You CAN Build Muscle & Lose Fat At The Same Time
45sChallenges a common fitness myth with scientific evidence and examples of pro athletes.
▶ Play ClipBody recomposition—building muscle while losing fat—is possible for most people, not just beginners. Research shows it occurs even in advanced athletes when using a small calorie deficit, high protein intake, and proper training. The key is balancing opposing goals by signaling the body to use fat stores for muscle growth.
A 2021 meta-analysis of 59 studies found that muscle growth halts when the calorie deficit exceeds ~300 calories, and decreases beyond 500. A slight deficit of 200-300 calories is optimal for maximizing recomposition odds.
During a deficit, muscle protein synthesis drops. High protein intake (0.8-1g per pound of body weight) counteracts this and supports muscle growth while losing fat.
A 2023 study showed both heavy/low-rep and light/high-rep training can work for recomp, provided sets are taken close to failure (within 3 reps). Effort is the key factor.
A 2020 study found that a sleep education program (aiming for 7+ hours) significantly improved fat loss during a workout program, while the workout-only group gained fat.
Beginners, people returning after a break (muscle memory), and those who previously trained suboptimally are most likely to recomp. However, even for them, recomp becomes harder below ~15% body fat (men) or ~22% (women).
Recomp results are slow and harder to track than bulking/cutting. Traditional cycles may be superior for experienced lifters. The video recommends considering your primary goal before choosing recomp.
"The title accurately reflects the content: the video provides a step-by-step guide on how to lose fat and gain muscle simultaneously, backed by research."
What is the recommended calorie deficit for body recomposition?
A small calorie deficit of around 200-300 calories per day.
[1:35]
What protein intake is recommended during a calorie deficit for body recomposition?
0.8 to 1 gram per pound of body weight.
[3:16]
How much sleep is recommended to support body recomposition?
At least 7 hours per night.
[6:09]
Which three groups of people are best suited for body recomposition?
Beginners, people returning after a break (muscle memory), and those who haven't trained optimally before.
[6:21]
Why is body recomposition considered challenging?
Because muscle building is energy-demanding and a calorie deficit typically prevents it. However, the body can use fat stores for energy.
[0:43]
What study is referenced to determine the optimal calorie deficit for muscle growth?
A 2021 meta-analysis of 59 fat loss studies.
[1:35]
What does the 2023 study say about training with heavy vs. light weights during a calorie deficit?
Both heavy weights for low reps and lighter weights for high reps can work, provided effort is high (close to failure).
[3:49]
How close to failure should each set be taken to maximize muscle growth?
Within 3 reps of failure, possibly even closer.
[4:24]
What does research suggest about gender differences in body recomposition?
Females may be more likely to experience body recomposition even when relatively lean.
[7:55]
What are the approximate minimum body fat percentages for body recomposition to be possible?
Around 15% body fat for males and at least 22% for females.
[8:11]
Pro athletes can recomp
Shows body recomposition is possible even in highly trained individuals, not just beginners.
[0:25]Optimal calorie deficit
Provides a specific, research-backed range (200-300 calorie deficit) for maximizing muscle gain while losing fat.
[1:35]High protein intake crucial
Emphasizes the importance of protein (0.8-1g per pound) to counteract reduced muscle protein synthesis during a deficit.
[3:16]Train close to failure
Highlights that effort level (within 3 reps of failure) is more important than rep ranges for muscle growth during a deficit.
[4:24]Who benefits most
Identifies three groups (beginners, returnees, suboptimal trainers) most likely to succeed with recomp, helping viewers self-assess.
