[00:00]
Someone's paying influencers to tell you that artificial intelligence will kill us all. Someone else is paying influencers to tell you that AI will make your life better. I stumbled across this story after I was offered money to do exactly this. I looked into it and
[00:17]
realized that this has been going on for a while on both sides of the debate. And since you seem to be the kind of person that watches YouTube, I think you should know who is influencing
[00:29]
the influencers. YouTube sponsorships usually work like this. The creator has expenses that they need to cover and paid subscriptions and integrated ads don't do it. So, they need a sponsor. The creator
[00:44]
gets their expenses covered and they can publish their content without a paywall. The sponsor get exposure. The audience gets a special offer. Everyone's happy. In these arrangements, the
[00:56]
sponsor has no editorial control about the content of the video other than the segment that's about their product or service. In fact, for my science news, the sponsor usually doesn't even know the
[01:08]
topic of the video until it's live because I don't know in advance what news will come up next week. But here's the issue. Sponsors often see a higher impact when their sponsorship is undisclosed
[01:21]
or murky because that makes recommendations appear more trustworthy. Strictly speaking, this is illegal, but there's a gray zone where you know, a creator might just come to agree on the
[01:33]
viewpoint of the sponsor. So, maybe their entire video just so happens to please the sponsor who had no editorial say about the content whatsoever. This isn't even far-fetched if you consider that a
[01:45]
sponsor might only contact creators they think are sympathetic to their point of view to begin with. Case in point, I was contacted by an organization that wants to warn you that AI is an existential
[01:57]
threat. Now, I've myself warned of the dangers of AI, so I'm indeed very sympathetic to that message. But then they wanted to tell me what the video was supposed to be about and what I was supposed to say, down to the sentences I should read and references I should quote. I said, "No."
[02:14]
But look, if the price is right, someone else will do it eventually. Then I saw on X this YouTuber saying he's now got three inquiries from anti-AI sponsors. This one, which he screenshotted,
[02:29]
came from someone who mentions the Center for AI Safety, which is handing out grants to creators to make videos that warn of the coming apocalypse. And would you know it, the apocalypse
[02:41]
comes with a marketing budget. There's also the nonprofit Control AI, which has been sponsoring videos about how AI is an existential threat. And the Future of Life Institute launched a
[02:53]
campaign to regulate AI called Protect What's Human, which invites people to take paid social media work. Follow the campaign directions, submit a draft, receive feedback, publish,
[03:05]
and then get paid. According to an article in the Washington Post last year, this institute has funded 30 projects to develop AI safety content. Totally unbiased reporting, I'm sure. I think
[03:17]
that the reason these nonprofits are seeking out influencers is a response to social media campaigns by the big AI companies that have been going on for years. OpenAI, Anthropic, Google,
[03:29]
Perplexity, they all have paid creators to explain how much using AI has changed their workflow. These are standard influencer sponsorships, and I believe that they're almost all disclosed. But the
[03:42]
pro-AI side is channeling some of its efforts through nonprofits, too. And again, that makes disclosure murky. The most striking example comes from Build American AI. Taylor Lorenz reported for
[03:56]
Wired that she was personally approached by the non-profit organization Build American AI. They offered $5,000 for one TikTok video that presents China's AI progress as a threat to American jobs.
[04:10]
Lorenz didn't take that offer, but she reports that evidently other creators did in posts that were marked but sometimes didn't disclose just who paid. The non-profit Build American AI has, among
[04:28]
others, received funding from OpenAI's president Greg Brockman. Now, let me be clear. I don't think that it's per se wrong to pay people to get a message out on social media. Indeed, it would
[04:43]
be stupid of these organizations on either side of the debate if they didn't do it. The reason this bothers me is that this is a case where political lobbying is spilling over into science and tech
[04:56]
reporting, where it encounters an audience that isn't quite used to this. I don't see myself as an influencer. I see myself as an info-encer. I give you information and I want you to think for
[05:10]
yourself. And this is also the purpose of this video. I'm not condemning any organization or creator. I just want you to know that when it comes to anti-AI or pro-AI content, watch out
[05:24]
for who paid for it. For complete transparency, I should disclose that Big Cheese continues to exert enormous influence over my decisions. I read a lot of news every day, and that used to be really
[05:39]
tedious because a lot of headlines repeat and it's difficult to tell what quality the articles are, but today's sponsor Ground News really made my news reading so much better. Ground News is a
[05:51]
news platform that collects news from all over the world. It really saves me a lot of time because I don't have to sort through a dozen headlines on the same story. I can just get a quick summary
[06:03]
and fact-check for all the coverage. And Ground News also gives you a lot of extra information at one glance. An interesting recent example is this story about the chair of the financial
[06:15]
stability board who's warning of AI. You can see at one glance that this received a lot of coverage both on the political left and on the right with the factuality generally high. Ground News also tells you what points the outlets agreed on. AI is potentially a threat to the global financial
[06:32]
system and where there's disagreement. That's just how big the problem is and what's the cause. All at one glance. And it now also tells you which sources are not paywalled. Ground News also has
[06:44]
this interesting feature called blind spot. This collects news which has been covered only on one side of the political spectrum. I found Ground News super useful for putting news into context
[06:57]
quickly. And of course, I have a special offer for you. That's a 40% discount on the Vantage plan which gives you access to all their features. All you need to do is use my link ground.news/sabine
[07:11]
or use the QR code so they'll know I sent you. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.