[00:00]
Yes, in the midst of all of this, the
[00:06]
considering a piece of legislation
[00:14]
I was part of a Hot Rotisserie
[00:18]
This started off a standalone bill and now
[00:23]
year's Farm Bill, which means it's probably
[00:29]
though I do think the whole thing is
[00:33]
for sure, but it is little more than a
[00:40]
There is a lot of important stuff we can
[00:45]
works by going deep on this silly bill
[00:51]
The biggest but not the only way we give food
[00:57]
the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
[01:03]
still call it food stamps, because back
[01:08]
physical paper coupons you could use to buy
[01:13]
and they came in like 1 dollar
[01:18]
You would take those to a store
[01:21]
which was a lot of them but not all
[01:26]
except it was money you could only spend
[01:31]
back in more food stamps, or if it was less than a
[01:37]
If it sounds like a hassle for everyone
[01:42]
basically had to be ready to accept two totally
[01:47]
and ... it was really visually obvious to
[01:53]
that you were using food stamps,
[01:57]
to pay with food stamps which made
[02:02]
Everything got a lot better in the early 2000s
[02:07]
cards. Electronic Benefit Transfer. You use them
[02:13]
fills is up every month for you. The typical
[02:20]
Even if you are opposed to government social
[02:25]
efficiency of the SNAP system. Just as you have
[02:32]
sponsor of this video. Helix makes premium
[02:38]
your body and shipped to your door,
[02:43]
Memory foam, springs, firm, soft, medium like
[02:52]
out on the west coast for a thing the other
[02:57]
Helix mattress. When I'm away my body aches for
[03:05]
model is right for you and your partner. Also
[03:12]
You make it less firm by unzipping these flaps
[03:20]
might want a particular firmness. Invest in a
[03:26]
Hit my link or my QR code to save 27% site-wide
[03:34]
27% off site wide at HelixSleep.com/ragusea,
[03:42]
Anyway, even if you are philosophically
[03:47]
you have to marvel at the efficiency
[03:52]
If you want to hand out food directly to the
[03:59]
supply chain. We already have a nationwide
[04:05]
and so it's much more efficient to just give
[04:12]
But a complication arises when one considers
[04:20]
Grocery stores sell magazines and flower
[04:26]
they dangle right at grabbing distance for
[04:31]
and depending on the state, some
[04:36]
These are things that you might not want people
[04:42]
for reasons that are legitimate if debatable.
[04:46]
So, since the very first federal food stamp
[04:53]
there have been rules about what you
[04:58]
That very first national program in 1939
[05:06]
surplus — that is, crops that U.S. farmers
[05:12]
the open market. This is why SNAP is, to this
[05:19]
Agriculture instead of, like, the Department
[05:26]
in the U.S. double as farm subsidies — always
[05:34]
There's this thing that still exists called
[05:39]
out as a way for the government to
[05:44]
to stabilize the price for farmers. Use
[05:50]
And the USDA would process and package
[05:56]
as a kind of supplement for people on food
[06:01]
"government cheese." Colloquially it refers
[06:08]
But etymologically speaking,
[06:12]
a big block of processed cheese made by the
[06:18]
Many years ago I made a YouTube video about
[06:24]
is this unholy, big, bulk dessert where you
[06:31]
graham crackers and blueberry pie filling.
[06:36]
who is Hopi, he grew up on reservation.
[06:42]
of commodity food products and he told me
[06:48]
would make to use up the big commodity blocks
[06:56]
Obesity and metabolic syndrome disproportionately
[07:02]
sometimes point to the commodity foods
[07:08]
it's a farm subsidy as much
[07:12]
and sometimes it makes more sense as a farm
[07:18]
The Food Stamp Act of 1964 said you could
[07:24]
consumption except alcohol and "imported foods."
[07:33]
protectionism for farmers, effectively an
[07:39]
And since the 1970s, the law has, in one way or
[07:46]
stamps to buy hot, ready-to-eat food. The
[07:54]
not for eating out. Not for restaurant food.
