[00:00]
There are many important aspects that
[00:04]
but one that I find especially interesting due
[00:10]
Without some sort of setback, or at the
[00:15]
games run the risk of losing meaning. The best
[00:21]
and so space for failure is a key
[00:25]
This can take all sorts of forms, both big and
[00:32]
tons of ways to incorporate it—it all comes
[00:38]
What makes failure tricky is that it is a
[00:43]
when I come across a new boss in a game, a part of
[00:48]
attempt. Of course, if I did first try every fight
[00:52]
away with is that the game was too easy for me.
[00:58]
Despite our aversion to it, we need failure.
[01:05]
it's what makes your inputs matter. And for
[01:09]
a threat—the consequences have to be carried
[01:14]
the threat will no longer feel threatening,
[01:20]
On the other hand though, there is only so much
[01:25]
creating this push and pull for developers where
[01:29]
in a way that will feel meaningful and be
[01:33]
are trying to create without driving away
[01:37]
Over the past couple months, there has been
[01:41]
Silksong for this reason. The game is incredibly
[01:47]
will have you dying over and over again, and what
[01:52]
that in most cases, instead of respawning in a
[01:57]
you most likely will be sent far, far away and
[02:03]
have long been a part of metroidvanias and other
[02:08]
but there has been a somewhat recent push
[02:15]
is with how Elden Ring does it, that being always
[02:20]
allowing players to immediately retry after
[02:25]
whole but instead the boss, and this format
[02:30]
of some of these fights. They are balanced
[02:33]
come in at full strength and therefore they
[02:38]
from how difficult they are, not from
[02:42]
In Silksong, bosses also seem balanced around the
[02:47]
strength despite having to travel so far to get
[02:52]
never that far away from being at full strength,
[02:57]
can be recovered without any sort of item,
[03:01]
restore their primary resource, flasks, by
[03:07]
Hornet leaves a cocoon behind, and breaking it
[03:12]
for the player to start every fight with a
[03:16]
there is still far more friction here. Every death
[03:22]
getting to keep practicing the part that caused
[03:25]
section that calls for a different skillset
[03:29]
Now, despite what people who hate them will
[03:33]
of folks out there who do like runbacks, and
[03:39]
that the challenge comes from mastering an
[03:43]
segments. They like having space between
[03:47]
fight with consideration instead of casually
[03:52]
like finding the optimal path back and perfecting
[03:57]
the temptation it creates to go somewhere else
[04:02]
Sickos like this do exist. And, yes, I am
[04:08]
Admittedly, while I have started to find runbacks
[04:13]
I didn’t have that same feeling in Silksong,
[04:18]
awkwardly weaving between enemies in Dark
[04:22]
wants you to do, speeding through areas in
[04:27]
bunch of moves specifically designed to help you
[04:32]
of it feeling like cheesing the intended
[04:37]
Now, even as someone who found value in them, it
[04:43]
for tons of people, and this largely comes down
[04:48]
obviously runbacks will feel different to those
[04:52]
compared to those who come closer to 30 or 40.
[04:58]
but also will lead to diminishing
[05:01]
at the actual runback. For many, there is a
[05:06]
getting back to the part they’re stuck on will
[05:10]
like part of the challenge and more like
[05:14]
Unsurprisingly, the more punishing failure is, the
[05:20]
around Silksong often gets boiled down to it
[05:25]
started to point out, it has more to do with how
[05:29]
They are obviously intertwined, but it's not
[05:34]
beyond anything a game has ever done before;
[05:38]
a different hard part where dying on the way
[05:42]
money. It is a tension that is hard to hold and
[05:47]
it seems like for a good amount of people than
[05:52]
Silksong can so easily beget more failure, and
[05:58]
Honestly, I think part of why roguelites
[06:02]
a lot of them do the opposite of this. They
[06:07]
where, yes, you most likely will fail time and
[06:12]
close to even looking like a successful run;
[06:16]
every failure is a chance to improve your
[06:20]
unlocking new moves or anything else that may give
[06:27]
and the consolation is often that the playable
[06:31]
with horizontal progression where its more
[06:35]
having a wider pool of upgrades and
[06:39]
more opportunities to craft powerful builds.
