[00:00]
I don't take probiotic supplements as a
[00:02]
doctor and a scientist and if you take
[00:04]
them daily, the latest science is
[00:06]
telling us they're probably not doing
[00:09]
much and they might even cause harm.
[00:11]
I've been interested in gut health for
[00:13]
many years, both during and after
[00:16]
medical school, and I've recommended
[00:18]
probiotic supplements in some very
[00:20]
specific cases, but the supplement
[00:22]
industry has turned this into a complete
[00:24]
marketing gimmick. and your gut's much
[00:27]
more complex than a couple bacterial
[00:30]
species crammed into a pill. So, today I
[00:32]
want to show you when probiotic
[00:34]
supplements actually make sense versus
[00:36]
when they're just a waste of money and
[00:39]
when they can actually backfire. And
[00:41]
we'll also talk about a much better
[00:43]
option for most people. For more
[00:45]
breakdowns of science and popular trends
[00:48]
and different supplements with no sales,
[00:50]
subscribe. When we hear probiotic, we
[00:53]
usually associate that with a healthy
[00:55]
gut. And there's some truth to that.
[00:58]
Your gut contains trillions of microbes
[01:01]
that help break down food. They talk to
[01:03]
your immune system and they also nourish
[01:06]
your gut wall. But the supplement
[01:07]
industry wants you to make this logical
[01:09]
leap that if gut bacteria are a good
[01:12]
thing, then adding more bacteria in a
[01:15]
pill must be good for you. And the
[01:17]
scientific evidence is showing us this
[01:19]
is a big mistake because probiotic
[01:21]
supplements have a number of problems.
[01:24]
Number one, there's almost no
[01:25]
regulation. The seller doesn't need to
[01:27]
show that the product works or even that
[01:30]
it contains what's advertised on the
[01:32]
bottle. Studies have shown that it's
[01:34]
quite common for the content of these
[01:36]
pills to not match what's advertised.
[01:39]
Sometimes the concentration is wrong.
[01:42]
Sometimes the species don't match. So,
[01:45]
for anyone going for a probiotic
[01:46]
supplement, it's always better to go
[01:48]
with a third-party certified brand. That
[01:51]
way, you know what's on the bottle is
[01:53]
what's in the pill. Also, you want to
[01:55]
get used to the fact that all of these
[01:56]
claims on the bottles gut health, immune
[02:00]
support, immune boost, that's marketing.
[02:04]
It's not science. Okay. The second
[02:05]
problem with probiotic pills is that a
[02:08]
lot of these microorganisms are actually
[02:11]
very sensitive to heat, to oxygen, and
[02:14]
to the acid in your stomach. So, even if
[02:16]
the pill does contain what the
[02:18]
manufacturer says, by the time it's been
[02:21]
stored in a warehouse and shipped and
[02:23]
sits in a shelf and you take it and it
[02:26]
crosses your stomach, there might be
[02:28]
very little or nothing left to get to
[02:31]
where it needs to be. Studies have found
[02:32]
that up to twothirds of people show no
[02:36]
evidence of probiotic supplements
[02:38]
actually working, actually colonizing
[02:39]
their gut, or reported any digestive
[02:41]
benefits. And finally, these pills
[02:44]
hugely oversimplify gut biology. Your
[02:47]
gut contains hundreds up to a thousand
[02:49]
different strains of microorganisms, all
[02:52]
interacting in an equilibrium with each
[02:55]
other, all with individual different
[02:57]
roles. And so picking two or three or
[03:00]
five random ones and cramming them into
[03:02]
a pill, that might not be what you need.
[03:05]
Could even be counterproductive. A
[03:06]
famous study from a couple years ago
[03:08]
found that the effect of probiotics
[03:10]
varies enormously from one person to the
[03:13]
next. Some people show colonization by
[03:16]
these microbes. Other people are really
[03:18]
resistant. The microbes just don't take
[03:20]
hold. So you want to be careful with a
[03:22]
friend or a neighbor saying, "Hey,
[03:24]
probiotics worked really well for me.
