[00:00]
I am very fond of nuclear fusion. I honestly believe it’s the energy source of the future. But it’s not looking good. Nuclear fusion is in deep trouble. Let’s have a look.
[00:12]
What if you could get a subscription for science experiments? You can from today's sponsor, MEL Science. And of course, I have a special offer for you. MEL Science has lovely experiment sets
[00:25]
for children and young learners, and you'll get a new one each month. They cover physics, chemistry, and STEM in general. Each kit includes the equipment and step-by-step instructions.
[00:38]
MEL Science has these dedicated sets on topics like magnetic levitation, polarization, or renewable energy. But they also have more general sets like this one with lab equipment,
[00:51]
including safety glasses. That's a good opportunity to talk about general safety measures. And even I finally look like a proper scientist. I love the MEL Science sets because you get everything together and it just works. My kids are hugely enjoying these little experiments
[01:09]
which they find so much more interesting than what they do at school. And here comes the special offer. If you use the link in the info below or the code SABINE year, you'll get a year
[01:22]
of science for just $22.45 per month until July 4th. And now back to the science news. In the past twelve months, multiple fusion companies have silently changed their plans or moved completion dates into the future.
[01:38]
Zap Energy, for example, is a Seattle-based company that wants to use what’s called the Z-pinch method to generate nuclear fusion. For this, one charges a huge capacitor and then suddenly releases the energy into the fuel gas.
[01:52]
The electricity turns the gas into a plasma and creates lightning bolts that contract until fusion sets in. Theoretically. In May 2021, they announced almost
[02:04]
30 million dollars in funding and were, quote “targeting scientific energy breakeven by 2023.” Well, that didn’t happen, did it? Then, just a few weeks ago they announced that they’re pivoting to nuclear fission. According to
[02:19]
their website “Today Zap is announcing that we’re building not just a fusion company, but an integrated nuclear platform that spans both advanced fission and fusion technologies.”
[02:31]
Then there is Marvel Fusion, a Munich-based company doing laser-driven fusion with ultra-short femtosecond pulses. They’ve raised about 160 million euros,
[02:43]
including from Siemens Energy and the EU Innovation Council. In March, told investors they plan to sell their laser technology for defense, medical, and industrial uses. So not like they are giving up on fusion, but focusing on more immediate payoffs.
[02:57]
They’re also considering relocating to the US. I can’t blame them. In Germany, the first step is to fill out Form B-377 for permission to think about sunlight.
[03:12]
First Light Fusion, a UK-company, has completely given up on their original plan. It started out looking good for them. They successfully demonstrated nuclear fusion by firing a projectile at a fuel target. In 2023, they signed an agreement with the UK Atomic Energy Authority
[03:28]
to build a demonstration facility. But two years later, they published a “strategic update” that said they were “discontinuing the proposed development… to focus on advancing and commercialising its patented amplifier technology”.
[03:43]
Then they put out plans for a new demonstration machine with a vague completion timeline sometime in the 2030s, but also announced they will be selling parts to other companies which they started doing in April. So you see,
[03:57]
there’s a pattern here, fusion companies shifting to selling related technology. The same thing happened with the Australian company HB11 Energy which pursued hydrogen-boron
[04:10]
fusion. When they launched in 2021 they said their program is, “aimed at the Holy Grail of fusion energy research — to demonstrate net energy gain”. But in late 2024, they announced a shift to selling laser and target technologies. In their own words because “few private investors
[04:27]
[are] willing to wait decades for a return. ” Then there are the companies that silently move their dates. Like General Fusion. They’re a Canadian company. In 2021 they announced they
[04:41]
would build a Fusion Demonstration Plant in the UK, with construction starting in 2022 and operations by 2025. Then the timeline slipped to completion in 2027. Then the entire
[04:53]
project just… disappeared. That’s one way to reach confinement. They then instead built a smaller demonstration machine in Vancouver and now aim at a commercial power plant in the mid-2030s.
[05:05]
Where does their money come from? In January, they announced that they plan to put out stocks by the middle of the year. And they’re doing this via a SPAC deal with Spring Valley,
[05:17]
that’s the same company that brought NuScale’s small modular reactors on the stock market! If you don’t know what a SPAC is, I talked about this in an earlier video on quantum computing. Basically it’s a way to circumvent proof of commercial viability.
[05:33]
Then there is Helion Energy, which wants to generate fusion by shooting plasma rings at each other and that is, among others backed by Sam Altman. In 2014, they wrote on their website that they “aim to have a commercial plant operational in six years”. Six years later… their
[05:50]
plan was still to do it six years later. In 2021, they raised half a billion dollars and said they want to generate net electricity from fusion by 2024. Then they said they are “on track” to generate energy “by 2028”, and now say somewhat vaguely “before the end of this decade.”
[06:07]
The US-Company Commonwealth Fusion Systems said in 2021 they want to demonstrate net energy by 2025. Didn’t happen! Their webpage now says it will
[06:19]
achieve net energy “in 2027.” Yeah, hmm, guess we will see about that. You may have noticed a pattern here, it’s that all these companies are American, British or Canadian. This is for one thing because most startups are located in these countries,
[06:34]
but it’s also because companies elsewhere have been more careful with making promises. It’s not that they are actually more successful elsewhere, it’s just harder to pin them down on it. To top it all off, the authors of a recent study in nature report that it is likely
[06:51]
that even if nuclear fusion would generate net energy, it would remain extremely expensive, even more expensive than nuclear fusion. For the record, I think this analysis is too pessimistic because it’s based on the cost trajectory of nuclear fission which I think went
[07:08]
badly for geopolitical reasons not because of technological limitations. But fusion companies have produced something commercially useful: press releases with extremely high energy density.
[07:22]
Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.