[06:44]
giving players a sort of permission structure
[06:49]
For instance, a pretty common phenomenon with
[06:53]
will come across a boss, be underpowered in
[06:58]
it until they beat it. Typically, bosses like
[07:03]
meant to be barriers that push players to explore
[07:07]
better equipped, you’ve heard all this before.
[07:12]
which isn’t easy for a lot of players to do.
[07:17]
the character's ability over the player's
[07:22]
different when they do come back. If they get too
[07:27]
and so beating the boss won’t feel nearly
[07:32]
made. However, in a roguelite, due to the
[07:36]
with a massive increase in the character’s power,
[07:41]
making it unlikely that the fight will be
[07:45]
it to be harder to deem what deserves more credit
[07:50]
Also, more and more roguelites have started
[07:54]
challenge once the player has started
[07:57]
upgraded their character’s abilities. The Heat
[08:02]
examples of this. Before each run, players can
[08:07]
damage and health increases for enemies to more
[08:12]
time limits—changes that have a significant
[08:17]
challenge players opt-into, customize to their
[08:23]
implement. It lets them increase the challenge
[08:27]
deserves the credit while making it rare to
[08:32]
All of this creates a system that offers a
[08:37]
regardless of skill level, never
[08:40]
exact same thing over and over again. It
[08:42]
To be clear, I am not trying to say that
[08:45]
better than other types—it is just that it's
[08:50]
players to accept because it doesn't leave
[08:55]
A person's tolerance for failure depends
[09:00]
looms larger than most is how much time they
[09:05]
an hour every few nights to play something,
[09:09]
dying to fucking Groal again? Most players
[09:14]
within any given gaming session, and even if
[09:18]
that isn't necessarily going to be felt
[09:23]
The right amount of failure is a hard thing
[09:27]
of a game and the state of mind of the
[09:31]
generally the ideal amount sort of exists on
[09:36]
a boss is when you are on the brink, when
[09:41]
and so, especially with games that aim to be more
[09:46]
times you are willing to fail is relatively low,
[09:51]
Of course, failure isn’t always tied to having
[09:57]
be used to shape what happens next whether
[10:02]
this type of failure may seem like it'd be
[10:05]
their time wasted as it doesn't force them
[10:09]
many seem averse to this approach as well.
[10:14]
to gameplay. If you get thrown into a high
[10:18]
permanent death of an NPC or something,
[10:22]
but failing will be a hard thing to accept. Not
[10:26]
experience but also there is a decent chance that
[10:31]
what you were supposed to do, making it feel less
[10:35]
and more like a miscommunication
[10:38]
Even though plenty of people like to be
[10:42]
they don't necessarily want the
[10:44]
to have a lasting impact. They want to be
[10:49]
and the fear of dealing with longterm
[10:54]
This fear is a big part of why
[10:57]
especially ones that span the entire play
[11:01]
to balance titles to protect against this, a
[11:06]
putting them so far behind that by the time
[11:10]
A fairly common critique I received on my recent
[11:15]
some games that I think would have been better
[11:19]
the ways this fear can play out; what happens
[11:25]
I wish I would have because I think there are
[11:29]
to being forced to start the game over; and that
[11:34]
video which is that no matter how interesting
[11:39]
the discomfort they create will still
[11:43]
For instance, instead of getting a game over,
[11:48]
could simply lead to some other consequence. In
[11:53]
when talking about titles that use time limits
[11:59]
Every character, including your own, only has a
[12:04]
life can be extended through the use of a resource
[12:08]
a good reason to explore despite the time limit
[12:13]
characters alive as possible. However, if the
[12:18]
they are presented with the option to sacrifice
[12:23]
certainly less brutal ways a game could go about
[12:28]
fundamentally change character relationships or
[12:33]
those who live there or anything else that brings
[12:38]
effective ways of providing near unlimited time
[12:42]
it. Another approach that could work with a system
[12:48]
the player continue playing even after running
[12:52]
they get. Depending on the complexity of the game
[12:56]
but it would ensure that the player doesn't miss
[13:03]
Now, the problem with these approaches is that
[13:08]
drastic as sacrificing other characters, doing
[13:13]
you've come to care about, while narratively
[13:18]
a game over, you will pretty much have to do it or
[13:23]
of game simply because you weren't quick enough.
