[00:00]
Grand Theft Auto VI has arrived, and it operates at 30fps exclusively. Rockstar's latest bucks industry trends and runs with a 30fps target on current gen consoles.
[00:14]
This has provoked some controversy online, as nearly every current gen game offers some kind of 60fps mode, even if lower framerate options are also provided. So why isn't GTA VI a 60fps game?
[00:29]
This video is sponsored by Displate. Displate makes premium metal posters offering a massive collection of metal artwork as a sleek alternative to traditional paper prints. With over two million designs available, making it the largest collection of metal artwork ever assembled,
[00:45]
you can easily find pieces for movie franchises like Marvel and DC. That fits alongside gaming series like Cyberpunk, Fallout, Boom and Assassin's Creed, several of which we've just added to Once you have your disc plate, mounting is much easier than you might think.
[01:01]
Every disc plate comes with a magnetic mounting system that installs in seconds. That means absolutely no holes and no drilling required, and you can just swap your ass around easily whenever you want to rotate your collection.
[01:13]
Right now, Displate's Black Friday sale is back. The more disc plates you grab, the bigger the discount. You get 34% off one or two prints, 38% off three to four, and up to 42% off five or more
[01:26]
Use code FOUNDLY at the link below to get the offer. The sale runs until November 30th. Check out the link in the video description below to find out more.
[01:38]
There are very few games in this generation of consoles that don't have a 60 FPS targeting mode, at least on PS5, Series X, and PS5 Pro. At the outset of this generation, nearly every single launch title for the PS5 and the Xbox
[01:53]
series machines packed the 60fps mode, which was pretty natural given that they were mostly cross generation titles. From that point, the trend stuck as developers largely maintained 60fps modes in their games. Only a handful of prominent games don't have 60fps modes
[02:09]
on current-gen consoles, including Gotham Knights, Mind's Eye, and the Microsoft Flight Simulator games. But GTA 6 has now been added to that list, and I don't think it's likely to come off it anytime soon. I think the central problem here comes down to simulation, because
[02:25]
GTA 6 is doing some pretty extraordinary things relative to just about every other crunching game. NPCs are of particular concern. GTA 6's NPCs are capable of a wide range of reactions
[02:37]
to the player, based on player actions at any given time, and critically, there are a lot of them. I saw crowds of dozens and dozens of NPCs in pedestrian-dense areas, like the airport and beach.
[02:50]
Inside clubs, NPCs are even more numerous but player freedom is limited a bit here so I not quite sure what kind of routines the NPCs might use For the most part the NPCs are likely running with the cheapest routines the engine can
[03:04]
reasonably manage. All they need to do in most instances is navigate the environment and look plausible in any given moment. That's evident when we walk through this airport. Pedestrians don't need to do too much, so they likely run simple AI calculations that
[03:19]
are literally time-sliced. but when we fire a weapon into the air, the pedestrians start sprinting away from the player, tasking their way through a tight interior and around each other, running for the exit. If we pull up some framerate graphic in the airport,
[03:33]
proceeding through the building doesn't cause any particular issue and the game runs just fine at 30fps, but the moment we settle the NPCs, the framerate dies into the 20s and stays there.
[03:45]
Calculating realistic crowd reactions from large groups of NPCs can be very taxing, The NPCs have to switch into a more advanced AI routine, and these AI routines likely don't scale so well at high crowd densities.
[03:58]
We see the same issue outside of this club. Firing into the air kicks thousands of NPCs into high gear, suppressing performance. These are obviously pretty extreme examples as most places in the game have fewer NPCs
[04:11]
milling around, but these kinds of stresses should be present any time the player causes NPCs to break out of their low-level AI states, which happens all the time. I've been showing off Series X footage so far, but the same stresses emerge on the other consoles, including PS5 Pro.
[04:28]
Sony's enhanced console runs pretty well overall, but all consoles can buckle under the right conditions. In large part that's because they all use very similar Zen 2 based CPUs, separated mostly by minor clock speed differences and memory bandwidth.
[04:42]
Physics changes also seem to cause some performance issues in GTA 6. Fast crashes are a pretty consistent way to cause momentary frame rate dips on Series X, and rampages using the grenade launcher seem to cause deeper frame rate dives than
[04:57]
we find with bullet weapons. When you blow up cars in GTA 6, a lot of physics-like bits come off the vehicle, including wheels, engine covers, hubs, and doors. Like the crowd simulation stresses earlier, grenade launcher gameplay shows the worst
[05:11]
case for performance, but this is likely reflected to a degree in practical performance constraints in some encounters and missions. GTA 6 also has to stream in some pretty high-savvy assets.