[03:27]
the same pill might not do anything for
[03:29]
you. But the most surprising part is
[03:31]
that in some contexts, probiotic pills
[03:34]
can actually harm you. They can actually
[03:36]
work against you. So when we take an
[03:39]
antibiotic for some infection, it's very
[03:41]
common for the antibiotic to wipe out
[03:44]
some of our gut microbiome and then that
[03:47]
will recover gradually over time
[03:49]
depending on diet and other factors. But
[03:51]
in a fascinating study, scientists found
[03:54]
that when they gave the participants a
[03:56]
probiotic, a pill containing 11 species
[03:59]
of microbes that they selected, it
[04:01]
actually delayed their recovery. So they
[04:04]
did worse. They recovered slower than
[04:06]
the folks who got nothing, who just got
[04:08]
a placebo. So this was a shocking
[04:10]
finding because this is exactly the
[04:12]
context where you'll assume that it
[04:15]
makes sense to take a probiotic. you
[04:17]
just took an antibiotic, your gut
[04:18]
doesn't feel right. And so you buy a
[04:20]
probiotic that says gut health on it
[04:22]
because you're trying to rebuild your
[04:24]
gut, right? But like we said, our gut
[04:26]
microbiome, it's a living organism in a
[04:29]
balance. And so throwing in the wrong
[04:31]
microorganism,
[04:33]
can actually mess up that balance, can
[04:35]
actually be worse. We're going to talk
[04:37]
about which probiotic strains can help
[04:40]
in that situation in specific cases.
[04:43]
Just want to point out that probiotics
[04:45]
can also cause some side effects. Gas,
[04:48]
bloating, discomfort, although usually
[04:51]
it's mild and temporary. Now, everything
[04:54]
we're saying doesn't mean that
[04:56]
probiotics are poison for everyone at
[04:59]
all times. I'm not anti-supplements. I'm
[05:02]
anti-arketing
[05:03]
that's taking advantage of you. So, you
[05:05]
want to take the right thing for you at
[05:08]
the right time. Medicine isn't cookie
[05:10]
cutter. This is why it's good that I
[05:13]
reject all sponsors and I don't sell
[05:15]
anything on the channel because when
[05:16]
something like this comes up, I don't
[05:19]
care. I can just tell you the truth,
[05:20]
what works, what doesn't work. There's
[05:22]
no financial pressure. So, for example,
[05:25]
in people taking antibiotics, this
[05:27]
specific strain of probiotic sacroyces
[05:31]
bulardi, it's a type of yeast, and
[05:34]
there's some evidence that that can help
[05:36]
prevent cadiff infection. It's not the
[05:39]
highest level evidence, but it's
[05:40]
defensible. Someone in that situation to
[05:42]
give that specific probiotic to prevent
[05:46]
CIFF infection. That's a defensible
[05:49]
medical decision. There's also some
[05:50]
specific GI conditions. There's
[05:52]
something called pouchitis if you have
[05:54]
that. Pre-term infants sometimes are
[05:56]
given probiotics as well. So, very
[05:58]
specific situations. Notice how
[06:00]
different that is from everybody go take
[06:03]
this random probiotic pill. Healthy,
[06:05]
unhealthy, doesn't matter. Also, if you
[06:07]
have specific conditions, if you're
[06:09]
immuno compromised, for example, if you
[06:12]
have cancer and you're going through
[06:13]
treatment through chemotherapy, you want
[06:15]
to be especially careful with
[06:17]
probiotics. In some cases, they can
[06:19]
actually cause infections if the immune
[06:22]
system is weakened. Okay, so we've
[06:24]
covered a lot of the myths and the facts
[06:27]
around probiotics, but here's a twist.
[06:30]
If probiotic pills are overhyped and
[06:32]
they're not needed by most healthy
[06:34]
people, what about probiotic foods?
