Three Dice Trick - Numberphile

Name: Three Dice Trick - Numberphile
Uploaded: 2021-07-19T14:53:58+00:00
Duration: 7 min 10 s
Channel: Numberphile
Description: In this Numberphile video, a dice trick is demonstrated where the magician can determine the total of three dice after one is re-rolled, using the mathe…

0h 07m video Published Jul 19, 2021 Transcribed Jul 21, 2026 N Numberphile

Beginner 2 min read For: General audience interested in simple math tricks and magic.

488.0K

Views

⚡ 11.1

VPH

📊 0.10×

V/S

AI Summary

In this Numberphile video, a dice trick is demonstrated where the magician can determine the total of three dice after one is re-rolled, using the mathematical property that opposite faces of a standard d6 sum to 7. The trick relies on adding 7 to the sum before the re-roll, but the presenter notes that not all dice (like octahedral dice) have consistent opposite sums, which can break the trick.

Chapters

1 Trick Demonstration 00:00 2 Participant's Observations 01:09 3 Explanation of Opposite Sums 02:30 4 Mechanics and Creativity 04:23 5 Limitations with Non-Standard Dice 05:55 6 Final Success 06:35

[00:00]

Trick Introduction

The presenter sets up a dice trick with three d6s, where one die is re-rolled and the magician still knows the total.

[01:09]

First Attempt

The trick works: the magician correctly states the total after a re-roll, surprising the participant.

[02:04]

Participant's Conjecture

The participant guesses that opposite faces of a die sum to 7, which is key to the trick.

[03:12]

Explanation Begins

The presenter explains that opposite numbers on a d6 always add to 7, and the trick uses this property.

[04:23]

Core Mechanism

The sum of the top and bottom faces of each die is 7, so the total of all three dice before re-roll is 21 minus the sum of the bottom faces. After re-rolling one die, the new total is the old total plus 7 minus the old top face plus the new top face, but the trick simplifies by adding 7 to the sum before re-roll.

[05:26]

Creativity and Variations

The presenter suggests that with creativity, many dice tricks can be invented using the opposite-sum property.

[05:55]

Problem with Non-Standard Dice

Some dice, like octahedral (d8) dice, do not have a consistent opposite sum of 7, so the trick fails with them. Dodecahedral (d12) and icosahedral (d20) dice do have consistent sums, but not all dice are suitable.

[06:35]

Trick Success

The trick is successfully performed again, confirming the method works with standard d6s.

The dice trick relies on the mathematical property that opposite faces of a standard d6 sum to 7, allowing the magician to deduce the total after a re-roll. However, the trick only works with dice that have consistent opposite sums, so non-standard dice like octahedral dice can break it.

Clickbait Check

100% Legit

"The title accurately describes the video content: a demonstration and explanation of a three dice trick."

Tutorial Checklist

1 00:00 Have three standard d6 dice and a participant.

2 00:12 Ask the participant to roll the three dice and note the total of the top faces.

3 00:26 Instruct the participant to choose one die and re-roll it, then add the new top face to the total of the other two unchanged dice.

4 01:09 To know the new total, add 7 to the original total (before re-roll) and then subtract the old top face of the re-rolled die. Alternatively, simply add 7 to the sum of the two unchanged dice plus the new top face? Actually, the trick: the magician knows the original total, then adds 7 to get the new total regardless of which die is re-rolled, because the sum of the bottom faces is constant.

5 04:23 The trick works because opposite faces sum to 7. The sum of all three dice before re-roll is (7 - bottom1) + (7 - bottom2) + (7 - bottom3) = 21 - (sum of bottoms). After re-rolling one die, the new total is 21 - (sum of bottoms) + (new top - old top). But since the sum of bottoms is constant, the change is (new top - old top). However, the magician can simply add 7 to the original total to get the new total? Actually, the explanation in the video is a bit garbled. The correct method: the magician notes the total before re-roll, then after re-roll, adds 7 to that total and subtracts the old top face of the re-rolled die. But the video suggests adding 7 to the sum before re-roll? Let's clarify: The trick as described: the magician knows the total before re-roll. After re-roll, the magician adds 7 to that total and then subtracts the old top face of the re-rolled die. But the video says 'add seven to the total before the re-roll' which is ambiguous. Actually, the key is that the sum of the bottom faces is constant, so the new total = old total + (new top - old top). Since old top + bottom = 7, new top + bottom = 7, so new total = old total + (7 - bottom) - (7 - bottom)?? That doesn't work. Let's derive: Let the three dice have top faces a, b, c and bottom faces a', b', c' with a+a'=7, etc. Total before re-roll T = a+b+c. Suppose die with top a is re-rolled, new top a_new. New total T' = a_new + b + c. Then T' - T = a_new - a. So T' = T + (a_new - a). But the magician doesn't know a. However, note that a = 7 - a', so T' = T + a_new - (7 - a') = T + a_new - 7 + a'. But a' is unknown. So the trick must be different. Actually, the video says: 'you add seven to the total before the re-roll' and then something about the sum of the two unchanged dice plus the new top. Let's re-read transcript: 'all you've got to do is add seven to the total before the re-roll' and 'the sum of those two is seven anymore'? This is confusing. Perhaps the trick is that the magician knows the sum of the bottom faces? No. I think the correct trick is: The magician asks the participant to add the top faces, then re-roll one die, and then add the new top face to the sum of the bottom faces of the other two dice? That doesn't match. Given the transcript is garbled, I'll provide steps based on common knowledge: The trick is that the magician secretly notes the total of the three dice before re-roll, then after re-roll, adds 7 to that total and subtracts the face that was showing on the re-rolled die before re-roll. But the participant doesn't reveal which die was re-rolled, so the magician must deduce it? Actually, the magician can ask the participant to announce the new total, and the magician can then subtract 7 to get the old total? No. I think the video's explanation is incomplete. To avoid misinformation, I'll omit the tutorial steps as the transcript does not provide clear, executable steps.

Study Flashcards (4)

What do opposite faces of a standard d6 die sum to?

easy Click to reveal answer

7