[05:23]
Just about everything in the environment has been modeled with excellent geometric and texture detail, especially for an open-world game, but unlike most games, even most open-world games, GTA 6 takes place within a modern-day urban environment, where every exterior space has
[05:39]
to hold up to the streaming demands of a fast sports car or a low-flying aircraft. The consoles do have some advantages here. All current gen home consoles have very fast SSDs for instance which can load gigabytes per second of data with no seek times Prior GTA games have been designed around slow spinning hard drives or glacial game discs which put hard limits on the assets Rockstar could use The Series X
[06:03]
PS5, and PS3 Pro also have a pretty generous 16GB of memory, which means reasonably detailed assets can remain in memory for longer if needed, and the car also has activated decompression blocks,
[06:15]
which helps to ease CPU load. But the console's aged Zen 2 CPUs are still responsible for some key streaming tasks, which is perhaps reflected in performance slowdowns when accelerating at speed. Granted, these issues are much more severe on the Memory Star series S,
[06:30]
but other consoles do drop frames when driving quickly. Fast traversal could reflect CPU-domed issues with the management and acceleration of ray tracing as well. Coordinating updates to the ray-trace scene can involve substantial CPU
[06:44]
work and that goes doubly for a game like Grand Theft Auto. There's a high density of objects in the world and large groups of generated pedestrians. And they need to update in a world where the player has access to a jet plane or luxury sports car that can travel at lightning
[06:58]
speed. I suspect this has a high CPU cost, and that's all just based on my own intuition. Alex tested the PC GTA V enhanced edition last year and found that mainstream CPUs like the Ryzen 5 3600 struggle to hit 60fps in fast reversal with ray tracing turned on. That CPU
[07:17]
CPU in particular often offers a close match for CPU-limited console performance, so it stands to reason that similar ray tracing techniques, applied to a much more sophisticated world, would also preclude 60fps performance.
[07:30]
But CPUs aren't the only limit here. There's also GPU-bound performance. GTX's sumptuous visuals do come at a cost. Rockstar is ordering a smorgasbord of expensive graphics tech here, including RTGI, RT Reflections,
[07:43]
and Strain-based hair. The RTGI and RT reflections are excellent, but the strand-based hair offers exceptional quality with unprecedented application, as pedestrian seems to widely employ the strand hair technique.
[07:55]
Here, though, I'm a bit more optimistic about the potential for scaling. Part of that is because graphics are inherently scalable, resolutions can be tweaked, techniques can be altered or removed, and the game will often still play and look in blood, so it's
[08:10]
how it should. the PU side, concessions are usually harder to manage and sometimes will demand immediate gameplay impacts. Plus, we have an example already of how GTA 6 looks when it is scaled to a much less generous
[08:24]
performance target. GTA 6 has a Series S version running on a console with less than half the GPU compute of PS5 and Series X. There are significant visual concessions in that machine, but the game still looks unmistakably
[08:38]
like its bigger console brethren. the Series S visual preset would likely provide a good template for 60fps performance on the GPU side for the big consoles, if Rockstar decided to go that route.
[08:50]
But the CPU constraints to 60fps gameplay are more or less baked in and can be removed without dramatically altering the game itself There one final option for Rockstar though that could genuinely create a 60fps update
[09:04]
– frame generation. I've used an optical flow process to simulate what this might look like, using my existing Series X capture. In some respects, I find this easier to watch and engage with than the game at 30fps.
[09:17]
60fps is easier for the human visual system to track and make sense of, without the broad discontinuities created by 30fps motion. The problem here is twofold. Firstly, the animation deltas between 33ms frames are pretty large, so any current frame
[09:33]
gen process will produce significant artifacts. That's certainly true of FSL3FG, which would be the likely frame gen solution of choice on consoles. Input lag is the other key concern.
[09:45]
GTA 6 is already one of the laggier current gen titles out there, with end-to-end input lag in the range of 180ms or so on a Series X console with my setup. Adding what would likely be an additional frame of latency would make the game substantially
[10:01]
harder to control and would feel pretty odd at a 60fps update. So could GTA 6 run at 60fps on consoles? Within current technology and programming paradigms, I think it would be very challenging.
[10:13]
GTA 6 seems to be CPU limited to a substantial degree in its 30fps colorful update, which is the worst case scenario for a potential optimization push to 60. I don't think Rockstar has been a seed to blear here.
[10:26]
I think they have created a game world that is genuinely challenging to run as a faster clip. I'm also doubtful that the upcoming PC version of GTA 6 will be able to run at the perfectly consistent 60fps on decent kit.
[10:39]
PC-to-CPUs released in the past few years are pretty good, but achieving even 200% of console performance isn't going to be enough to clear 60fps, in the game's heavier scenes at least,
[10:51]
which we suspect are largely CPU-limited. But I think GTA 6's performance profile is less something to overcome and more something to accept. By a lot of metrics, this is the biggest,
[11:03]
most ambitious game ever created. Even though 60fps has become the standard this generation, surely, in some cases, there has to be room for the occasional 30 FPS game, in situations
[11:15]
where technical realities justify this slower update. In my view, GTA 6 is that game. It's the ultimate AAA title, built to an outstanding technical and artistic standard, with a ridiculously large and deep open-world environment.
[11:30]
I'm not keen on 30 FPS in general for current-gen culture titles, but this is a game that would be challenging to achieve at a faster update. If you enjoyed this video, please like, subscribe, and press the bell for YouTube notifications.
[11:43]
Check out the Patreon at patreon.com slash digitalfoundry for exclusive and early access content, and to get in touch with your social media.