[00:00]
In 1973, an airliner struck a bird
[00:03]
called a Ruples Griffin vulture, which
[00:05]
on its own isn't that weird. Planes hit
[00:07]
birds pretty regularly during takeoffs
[00:09]
and landings. But this collision
[00:11]
happened at a cruising height of over
[00:13]
11,000 m. That's way above the height at
[00:16]
which most birds fly, which it makes me
[00:19]
wonder, what is the highest a bird can
[00:21]
actually fly. Hi, I'm Cameron and this
[00:24]
is Minute Earth. Birds don't tend to fly
[00:26]
higher than they absolutely need to for
[00:28]
the same reason you don't sprint when
[00:30]
you could walk. It's difficult and
[00:32]
tiring. So, we can't necessarily get the
[00:35]
answer to this question through
[00:36]
observation. I mean, I guess we could
[00:38]
drop a bunch of birds out of airplanes
[00:40]
and see what happens, but our AdSense
[00:42]
revenue definitely isn't going to cover
[00:43]
that. Plus, we're not monsters. So,
[00:46]
let's use our understanding of
[00:47]
aerodynamics, scaling laws, and biology
[00:50]
to science our way to an approximate
[00:52]
answer. There are two things that limit
[00:54]
how high a bird can fly. Its ability to
[00:57]
stay aloft as the air pressure
[00:58]
decreases. And on a much more basic
[01:01]
level, its ability to stay alive as the
[01:03]
temperature and amount of oxygen
[01:05]
decreases. So, first, let's figure out
[01:07]
which bird could survive at the highest
[01:09]
altitude. Oxygen supplies birds the
[01:12]
energy they need to stay warm, but at
[01:13]
higher altitudes, there's less oxygen
[01:15]
available and the temperature is much
[01:16]
colder. So, a bird's ability to survive
[01:19]
high up in the air depends on how
[01:20]
efficiently they use oxygen and how well
[01:22]
they can retain body heat. This paper
[01:24]
measured the oxygen use of a handful of
[01:26]
birds and found that very generally
[01:28]
their overall oxygen use increases with
[01:30]
mass. We can then adjust according to
[01:33]
other traits like how much energy their
[01:35]
flight muscles require and how much
[01:36]
insulation their feathers provide. From
[01:38]
all of this, we can calculate the
[01:40]
altitude at which each bird should
[01:42]
suffer from hypothermia. Let's call this
[01:44]
their popsicle point. If we then compile
[01:46]
a data set of flying birds and plug
[01:48]
their data into these equations, we can
[01:50]
see a general pattern emerge. Larger
[01:52]
birds can theoretically survive at
[01:54]
higher altitudes than smaller birds.
[01:56]
There are exceptions, of course. This is
[01:58]
biology after all, but our calculations
[02:00]
suggest that there are a bunch of birds
[02:02]
that could potentially survive above
[02:04]
10,000 m. And the largest bird in our
[02:06]
data set, the wandering albatross, might
[02:09]
be able to survive as high as 17,000 m.
[02:12]
But remember, we also need to figure out
[02:13]
if any of these birds could actually
[02:15]
stay aloft at such high altitudes.
[02:17]
Because the air is less dense the higher
[02:19]
you go, less air is available at higher
[02:21]
altitudes to push upward against a
[02:23]
bird's wings and create that lift. A
[02:25]
bird's ability to stay a loft high in
[02:27]
the air depends on its weight, size of
[02:28]
its wings, and the shape and angle of
[02:30]
attack of its wings. That's a factor
[02:32]
called the lift coefficient. Combining
[02:34]
all of that tells us how much lift a
[02:36]
bird's wings should generate in still
[02:38]
air at a given altitude. Simple enough
[02:40]
at first. Uh, but while weights and
[02:42]
wingspans and whatnot are easy enough to
[02:44]
measure, the wing shapes and angles
[02:45]
aren't because a bird's wing shape
[02:47]
changes as it flies. I'll save you the
[02:49]
long explanation of my rationale here
[02:51]
and just say that this is about where I
[02:53]
go out on a bit of a limb. The lift
[02:54]
coefficient for the birds in our data
[02:56]
set peaks at about 1.5 or so, and that's
[02:58]
when they're taking off or about to
[03:00]
stall. In other words, when the bird is
[03:02]
trying hardest to generate lift. And
[03:05]
since staying aloft is likely a struggle
[03:06]
at a bird's maximum altitude, this is
[03:08]
probably a pretty good estimate of the
[03:10]
lift coefficient at this point. From
[03:11]
there, we can find the lowest air
[03:13]
pressure at which each bird could
[03:14]
generate sufficient lift to keep its