[06:36]
Kafir, yogurt, kombucha. You've heard me
[06:39]
talk about these foods in many videos in
[06:42]
the past. I've told you that I eat them
[06:44]
on a regular basis. So, am I just a
[06:46]
hypocrite? So, there's a number of
[06:48]
fundamental differences between a
[06:50]
probiotic pill and a probiotic food like
[06:53]
some fermented foods. Fermented foods
[06:56]
contain an entire ecosystem of
[06:58]
microorganisms. Kafir, for example, has
[07:01]
been shown to contain dozens of
[07:03]
bacterial strains and yeast strains. And
[07:05]
we know that one key feature of a
[07:07]
healthy microbiome is diversity. So
[07:11]
these fermented foods already come with
[07:13]
that diversity built in that natural
[07:16]
ecosystem. You can't get that. You can't
[07:18]
replicate that with a pill that has
[07:21]
three or four strains in it. But also
[07:23]
the types of strains that you're getting
[07:25]
in the fermented food are the ones that
[07:27]
survived and that evolved in that
[07:30]
ecosystem, right? interacting with each
[07:32]
other. Not a couple strains that were
[07:35]
artificially chosen because they're
[07:37]
easier to manufacture at scale or to
[07:39]
ship or something like that. But also
[07:41]
the concentration and the proportion of
[07:43]
the microbes to each other that's
[07:45]
already built in because a fermented
[07:48]
food is a living organism. It's
[07:51]
literally fermenting all the way up and
[07:54]
growing all the way up to you consuming
[07:56]
it. That's assuming it's not killed by
[07:58]
heat, right? That's a common question
[07:59]
and that can happen if it's heated then
[08:02]
the microbes are killed. So this depends
[08:04]
on the food. Kafir for example it's done
[08:06]
from pasteurized milk but the
[08:08]
pasteurization happens before the
[08:11]
fermentation process. So it doesn't kill
[08:14]
the bunks. Make sense? And one last
[08:16]
point I want to make with the fermented
[08:18]
food with the probiotic food you're also
[08:21]
getting the entire food matrix. It's not
[08:23]
just the microbes by themselves. You're
[08:26]
also getting in addition to the
[08:28]
probiotics, you're getting the
[08:30]
prebiotics. So that's specific types of
[08:33]
fiber and specific types of starch that
[08:36]
the microbes consume. Those come in
[08:38]
there as well. You're also getting the
[08:40]
postbiotics. So those are fermentation
[08:43]
products, metabolites of the microbes
[08:46]
that are in there as well that have all
[08:48]
kinds of physiological effects on your
[08:50]
body and many other compounds like fatty
[08:52]
acids and amino acids. So they're
[08:54]
fundamentally different products. A pill
[08:57]
with two or three species crammed in,
[09:00]
concentrated, isolated versus this
[09:04]
complex ecosystem of the fermented food.
[09:06]
So this goes back to a principle we've
[09:08]
talked about in many previous videos,
[09:10]
which is we don't just want to get
[09:13]
microbes in there. We also want to feed
[09:16]
them properly. It's like planting a
[09:17]
seed, but then you got to water it and
[09:19]
give it light. Otherwise, it doesn't
[09:22]
sprout. It's useless. So, if you're new
[09:23]
to the channel, we have a lot of content
[09:25]
covering all of this, all the
[09:26]
actionables, how to maintain a healthy
[09:28]
microbiome. Also, notice that the this
[09:30]
matrix, this food matrix wraps the
[09:33]
microbes so that they're not directly
[09:35]
exposed to the acidity of the stomach,
[09:37]
not as much as they are in a pill where
[09:40]
they're isolated. And so, there's a
[09:41]
landmark trial that showed that
[09:43]
generally healthy people given fermented
[09:46]
foods, their microbiome diversity
[09:48]
improved and their inflammation came
[09:50]
down as well. So, this is the twist.
[09:53]
People get these probiotic pills to have
[09:55]
a healthier gut, a healthier microbiome.
[09:58]
But for most people, there are actual
[10:00]
foods that are much more likely to
[10:02]
deliver that result. Now, bear in mind,
[10:04]
fermented foods also have some caveats.
[10:06]
So, for example, people with a weakened
[10:09]
immune system, people with specific
[10:11]
sensitivities like histamine
[10:12]
intolerance, talk to your doctor before
[10:14]
you start fermented foods. Okay, so
[10:16]
let's make this actionable. How do you
[10:17]
actually make that decision? You're
[10:19]
standing in the store. Look at the shelf
[10:21]
with all the probiotics. This is what I
[10:23]
tell a friend of mine if they ask me
[10:25]
about this. If you're healthy
[10:26]
individual, you just heard the
[10:28]
probiotics are good for your gut. Save
[10:30]
your money. Spend it on some yogurt with
[10:33]
probiotic cultures or some kafir or some
[10:36]
kombucha or something like that. If you
[10:38]
have a specific health condition or a
[10:41]
gut issue, then it's possible that
[10:43]
probiotics might be right for you. But
[10:46]
don't grab a random strain. You want to
[10:48]
look up the exact strain and the dose
[10:51]
that was shown to help your situation
[10:53]
and ideally talk to a
[10:55]
gastroenterenterologist. And remember,
[10:56]
for specific medical issues, weakened
[10:59]
immune system, cancer, going through
[11:01]
treatment, talk to your doctor before
[11:02]
you start probiotics. For more
[11:04]
evidence-based breakdowns of common
[11:06]
questions with no sponsors and no sales,
[11:09]
subscribe and I'll see you on the next
[11:10]
video. Actually, I'll link one right
[11:12]
here.