[6:21][00:00] build muscle lose fat pick what well
[00:04] what if I want to do both at the same
[00:06] time known as body recomposition many
[00:09] people believe this is impossible or
[00:11] only reserved for a small percentage of
[00:13] people but that's not entirely true most
[00:16] people definitely can build muscle and
[00:19] lose fat at the same time in fact it
[00:21] happens all the time in research and not
[00:23] just in beginners this study found
[00:25] positive body recomposition in pro
[00:28] football players already squatting over
[00:30] 382 pounds and benching over 289 pounds
[00:34] and even some women at extreme levels of
[00:37] leanness preparing for a bodybuilding
[00:39] show have been found to gain a bit of
[00:41] muscle during this process so what's the
[00:43] secret well the major problem with
[00:45] trying to build muscle and lose fat at
[00:47] the same time is their two opposing
[00:49] goals to typically you need to be in a
[00:52] calorie deficit to lose fat but because
[00:54] muscle building is such an energy
[00:56] demanding process this usually prevents
[00:58] you from building muscle however the
[01:01] energy your muscles need to grow doesn't
[01:03] just have to come from your diet with
[01:05] the right nutrition and training plan
[01:06] you can actually signal your body to use
[01:09] its existing fat stores as energy
[01:11] towards building muscle and as a result
[01:13] build muscle and lose fat simultaneously
[01:16] so how do we do it well there's three
[01:19] steps to this starting with nutrition
[01:20] now the most important part of your
[01:23] nutrition is your calorie intake and
[01:25] although you want to be in a calorie
[01:27] deficit to stimulate fat loss it
[01:29] shouldn't be as aggressive as it is
[01:31] during a typical diet and phase as for
[01:33] what that sweet spot is let's take a
[01:35] look at this 2021 meta-analysis
[01:38] researchers pull together 59 fat loss
[01:41] studies to try to find at what point a
[01:43] calorie deficit becomes too low for
[01:45] building muscle to be possible here is
[01:47] the graph of the results notice how many
[01:50] people were able able to build muscle
[01:51] when the deficit was small but as soon
[01:53] as it surpassed a deficit of around 300
[01:55] calories muscle growth came to a halt
[01:58] and even began to decrease as soon as
[02:00] the deficit grew larger than 500
[02:02] calories now keep in mind this data is
[02:05] from subjects following standard fitness
[02:07] programs employed in research studies
[02:09] which usually aren't the most ideal
[02:11] programs for building muscle so with the
[02:13] optimized training plan I'll show you
[02:14] later on in this video it's very
[02:16] possible you'll still be able to build
[02:17] muscle even in a 500 calorie deficit and
[02:20] Beyond however based on this data if you
[02:23] want to maximize your odds of being able
[02:25] to recop it's likely that a slight
[02:27] deficit of around 200 to 300 calories is
[02:29] best and if you do want some help
[02:31] calculating this you can head over to
[02:33] billtoscience.com calculator okay so we
[02:36] have calories figured out but what seems
[02:38] to be just as important is your protein
[02:40] intake you see a calorie deficit reduces
[02:43] your rates of muscle protein synthesis
[02:45] so less of the protein you eat will be
[02:47] used as a building block for building
[02:49] muscle E2 little protein and your body
[02:52] will start to look for it elsewhere such
[02:53] as your existing muscle mass as for how
[02:56] much to eat to counteract this let's
[02:58] take a look at three studies each of
[03:00] them had subjects eat in a calorie
[03:01] deficit but assigned them to either a
[03:03] low or high daily protein intake of
[03:06] different amounts every single study
[03:08] found Superior muscle growth in the high
[03:10] protein group and since subjects were
[03:12] still in a calorie deficit they managed
[03:14] to lose fat at the same time now
[03:16] unfortunately we don't yet have a study
[03:18] that compares protein intakes that are
[03:20] both relatively High during a calorie
[03:22] deficit such as 0.8 versus 1.2 grams per
[03:25] pound of body weight however I think
[03:27] it's pretty safe to say that you'll be
[03:29] pretty much close to maximizing your
[03:30] growth at about 0.8 grams per pound and
[03:33] if you really want to be on the safe
[03:34] side bump it up to one gram per pound so
[03:37] the next step is to pair your nutrition