[03:16]
mass aloft. And then use our friend, the
[03:18]
barometric equation to convert those
[03:19]
numbers to altitudes to estimate the
[03:21]
highest point each bird in our data set
[03:24]
should be able to actually maintain
[03:26]
flight. Let's call this their lift
[03:27]
limit. In general, the smaller birds
[03:30]
have the highest lift limits. The
[03:32]
hulking mute swan would struggle to
[03:33]
generate lift at a mere 3,800 meters,
[03:36]
while the puny sand martin should be
[03:38]
able to glide at nearly 19,000 m. Of
[03:41]
course, air moves and it's not uniformly
[03:43]
dense at given altitudes, so there's
[03:45]
definitely some wiggle room here, which
[03:47]
will be a surprise tool that's going to
[03:49]
help us later. But in any case, a bird
[03:51]
with a higher lift limit should be able
[03:53]
to fly higher than a bird with a lower
[03:55]
one. Now, let's combine our lift limit
[03:57]
data with our popsicle point data. We
[03:59]
can see that lots of birds like the
[04:01]
missile thrush can theoretically fly
[04:02]
super high but would freeze long before
[04:05]
they got there. And then there are a
[04:07]
bunch of other birds like the wandering
[04:08]
albatross that could likely survive at
[04:11]
super high altitudes but wouldn't be
[04:13]
able to actually maintain flight up
[04:14]
there. That leaves us with a small
[04:16]
cluster of birds with relatively high
[04:18]
popsicle points and high lift limits.
[04:21]
Mathematically, these should be the
[04:22]
highest flying birds. And for the most
[04:24]
part, they're geese. The grey lag goose,
[04:27]
the bean goose, the Canada goose, and
[04:28]
the barheaded goose should be able to
[04:30]
fly as high as 8,000 meters or so,
[04:32]
according to our calculations. And this
[04:34]
matches up pretty well with what
[04:36]
scientists have actually observed. Like
[04:38]
during its migration over the highest
[04:39]
mountain range on the planet, the
[04:41]
bar-headed goose can reach altitudes of
[04:43]
over 7,000 m. And then there's the white
[04:46]
str, which based on its popsicle point
[04:48]
and lift limit, is our predicted highest
[04:50]
flying bird. It could potentially fly up
[04:53]
to about 10,500 m. In reality, it
[04:57]
doesn't fly anywhere near that high. But
[04:59]
remember, birds don't necessarily fly as
[05:01]
high as they might be physically capable
[05:03]
of. But wait, what about the Ruples
[05:05]
Griffin? A bird we know for a fact can
[05:08]
fly higher than 11,000 m. Our math
[05:12]
suggests that it is lift limited a lot
[05:14]
lower than that, about 8,200 m. But this
[05:17]
is where theoretical calculations fall
[05:19]
short without some additional real world
[05:20]
knowledge. See, the Ruples Griffin likes
[05:22]
to soar on thermals, warm columns of
[05:25]
rising air that can help birds exceed
[05:27]
their mathematical lift limit, sometimes
[05:29]
even thousands of extra meters up into
[05:31]
the air. Other birds are also known to
[05:33]
ride thermals, but none of the other
[05:35]
high popsicle point birds ride such
[05:37]
supercharged thermals. So, the Ruples
[05:39]
Griffin is likely the bird capable of
[05:41]
the highest flight. With the right
[05:42]
thermal, it might even reach its very
[05:45]
generous popsicle point of 15,000
[05:47]
meters. Turns out that bird might have
[05:49]
had a lot of climbing left to do.
[05:55]
You might have noticed that this video
[05:57]
is chalk full of all sorts of
[05:59]
calculations that I basically ripped my
[06:01]
hair out trying to make sure I got
[06:02]
right. It would have been great if I had
[06:04]
a brilliant tutor sitting next to me
[06:06]
guiding my learning. Wait, there is a
[06:08]
brilliant tutor. If you regularly watch
[06:10]
our videos, you're probably aware of the
[06:13]
awesome interactive learning platform
[06:14]
that is Brilliant. Now, Brilliance
[06:16]
lessons are guided by a super
[06:18]
intelligent personal tutor for math and
[06:20]
coding. You can now learn hard subjects
[06:22]
with one-on-one feedback whenever you
[06:25]
want to fill the gaps and build your
[06:27]
confidence. Click the link below or scan
[06:29]
the QR code to get started with
[06:31]
Brilliance Tutor for free. You can
[06:32]
upgrade to premium to unlock all
[06:34]
courses. And Minuteear's viewers can
[06:36]
save an additional 20% off an annual
[06:39]
subscription at brilliant.org/mminar.
[06:42]
Thanks Brilliant.