[00:01]
Mosul Dam rises 370 feet or 113 meters above
[00:09]
the tallest dams in the Middle East. The dam was
[00:16]
never really stopped. That’s because ever since
[00:22]
has literally been dissolving, nonstop, below
[00:29]
water started flowing through the foundation of
[00:35]
a year later, the volume of seepage was measured
[00:42]
I usually hate to use the olympic-sized
[00:46]
it makes sense because it was enough
[00:52]
And the issue is that, once a process like this
[00:58]
for the past 40 years or so, the problem at
[01:04]
some of the most preeminent engineers across the
[01:09]
and, of course, armed conflict. Failure of a
[01:15]
towns along the Tigris River would be fully wiped
[01:20]
wave would be so massive that even major parts of
[01:27]
submerged. In 2006, the US Army Corps of Engineers
[01:34]
in the world.” That was 20 years ago, and Mosul
[01:40]
And the story of how it got there is fascinating.
[01:55]
Mosul Dam is an earthen embankment dam
[02:00]
built to generate hydropower and store water
[02:05]
is on the west side of the dam with four turbine
[02:11]
sticking up from the plant that absorb changes in
[02:16]
The dam has an outlet structure through the
[02:21]
radial gates here. And an auxiliary spillway with
[02:27]
spillway gates and fuse plugs if you want to learn
[02:32]
The dam itself is impressive, but the rock that
[02:38]
and in many ways, far from ideal. The geology
[02:45]
a sedimentary rock that is widely used
[02:49]
and drywall. What it’s not widely used
[02:55]
the consensus of experts involved on Mosul
[02:59]
all around, a terrible idea. One
[03:04]
“the decision to locate such a major and important
[03:10]
the Mosul Dam site was fundamentally flawed.”
[03:15]
That’s because of a critical property of gypsum,
[03:18]
one that it doesn’t share with many other types
[03:24]
You might be familiar with limestone caves and
[03:30]
subsurface. Some of these can be quite dramatic
[03:36]
Cave in Kentucky. They’re formed because the
[03:42]
as long as it’s a bit acidic, which rainwater
[03:48]
years, that water kind of carves away the earth
[03:54]
is roughly 200 times more soluble in water than
[04:00]
sugar or salt that dissolves almost instantly, but
[04:07]
are accelerated to human timescales in gypsum.
[04:13]
because dissolution isn’t a linear process.
[04:19]
which means more dissolving and so
[04:23]
Many dam failures have resulted from internal
[04:28]
rock carries away particles, leaving voids. This
[04:34]
which I covered in an earlier video. But
[04:39]
by designing filtration systems that
[04:44]
escape the subsurface, you can’t easily
[04:49]
The designers of the dam knew the
[04:53]
and they had a few ideas to address it. One was
[04:58]
the bottom of part of the reservoir. This would
[05:03]
at least in the dam’s immediate vicinity,
[05:08]
the total volume of the flow. However, the volume
[05:14]
layer would be fairly fragile to damage from
[05:19]
was to use a cutoff wall, basically a continuous
[05:26]
The problem was that there were no machines that
[05:31]
of the gypsum. The idea they landed on was
[05:37]
Mosul Dam’s design included a continuous concrete
[05:43]
It had one purpose: to provide access to the
[05:48]
pumps. Political and schedule pressures
[05:53]
before the grouting was complete, but
[05:56]
to the gallery tunnel to continue that process
[06:02]
they underestimated how serious and complex a
[06:08]
As soon as the reservoir filled up, the problem
[06:13]
pools of seepage in the intro, but it wasn’t
[06:19]
the dam as caverns formed in the geology below
[06:25]
those sinkholes started appearing closer
[06:30]
the solution cavities were migrating in the
[06:36]
operators have maintained a continuous grouting
[06:42]
bentonite, and water into the rock below
[06:47]
the voids. It’s basically a nonstop
[06:53]
because grout doesn’t fare well in flowing water
[06:59]
Recognizing the hazard they had created
[07:04]
with a backup solution. Since it was clear that
[07:10]
