[00:00]
Climate sceptics have been raising the alarm about a scientific scandal. David Zaruk, a retired professor for science communication, has called it “Climate Science’s Fatal Mistake.”
[00:12]
Roger Pielke, a political scientist and former professor, called it a “scandal” that “is just the tip of the iceberg.” Various commentators have called it “an organized crime,” “a felony,” “coup d'état,” and atmospheric scientist Judith Curry called it “Worse than climategate” and next week
[00:30]
they’ll call for NATO to intervene. So today we’re going to have a look at what this is all about. This stink has been raised after the US American National Academies of Sciences, NAS for short, released a report about extreme event attribution in July. That’s the idea that
[00:47]
one can quantify how much more likely climate change made a disastrous event like a flood, sue fossil fuel companies or governments for their failure to stop climate change.
[01:01]
The issue the sceptics have is only superficially about the report itself. Mostly their issue is that many scientists involved in this event attribution are openly striving to pursue
[01:13]
legal action. This isn’t much of a secret. Myles Allen, who came up with the very idea of event attribution in 2003, literally has it in the title of his paper which reads “Liability for
[01:25]
Climate Change.” Friederike Otto, who, I believe, was a postdoc of Allen, later went to join the World Weather Attribution Centre, has openly said in an interview with E&E that, quote “she talks
[01:37]
‘a lot with lawyers’ about how attribution science could be used as a litigation tool.” And if you look at the report from the National Academy, it’s been authored by a select group of 14 scientists. Several of them have known ties to the World Weather
[01:55]
Attribution staff or legislation effort. The report received funding, among others, from the Bezos Earth Fund, which also supports the World Weather Attribution business. This is why Zaruk calls it the “Climate Attribution Cabal,” Pielke writes “it would
[02:12]
be fair to ask whether the NAS Attribution committee is about science advice at all, or instead, a not-so-subtle form of institutionalized stealth advocacy in support of climate litigation,” and Steven Koonin writes that the NAS “spins an illusion
[02:27]
of elite scientific consensus.” Tim Gallaudet, a retired admiral and oceanographer who served in the Trump administration, says “The new report strays even further from objectivity” than a
[02:40]
previous report that he didn’t like either. And twenty-five Republican state attorneys general have demanded an investigation of the NAS for their lack of objectivity. I had a look at the report, and I understand why these people are unhappy.
[02:56]
It’s not that the report is outright wrong. It’s that it’s a masterpiece of avoidance. The extreme event attribution business basically works like this. You take a specific extreme
[03:08]
weather event, quantify it in some way, and take a bunch of climate models. You run the models once with and once without global warming and compare the probabilities, basically.
[03:20]
This gives you an idea of how much climate change has contributed to the event. Maybe. The first problem is that you have to assume that the main difference comes from global warming. You can read this in a paper from Otto and collaborators, where they say “It
[03:36]
is assumed that the main changes in the distribution are due to global warming.” But often there are many other factors that contribute, sometimes significantly. For example, wildfire risk also depends on changes in land use or controlled burns
[03:52]
and so on. Another issue is that many of the existing climate models aren’t particularly good at predicting extreme events in the first place. My main beef is though that the probability you get will depend on how you define the event.
[04:08]
The more details you add about the event, the less likely it will become until eventually you are comparing zero to zero. There is pretty good evidence that climate change does impact trends of certain extreme
[04:23]
events. But making definite statements about the counterfactual probability of a particular event not occurring is, in my opinion, ill-defined mathematical nonsense. There is no amount of equations that will make this fundamental problem go away. It’s
[04:38]
not that I think climate change doesn’t happen or that I think it’s not man-made or that we shouldn’t worry about it. I think this event attribution business is bad maths. And where the 2016 NAS report clearly said that “the answers obtained are no longer directly
[04:56]
about the actual event” the new report vaguely says “Observations are typically insufficient to validate model-based estimates of event probabilities” and somewhere in their academic word salad they acknowledge that probabilities can differ wildly depending on how you calculate them.
[05:12]
In summary, I am sorry, but I agree that the NAS f*cked up. They had a chance to clearly call out how mathematically questionable this procedure is and they didn’t. Instead, they gave a platform to
[05:26]
a bunch of people with a political cause. This is the exact reason why people lose trust in scientists. Perhaps the National Academy should investigate how much this report contributed to the loss of public trust in science. Though I suspect they’d have difficulty defining the event.
[05:43]
I read a lot of news to keep you well informed and the most useful and time-saving way I found to do this is with Ground News, who've been sponsoring this video. Ground News is a news
[05:55]
platform that collects news from all over the world. It really saves me a lot of time because I don't have to sort through a dozen headlines on the same story. I can just get a quick summary of
[06:07]
all the coverage. And Ground News also gives you a lot of extra information at one glance. Take for example this recent story about scientists leaving the United States due to lack of funding. This received very little coverage on the political right. And Ground News
[06:22]
also has this bias comparison that tells you that the left-leaning coverage focuses on fears about future funding and academic freedom. Whereas the right leaning coverage emphasizes scale. Ground
[06:34]
News also gives you a factuality check on each news item which in this case is overall high. You can also see who owns the media outlets and where the news has appeared. I found this to be super useful for checking whether stories being blown out of proportion, ignored or distorted.
[06:51]
And of course, I have a special offer for you. That's a 40% discount on the Vantage plan, which gives you access to all their features. All you need to do is use my link ground.news/sabine
[07:03]
or use the QR code so they'll know I sent you. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.