[08:02]
probably made a bit more sense in the 20th
[08:08]
and prepared foods were generally, relatively
[08:14]
food industry is much more scaled up
[08:20]
It's still probably cheaper to cook
[08:25]
but we live in the real world, where a lot of
[08:31]
a lot of generational cooking habits
[08:36]
often working multiple jobs outside the
[08:42]
More than half of households with children
[08:48]
Yes, some SNAP recipients are unemployed, but
[08:55]
of the recipients who are unemployed
[09:00]
seniors and other people you wouldn't
[09:06]
Of the working people on SNAP, a lot of them are
[09:14]
the city bus because they can't afford a car, or
[09:20]
and they live in a food dessert where it's
[09:25]
etc etc, and you can imagine that a person living
[09:34]
to rely on at least some cheap prepared foods
[09:44]
But it was, perhaps, a different
[09:49]
didn't want people using government
[09:53]
which were considered a little more
[10:00]
Forget for a second whether you agree
[10:04]
as a practical matter, where would you
[10:11]
groceries? Are cornflakes a prepared food?
[10:22]
cereal is a grocery, right? Why? How about a
[10:33]
The common denominator is that they're not
[10:41]
food is usually served hot, to be consumed
[10:46]
as soon as you get home. Are there exceptions to
[10:54]
simplest way to draw a bright, legal line between
[11:04]
And so if we look at the food stamp language from
[11:13]
"Food" that can be bought with your SNAP card
[11:21]
home consumption except alcoholic beverages,
[11:31]
for immediate consumption other than
[11:38]
What clauses are we pursuing there? A whole bunch
[11:46]
and homeless people. There are carveouts that
[11:53]
buy hot meals from federally authorized vendors.
[12:00]
subsidized nursing homes. Again, a lot of these
[12:08]
sector entities that also, incidentally,
[12:15]
And even if you aren't covered by an exemption,
[12:18]
there are all kinds of workarounds for
[12:25]
in poor neighborhoods often have a microwave on
[12:31]
slice of pizza with your SNAP card and then you
[12:37]
And then there are the chickens.
[12:43]
is a very popular item in the United
[12:49]
widely-available source of ready-to-eat
[12:54]
Grocery stores often sell these birds a loss,
[12:58]
what they call a "loss leader" in business.
[13:04]
easy-to-use rotisserie cases. They fill the store
[13:12]
The customer buys the chicken, which is very
[13:18]
was about to expire anyway, and so this is
[13:24]
The customer buys the chicken, and they're
[13:30]
dinner. They're gonna buy drinks and sides
[13:36]
and retail is just like gambling,
[13:43]
Grocery stores that serve lots of
[13:47]
some of their chickens down so they can
[13:53]
they'll even have a microwave right there
[13:57]
Sure seems like a silly, pointless hoop to
[14:04]
I would argue, that if you want to draw a line
[14:11]
creating some kind of gray zone that people will
[14:18]
ineffective. It just means people are gonna bend
[14:27]
If you want to have speed limits, you have
[14:34]
over the speed limit with impunity. You just
[14:40]
That doesn't mean we have to accept where
[14:45]
the line between eligible and ineligible foods.
[14:55]
This single-page bill simply inserts the
[15:03]
definition of eligible food products that
[15:10]
Hot rotisserie chicken is the ONLY
[15:15]
other hot foods are still off limits to your
[15:23]
The bill is sponsored by a bipartisan
[15:30]
the most famous of whom is Senator
[15:34]
of Pennsylvania. I've watched Pennsylvania
[15:41]
been on my radar since he was the Mayor of
[15:50]
We cannot know if his stroke
[15:55]
we do know that strokes sometimes
[16:01]
Fetterman is thus quoted in his own
[16:07]
delicious) affordability play is Costco’s
[16:13]
of my family’s favorites and
[16:19]
That's a little weird, right? A U.S. Senator
[16:28]
true that the 5-dollar Costco chicken is sui
[16:36]
cheaper chicken on the national level.