[13:28]
bad ending for your character, this also can feel
[13:32]
is considered the good ending, the true ending,
[13:38]
as most people are probably only gonna play a
[13:43]
doesn't feel worth it for most. This increases the
[13:49]
look up the most efficient path or over powered
[13:54]
Honestly, this sentiment often exists even when
[13:59]
seen with games that have meaningful
[14:02]
most players would say that they want to
[14:06]
I don’t know that that is what they actually
[14:12]
that matter, I think what the majority of folks
[14:17]
want it to play out. Obviously this doesn’t
[14:25]
choice and living with the consequence of that
[14:30]
in control. They want to know that the choice
[14:35]
will get them the best ending or atleast the
[14:39]
you’re only going to play a game once, you
[14:43]
you gave the wrong fatherly advice or because you
[14:48]
What’s weird is that I imagine the majority
[14:52]
and engaging kinds of choices tend to
[14:56]
be is not clear. The kind that gets the
[15:00]
happen. What could go right, what could go wrong,
[15:03]
whether that be based on the things
[15:06]
the character they are playing as values.
[15:10]
posts I’ve read, playthroughs I’ve watched,
[15:19]
There is a reason why major gaming publications
[15:24]
major release that includes choices surrounding
[15:29]
This gets even more complicated when luck is added
[15:34]
of discourse around Baldur’s Gate 3 in regards
[15:40]
scumming. Whether it was to undo the consequences
[15:46]
became a wildly popular way to approach the game.
[15:50]
what players should do when playing a title like
[15:55]
and Dragons, the ultimate example of a game where
[16:00]
the mindset someone approaches a tabletop rpg
[16:05]
game with. While there is a whole cottage industry
[16:10]
a halfway decent group to play with, chances are
[16:15]
craft an experience that feels satisfying, that
[16:21]
that has payoffs for everything. But that
[16:27]
They can’t be as accommodating or nuanced as a
[16:32]
how you felt about how something played out
[16:37]
more harsh because of that. For instance, if you
[16:42]
portal at the start of the game, you just don’t
[16:47]
have to be pretty unlucky to miss in this way, but
[16:52]
chance that the player misreads the situation.
[16:57]
it is going to try to pull them in and miss him
[17:00]
would allow players to focus more on the other
[17:04]
have to navigate situations later on in much
[17:08]
a character as beloved as Gale, one who is vital
[17:14]
will never be a part of theirs. This might work
[17:20]
and games is often thrust upon us, it is near
[17:25]
Obviously this is one of the more extreme
[17:30]
Gate 3, but even with choices that have a
[17:34]
characters or events is hard for players
[17:39]
that make choices more interesting also
[17:43]
avoid falling into them whether that is through
[17:48]
What it always seems to come back to in one way
[17:53]
if their time is being wasted. They don’t want
[17:58]
get back whatever it is they hope to get out
[18:02]
tons of time on things we barely even think about,
[18:07]
different. It's more of an investment; it’s an
[18:11]
promise of control. Of being able to progress
[18:16]
a desired outcome. Failure is what makes this
[18:22]
what in some cases puts it in jeopardy. It is a
[18:28]
And one of the most unfortunate things about it
[18:32]
the least interested in experiencing failure,
[18:38]
Obviously there are many things that go into
[18:42]
to be a correlation between being more skilled at
[18:48]
punishment. It is the search for the sweet spot,
[18:54]
but so often, especially in titles with a single
[18:59]
with the consequences of failure. They aren’t
[19:06]
time after dozens and dozens of hours in a game,
[19:12]
ones getting through with far less friction and in
[19:18]
experience or access to weapons sooner, creating
[19:23]
them. Meanwhile, those a bit less skilled get
[19:27]
stuck for far longer. To be clear, being less
[19:32]
wanting to deal with failure at all; I'd imagine
[19:37]
all the way through, but, I’d imagine many want
[19:42]
punished this often and this severely pushes them
[19:47]
failing the most and those failing the least, wish
[19:52]
While difficulty discourse has long been at
[19:56]
the past couple years it has started to feel a bit
[20:02]
and it's not just that a new group of people who
[20:07]
the conversation; it's that a lot of people who
[20:12]
have started to sour on it. There are a lot
[20:17]
the general mental exhaustion of being a human in
[20:23]
a whole getting older and older thus having less
[20:27]
as far as things directly related to the industry
[20:32]
Dark Souls of it all. Obviously, Dark Souls
[20:37]
to difficulty has been massively influential.