they would just build another dam downstream
[07:16]
when) Mosul Dam failed. Badush Dam
[07:22]
It would have a hydropower plant and store water
[07:28]
storage pool to protect downstream cities from
[07:35]
halfway finished before the geopolitical
[07:43]
In 2003, a US-led coalition invaded Iraq as
[07:50]
to the September 11th attacks. As a major piece
[07:56]
the coalition worried. Some early reports hinted
[08:02]
as an act of sabotage. But it didn’t take long to
[08:09]
They started coordinating with the US Army
[08:14]
whose report concluded that the risk
[08:18]
the “most dangerous dam in the world” quote
[08:23]
The truth is that the “danger” of a dam is
[08:28]
and it’s not a statistic that’s widely tracked,
[08:33]
a government agency was willing to say it means a
[08:39]
the situation seriously and started working with
[08:45]
the dam. That panel largely came to the same
[08:52]
Coalition forces had bases and equipment
[08:57]
concerning enough that they decided to
[09:01]
inundation area if the dam were to breach. At
[09:07]
was helping the new Iraqi government
[09:11]
including improving the grouting program at
[09:16]
considered a temporary solution, the consensus
[09:22]
to address the foundation problems beyond
[09:27]
Initial efforts by the US government to help at
[09:33]
A few notable examples: The winning contractor
[09:39]
grout) mixing plant design, and somehow
[09:44]
despite it being printed on the front page of
[09:48]
the concrete plants had already been delivered,
[09:53]
to try and convert them into grout mixing
[09:59]
with no ladders or braces. Some weren’t even
[10:05]
for the hoppers had no retaining walls,
[10:10]
and pumping equipment couldn’t even fit into
[10:15]
dam operations staff meant to run all this
[10:20]
a few weeks of training. The oversight
[10:25]
Millions of dollars had been spent on 21
[10:31]
Coalition forces continued efforts to improve
[10:37]
the US was withdrawing troops from the country
[10:43]
back to the Iraqi government. Unfortunately, that
[10:49]
continued to plague the region. In mid-2014,
[10:56]
and Daesh) took over several cities in Northern
[11:03]
Mosul Dam, which was still relying on nearly
[11:09]
safe. That August, ISIS seized control of Mosul
[11:16]
collapse. For more than a week, the dam was out of
[11:22]
what the militants might do (or what they might
[11:28]
Even short-term neglect presented a serious
[11:34]
by Kurdish and Iraqi forces, with the help of US
[11:40]
Iraqi hands, but the surrounding areas weren’t.
[11:47]
the disruption of the workforce at the dam, and
[11:52]
operation wasn’t being maintained. Equipment
[11:58]
used. Voids were going untreated, and concerns
[12:04]
Realizing that the Iraqi government was too
[12:09]
the US decided to stay involved as
[12:15]
the Army Corps of Engineers led a task
[12:19]
and the results were alarming. The US Embassy
[12:25]
saying that the dam had an “unprecedented risk
[12:30]
half-a-million and 1.5 million people along the
[12:37]
crisis unlike almost anything in modern history.
[12:43]
ongoing occupation by the Islamic State, making
[12:49]
able to evacuate to safer areas. Electrical
[12:55]
and poor communication would make things
[13:00]
The Iraqi government tried to downplay the alarm a
[13:06]
Resources said, quote, “The looming danger to
[13:12]
is present in all the world’s dams.” I don’t
[13:17]
actually supported by some kind of analysis, but
[13:23]
hilarious if it weren’t such a serious situation.
[13:29]
what we normally use, and multiplying it by the
[13:34]
of Engineers, you get an expected annual fatality
[13:43]
would anybody consider that acceptable. This is a
[13:49]
large dam projects. This green area generally
[13:55]
making a structure safer. Yellow, you have to be
[14:01]
the minister’s estimate of probability, and the
[14:07]
Mosul Dam would plot somewhere around here on
[14:13]
moniker doesn’t seem like hyperbole when you
[14:18]
Sean MacFarland, “If this dam were in the United
[14:24]
The urgency finally spurred action in 2016.