[16:43]
And Costco is as close to a benevolent
[16:49]
corporate community. They pay their
[16:55]
to some corporate coercion from the
[16:58]
every other big company folded like
[17:04]
So why do I think the Hot Rotisserie
[17:14]
it only serves a certain kind of poor person.
[17:24]
of poor person. That's just where the Costcos
[17:32]
the kind of place you can take the city bus
[17:38]
back home on the bus. I mean, I'm sure there
[17:44]
Plus Costco is a discount club, which means
[17:51]
Once this bill passes, most of the
[17:56]
be bought with SNAP benefits are
[18:01]
which, again, often do not serve the inner
[18:09]
kinda seems like a bill for John Fetterman's
[18:17]
And it feels like a bit of an
[18:22]
here I am talking about the Rotisserie
[18:28]
Act" is fun to say, and it'll
[18:35]
The less token, more meaningful version of
[18:41]
lets you buy almost any kind of hot food with
[18:49]
called the Hot Foods Act from Democratic
[18:56]
not become law this year. Fetterman's
[19:04]
And I think that is revealing about
[19:11]
how seriously they take their jobs,
[19:16]
Because while they're throwing the hot
[19:22]
they are simultaneously cutting funding
[19:31]
getting SNAP benefits. According to USDA data,
[19:38]
dropped by about three million, 8 percent
[19:45]
President Trump's agriculture secretary,
[19:53]
this decline as an accomplishment. She
[20:01]
She does not have evidence to support this
[20:08]
it publicly. Rollins went on Fox the other day and
[20:17]
14-thousand SNAP recipients also own luxury cars,
[20:27]
Her source for this remarkable
[20:33]
data performed by the Foundation for
[20:38]
conservative group. If you go to this actual
[20:44]
their data or explain their methodology very
[20:51]
where you can go back and trace every single
[20:56]
One thing about the data they're working
[21:01]
no names attached to any of these data
[21:06]
going on with any of these people,
[21:12]
Indeed, the authors of this analysis
[21:17]
that some of these people on SNAP benefits who
[21:25]
not the perpetrators. They may be identity
[21:31]
security number to buy a car to hide the
[21:37]
We do not know if these SNAP recipients are the
[21:45]
All we know for sure is that the USDA
[21:52]
benefits. They've put extra hoops into
[21:59]
some fraudsters who did not really
[22:05]
has just discouraged some eligible people from
[22:12]
It's probably both, because that's how
[22:18]
Brooke Rollins doesn't like the
[22:23]
benefits when they don't really need
[22:31]
But the problem is, the way you crack down on
[22:39]
someone like Brooke Rollins don't like,
[22:47]
forms to fill out. More hoops. And a bigger
[22:56]
And when you make it really complicated to apply
[23:01]
industry of shady middlemen who help people
[23:07]
ends up becoming at least a little predatory, and
[23:13]
system that were intended to buy poor people food,
[23:21]
This is the central paradox of the
[23:27]
welfare programs. The alternative approach is
[23:35]
it for people to get the benefits, the easier you
[23:42]
You need less bureaucracy, less red tape.
[23:50]
to the benefits instead of going to the
[23:57]
The flip side of that more permissive,
[24:04]
up giving benefits to some people
[24:11]
Maybe that's the price you're willing
[24:18]
least you're paying for food and not
[24:26]
miles-per-hour of speeding that you have
[24:32]
And maybe that is a naive, rosy
[24:38]
a person who is not an expert in social welfare
[24:47]
experts, and a lot of them endorse a more
[24:56]
Sometimes the more efficient way to fill the
[25:04]
This is one of many arguments
[25:08]
benefits with a Universal Basic Income.
[25:17]
not just those who can prove they're poor
[25:22]
to everyone, you don't have to waste
[25:29]
Again, I don't know if that math
[25:35]
I'm just "teaching the controversy,"
[25:42]
at the grocery store and in the