[20:43]
being a niche studio to one of the most popular
[20:49]
indie, AAA, and everything in between, have
[20:54]
not even that there are too many soulslikes now,
[21:00]
it's that more and more games in all types of
[21:05]
leading to the average game now being more
[21:11]
After an era of streamlined titles, the pendulum
[21:17]
to where it was in the 80s and early 90s, but
[21:23]
I don't think this is exactly a bad thing, and I
[21:28]
a bit more punishing, but it feels like we're
[21:33]
audience is interested in engaging with. As
[21:38]
and harder ones have continuously tried to top
[21:44]
failure feels heavier than it has in a long
[21:49]
in life feel heavier now than they have in a
[21:53]
has started to be more pushback; that general
[21:58]
experience within the hobby they turn to in order
[22:04]
Failure makes games better. In some ways it is
[22:10]
it is no easy feat as there is no guarantee that
[22:16]
be respected. And part of this is because what any
[22:22]
will vary greatly depending on countless factors
[22:27]
Not to mention, at the end of the day games
[22:31]
more tragically, with me in mind; they
[22:37]
more specifically for subsections of the nebulous
[22:42]
and those subsections become more varied, more
[22:48]
All of this amplifies the frustration that
[22:53]
for feeling this way. I do think there is value in
[22:59]
are so averse to it that we don't even allow it to
[23:05]
inclination to avoid it, I think it can be hard
[23:10]
of failure we will be okay dealing with. We write
[23:19]
it is quite easy to get pushed too far. This is a
[23:25]
to balance. They are trying to find a line that
[23:31]
to hit even in games that offer players plenty
[23:36]
players are instinctively trying to push against,
[23:39]
way or another. I expect to see games shift
[23:44]
current state of things. Truthfully, I wouldn't be
[23:49]
structures more reminiscent of roguelites, and I
[23:53]
tons of major studios have experimented with them.
[24:04]
and I hope it is just the right amount of
[24:15]
Now, one way I don't want you to be a failure is
[24:20]
you've been struggling to find the perfect gift
[24:26]
to make a move and this video’s sponsor, Displate,
[24:31]
have a massive catalogue of high quality metallic
[24:36]
out, and they are far more durable than any paper
[24:42]
put the protective leaf and magnet on your wall,
[24:47]
with a lot of great properties ranging from The
[24:53]
work from independent artists. Regardless
[24:58]
or even yourself because you deserve nice stuff
[25:04]
from for fans of all sorts of things. Not to
[25:09]
which could be anything from a beautiful photo
[25:15]
in 10 seconds. Either or. Displate offers fast
[25:20]
description you can get 33% off for 1-2 displates,
[25:27]
or more. All in all, Displates look great and are
[25:33]
one for those you love as well as yourself.
[25:43]
For all of you still here, hello. I'd like
[25:48]
possible. I've been doing this for a while now.
[25:52]
this point in the video, you're responsible for
[25:58]
hate…respect. I hope you have a great day and/or