]
- Look, I get that some of this
[10:38]
Components cost more.
[10:40]
AI data centers are eating the planet.
[10:42]
And as we've seen,
[10:43]
companies like Sony
[10:46]
Not every price hike is evil.
[10:48]
But the grandfather clause,
[10:49]
the "we're not raising
[10:52]
I mean, that's not a response to cost.
[10:54]
That's a tool to keep you locked in.
[10:56]
The irony here is that this is in the face
[10:58]
of the whole concept of
[11:01]
starting to feel kind of out of date.
[11:03]
Xbox is pivoting harder
[11:05]
and on PC, online
[11:09]
That's the baseline.
[11:10]
The whole reason
[11:12]
exists as a product
[11:13]
is because Sony decided years ago
[11:15]
that they wanted to get some
[11:16]
of that sweet, sweet revenue
[11:17]
that Xbox Live was
[11:21]
But the second that the
[11:22]
stops charging for online,
[11:24]
the entire foundation of this tier
[11:25]
starts to get a lot shakier.
[11:27]
I understand that I'm a YouTuber
[11:28]
making a video on a $1 price hike
[11:30]
and calling Sony out for that.
[11:32]
And you know, if you do have
[11:34]
you're not paying any extra, right?
[11:35]
This is gonna apply to new subscribers,
[11:38]
but I just wanna highlight that.
[11:40]
I think everyone can recognize
[11:41]
that subscriptions are
[11:43]
but this feels like
[11:44]
it is like sort of almost weaponizing it
[11:46]
to a new degree of,
[11:47]
not only can you make it
[11:50]
but you can make it outright
[11:52]
just way more expensive
[11:53]
It really incentivizes you
[11:55]
to stick around with things
[11:56]
that you might ordinarily
[11:59]
So it's worth keeping an eye on, I think,
[12:01]
because while it's a test right now,
[12:03]
it's just $1, I think they're kind of
[12:04]
putting the toe in the water.
[12:06]
If this works, which I expect it will,
[12:08]
this I think will
[12:11]
And I think that is a very
[12:13]
Now on that cheery note,
[12:15]
if you enjoy this video
[12:15]
and you wanna subscribe to the channel,
[12:17]
make sure to subscribe for free
[12:19]
and ring that ding-a-ling button
[12:20]
for the Austin Evans channel.
[12:21]
And if you want the deeper story
[12:22]
on the entire mess Sony is into right now.
[12:25]
You can check out that video here.
[12:26]
Until next time, my friends,
[12:29]
Maybe pause the subscription first.
[12:32]
Oh wait.