[03:39] plan with a training plan designed to
[03:41] force your muscles to grow and there's a
[03:43] few relevant studies that can help us
[03:45] determine what the best approach might
[03:46] be one of them is a study published just
[03:49] last year where research just took 130
[03:51] subjects with at least six months
[03:53] trading experience and compared the
[03:55] effects of having them trained with
[03:56] heavy weights versus lighter weights
[03:58] while in a calorie deficit a common
[04:00] belief is that lighter waste for High
[04:02] Reps is better for fat loss whereas
[04:04] heavier weights for Less reps is best
[04:06] for building muscle but in this case
[04:09] both approaches resulted in a similar
[04:11] amount of fat loss as well as a little
[04:14] bit of muscle gain but this does heavily
[04:16] depend on one factor effort and this is
[04:20] honestly where I believe most of you
[04:21] guys are falling short you see in order
[04:24] to maximize growth you need to take each
[04:26] of your sets at least within three reps
[04:29] short of failure and in fact based on
[04:31] the new pre-print study it might be
[04:33] advantageous to take each set even
[04:35] closer to failure than this thing is
[04:37] most people don't train anywhere close
[04:39] to hard enough to reach this no you got
[04:41] more come on come on come on you have at
[04:44] least three more go and this brings me
[04:46] to an important point I want to make
[04:47] there really isn't a special body
[04:49] composition position training plan it's
[04:51] about doing the basics but doing the
[04:53] well polish hard enough during your sets
[04:55] train with enough volume work each
[04:57] muscle at least twice per week and most
[05:00] importantly stay consistent even if
[05:02] you're an experienced lifter fixing any
[05:04] one of these variables can very well be
[05:06] the stimulus your body needs to continue
[05:08] building muscle despite being in a
[05:10] deficit but before I cover who exactly
[05:12] body recomposition is best suited for
[05:15] there is one more variable you need to
[05:17] make sure you don't overlook sleep okay
[05:20] so the most relevant study we have
[05:21] regarding sleep and body recomposition
[05:23] was published back in 2020 researchers
[05:27] took untrained men and randomly assigned
[05:29] them to either a worker program
[05:30] consisting of two full body workouts per
[05:32] week or that same workout program plus a
[05:35] sleep education program designed to
[05:37] improve both the quantity and the
[05:40] quality of their sleep after 10 weeks
[05:42] both groups had similar increases of
[05:44] muscle with a trend favorite in the
[05:46] Sleep group when it came to Fat Loss
[05:48] however the Sleep group actually he
[05:50] ended up losing a significant amount of
[05:52] fat while the workout only group ended
[05:55] up gaining a little bit of fat other
[05:57] Studies have shown similar effects as
[05:58] well where sleep deprivation negatively
[06:00] affects both muscle gains and fat loss
[06:03] so to make sure you don't sabotage all
[06:05] the work you put into your nutrition and
[06:06] training try to get at least seven hours
[06:09] of sleep per night alright so now that
[06:10] we've covered how to recap let's discuss
[06:13] the most important part who body
[06:15] recomposition is best suited for and
[06:17] whether or not it's actually worth your
[06:18] time pursuing so first off the higher
[06:21] your potential for growth the more
[06:22] likely you'll be able to recall and
[06:24] there's three main groups of people who
[06:26] satisfy this criteria the first group
[06:28] are beginners who can basically touch a
[06:30] weight and end up growing the second
[06:32] group has to do with the fact that
[06:33] muscle regrows far easier than it took
[06:36] to initially grow it Lawrence one of our
[06:38] bill of science members is a good
[06:39] example of this he took some time off
[06:41] training and in his first two months
[06:43] back although his body weight didn't
[06:45] change very much he was able to build
[06:46] some muscle while losing a good amount
[06:48] of fat but the third group is where I
[06:51] think most people fall under and Nick
[06:53] another one of our build science members
[06:55] is a perfect example of this although he
[06:57] had been training for several years he
[06:59] was pretty much just going through the
[07:00] motions he never properly applied
[07:02] Progressive overload and had plenty of