[14:29]
Iraq awarded a contract to an Italian company
[14:32]
to rehabilitate the structure, including a
[14:38]
grouting program. It was one of the most
[14:43]
with participation from the Iraqi government,
[14:48]
Italian military, and a number of international
[14:54]
engineers involved on the project, and
[14:58]
In the early days of the project, they were
[15:03]
to support the Iraqis who were operating
[15:08]
let them monitor the situation remotely while
[15:14]
The entire project had to happen near the front
[15:20]
continued to unfold in Iraq. Security forces
[15:25]
the dam and supply routes for materials and
[15:31]
but eventually, the project team was able
[15:35]
Over the next few years, all the grouting
[15:40]
piping, electrical systems and drill
[15:45]
Crews drilled more than 5,000 boreholes with
[15:51]
kilometers or 250 miles. 41,000 cubic meters
[15:59]
into the foundation along the entire length of the
[16:05]
inflate a rubber device called a packer using air
[16:11]
borehole and injection pipe. Or you just grout
[16:17]
Then you can pump grout at very high pressure
[16:23]
fissures. You just keep pumping until you reach
[16:29]
that you hold until the grout stops flowing. And
[16:35]
All this work was done using a sophisticated
[16:41]
depth, mix design, flow rate, and quantity of
[16:46]
track progress, identify issues, and visualize
[16:53]
delivery to batching to drilling and injection,
[16:59]
I love unique measurement units, and this project
[17:05]
the contractor would try to inject water into the
[17:11]
is the loss of water of one liter per minute
[17:18]
of 1 megapascal or about 145 psi. For all the
[17:26]
98 percent had values below 3 Lugeons, a massive
[17:34]
The project finished in 2019. It was a 3-year
[17:40]
but Mosul Dam lost its most dangerous
[17:45]
the dam is in a much less precarious position.
[17:51]
Foundations Institute in 2022, highlighting
[17:57]
But this wasn’t like a typical construction
[18:02]
goal was to get the Iraqi government set up to
[18:08]
The rock below Mosul Dam may have a lot more grout
[18:15]
and there’s still a massive reservoir constantly
[18:20]
the rehabilitation project was training Iraqi
[18:27]
despite its magnitude, the project was sort of a
[18:33]
never been considered a permanent solution, and
[18:39]
improvement in the long-term prospects of the
[18:46]
Iraq is still planning for a more permanent
[18:51]
Badush Dam on the map, downstream from
[18:56]
the table if anyone can figure out how to come
[19:00]
Another option is that deep foundation cutoff
[19:06]
would provide a continuous barrier for seepage
[19:11]
These are used on a lot of dams across the
[19:16]
and depth as would be required at Mosul. In 2018,
[19:23]
5 billion dollars, an almost unimaginable
[19:29]
and functions today. Whether the electricity and
[19:36]
capital is something that will probably
[19:41]
the government will keep pumping grout and Dinars
[19:47]
a flawed foundation, but now with much more
[19:54]
One of the trickiest parts of Mosul Dam is that you can’t just see what the subsurface looks like. The Army Corps
[20:01]
of Engineers did a really detailed investigation,
[20:06]
on very limited observations from individual
[20:12]
a challenge for all kinds of engineering projects
[20:19]
My friend Brian at the Real Engineering
[20:24]
“The Anatomy of.” He’s putting everyday
[20:29]
so we can literally see inside. This is
[20:35]
up our favorite gadgets, and if you want to
[20:40]
You probably know about Nebula now, even if
[20:44]
built by and for independent creators. No studio
[20:51]
advertisements driving the content into a single
[20:57]
they’re excited about with as few barriers and
[21:03]
My videos go live on Nebula before they come
[21:08]
was specifically produced for Nebula viewers who
[21:14]
I know there are a lot of streaming platforms
[21:18]
monthly cost to keep track of, but I also know
[21:23]
there is a ton of other stuff on Nebula that
[21:28]
it dead simple: click the link below and you’ll
[21:35]
30 dollars, for an entire year’s access
[21:42]
if you have subscription fatigue, but
[21:45]
you can get a lifetime membership. Pay once
[21:50]
last. If you’re with me that independent
[21:55]
I hope you’ll consider subscribing. Thank you