[00:00]
A team of physicists claim they have found evidence for extra dimensions in data from the Large Hadron Collider. If they’re right, this would be one of the biggest discoveries in physics in decades. Let’s have a look.
[00:14]
The new paper comes from two physicists in France and is an analysis of data collected at CMS that is one of the detectors at CERN’s Large Hadron Collider, LHC for short. The LHC
[00:26]
collides protons at a centre-of-mass energy of several teraelectronvolts which is still the world record. If these protons slam into each other, they create new particles. And since the energy is so high, this might create particles that no one has ever seen before.
[00:43]
The CMS experiment is basically a gigantic collection of sensitive measurement devices interested in collisions that produce what is called “jets”. For particle physicists,
[00:57]
a jet is a spray of particles that appears when an energetic quark or gluon emerges from a collision. Quarks are the constituents of protons and neutrons, and gluons are the particles that hold quarks together. By measuring the energy and direction of these sprays,
[01:14]
physicists can reconstruct the masses of heavier particles that might have produced them. Fun fact: I know someone who sat at an airport working on slides about “collisions” and “jets” and nuclear physics, and was asked to please step
[01:29]
aside into a small room for some questions. True story. But back to the extra dimensions. That the Large Hadron Collider might find evidence for additional dimensions of space was one of the
[01:41]
most exciting prospects when I was a student. Indeed it’s what I wrote my PhD thesis about. You see, the relation is that if there are additional dimensions of space, they must be small, they must be curled up to a small radius. And then the wavelengths
[01:57]
of the particles must fit into the radius. This would mean that every particle that enters the extra dimensions has higher harmonics, standing waves in the extra dimensions. And the higher the harmonics, the higher the energy of the particles.
[02:12]
These physicists now say that the Large Hadron Collider has seen heavy versions of gluons with masses of about 3.6 and 8.6 teraelectronvolts. These
[02:24]
decay into heavier versions of quarks. And these then decay into these jets. They have found evidence for this in data collected by CMS between 2016 and 2018. In that run, CMS saw two particularly interesting events.
[02:39]
Each produced four jets with a very high combined mass. You can see the suspicious events here in this figure. It’s the two dots up here. They say that, depending on how you look at it,
[02:51]
they stand out at 3.6 to 4σ. So that falls short of the 5σ discovery threshold, but it is more than just a little odd. They say that the data from CMS Run 3 could cross the discovery threshold.
[03:04]
Their analysis is quite interesting because it is not just any sort of extra dimension they find. They find evidence for what is specifically called the Randall-Sundrum scenario. In this case there is only one extra dimension, and it has a cosmological constant. In the Randall-Sundrum
[03:20]
scenario the masses of the particles are not equally spaced, and that fits the data best. But, there are some problems with this analysis. First, the CMS Run 3 data is already out and they
[03:32]
have seen no further of these jets. Second, the idea of heavy gluons decaying into heavy quarks is contradicted by other data. The authors acknowledge this problem but basically just say, well, then the extra dimension is somehow more complicated. Third,
[03:47]
the authors claimed last year to have seen evidence for heavier versions of gravitons, that are hypothetical particles that would carry the gravitational force. That turned out to be a composite particle of a top and an antitop quark. So these
[04:01]
guys clearly are not accounting very well for standard physics in the first place. This is why, I am sorry, but I give this a 9 out of 10 on the bullshit meter. I don’t doubt that these events exist or that they are odd, but I do not for a second buy the extra dimension story.
[04:19]
What I think is going on here instead is that particle physicists are desperately searching for something, anything, interesting in the data that could justify building a bigger collider.
[04:31]
there was a time in my life when I didn’t think all this extra dimensional stuff is bullshit. My reasoning at the time was basically, well, we don’t know why space has 3 dimensions,
[04:44]
so then maybe it actually isn’t 3. Seems worth checking. Today I look at this entirely differently. A scientific hypothesis must be necessary in the first place. You cannot just invent maths and then forever claim that one day one might be able to test it. It’s
[05:00]
obviously a strategy that can’t work, and that, as a matter of fact, does not work. That said, I spent years studying dimensions that don’t exist. But this, as it turns out, was excellent preparation for the academic job market.
[05:15]
In September, a dark web marketplace claimed to be selling scans of more than 150 million drivers licenses. Oh yes, that's a thing. According to the FBI, Americans lost nearly $21 billion to cyber
[05:31]
crime last year. The reason is that AI is making scams better and most security tools are limping behind. Today's sponsor, Coveron, will help you stay ahead. Coveron is a service by Nord Security
[05:44]
that'll scan the dark web for your personal data, email, phone number, credit card numbers, and more. They also have an eye on your accounts and monitor them for any suspicious changes. And
[05:56]
if something doesn't look right, they don't just alert you. They'll also help you deal with the problem, not through some AI bot, but by connecting you with real experts. And their
[06:08]
coverage also includes insurance against financial losses. Scams or online fraud, for example, are covered up to $100,000. They also have family and couples plans. If you're
[06:20]
in the United States, you'll get 71% off this Black Friday. All you need to do is use my link coveron.com/sabinenews and the code sabinenews. Stay safe. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.