[07:04] other areas where his training could
[07:05] improve I also just didn't know how to
[07:07] approach his nutrition after we helped
[07:09] optimize his plan he quickly saw results
[07:11] and experienced incredible body
[07:13] recomposition over the course of several
[07:16] months although his actual body weight
[07:18] didn't change too much he clearly built
[07:20] a good amount of muscle while losing a
[07:22] ton of fat in the process that said even
[07:25] if they do fall into one of these three
[07:27] groups there's still one more condition
[07:28] you should satisfy and the importance of
[07:31] this is highlighted in a recent 2023
[07:33] case study researchers analyzed a group
[07:36] of professional bodybuilders during the
[07:38] contest prep and found that as they got
[07:40] leaner building muscle became far less
[07:42] likely and eventually muscle loss became
[07:45] inevitable once they surpassed a certain
[07:47] level of leanness it is interesting
[07:49] however that a few of the female
[07:51] subjects were still able to build a
[07:53] little bit of muscle and another study
[07:55] has actually shown similar results it
[07:57] suggests that body recomposition may be
[07:59] more likely to occur in females even
[08:01] when relatively but we definitely need
[08:03] more research but overall although the
[08:06] exact minimum level of body fat required
[08:08] to recomb isn't entirely clear yet I'd
[08:11] say around 15 body fat for males and at
[08:14] least 22 percent for females is a good
[08:16] minimum but now it's time for the
[08:18] million dollar question is body
[08:20] recomposition even worth your time well
[08:23] first off if you're someone who's pretty
[08:24] lean or has been trained both hard and
[08:26] consistently for at least six months
[08:28] then you're probably gonna have a hard
[08:30] time trying to recall secondly even if
[08:33] you are likely to recall you should also
[08:35] consider what your main goal is right
[08:37] now I know you want to do both but
[08:39] what's truly more important to you right
[08:40] now building muscle or losing fat for
[08:43] example while you might end up building
[08:45] a little bit of muscle during a recomp
[08:47] most research suggests that a surplus or
[08:49] lean ball book is likely Superior
[08:51] whereas if your main goal is to lose fat
[08:53] then a slightly more aggressive deficit
[08:55] would definitely lead to more fat loss
[08:58] with the possibility that you'll still
[09:00] be able to gain a little bit of muscle
[09:01] it's also likely no coincidence that no
[09:04] bodybuilder on the planet at least that
[09:06] I'm aware of natural or enhanced tries
[09:08] to recomp their way to muscle growth
[09:10] they use Balkan and cutting cycles and
[09:12] end up looking better year after year
[09:14] and perhaps just as important we as
[09:17] humans like to see things go in the
[09:18] right direction during a recomp results
[09:21] can be slow and your body weight doesn't
[09:22] really help indicate whether things are
[09:24] going in the right direction so you have
[09:26] to rely on other metrics like small
[09:28] differences in progress photos
[09:29] strengthen the gym have your clothes are
[09:32] fitting and tracking your waist
[09:33] circumference over time without proper
[09:35] guidance this can be a lot more
[09:37] difficult to navigate than a traditional
[09:39] bulker cut where the scale and quicker
[09:41] body changes can lead the way that said
[09:44] I do think for some people it is worth a
[09:46] shot and at the very least it's helpful
[09:48] to be mindful of when dieting in the
[09:50] event that your weight is stuck and you
[09:52] think you're not making progress but
[09:54] you're really just building muscle and
[09:55] losing fat simultaneously and as a recap
[09:58] here's who is best suited for here's how
[10:00] to execute it and here's what to expect
[10:02] and how long it typically lasts and if
[10:05] you need some help optimizing your plan
[10:06] then head to buildtoothscience.com and
[10:09] take our 30 second quiz to find the best
[10:11] step-by-step training and nutrition plan
[10:13] for you and your body I highly recommend
[10:16] that you give this video watch next for
[10:17] some new science-based training
[10:19] techniques you can start applying today
[10:21] to speed up growth thanks for watching
[10:23] I'll see you next time
⚡ Saved you 0h 10m reading this? Transcribe any YouTube video for free — no signup needed.