[00:00]
When I first heard of small nuclear reactors, I thought they're really going to fix a problem. But in the past years, it's become increasingly clear that they're creating more problems
[00:12]
than they solve. At this point, small modular reactors are basically dead. It's just that investors haven't yet all noticed. I have a secret and the time has come to tell you about it. I'm a regular reader of IEEE Spectrum
[00:29]
magazine and I'm happy to say they've been sponsoring this video. IEEE is the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, and Spectrum is their flagship magazine. It's not your average popular science magazine. This is really in-depth coverage by experts and
[00:46]
it's a must-read if you want to stay up to date on robotics, electric vehicles, AI or microchips just to name a few examples. And you know what? If you look at what other YouTubers make videos
[00:58]
about, I'm pretty sure that a lot of them are reading the same magazine. As you can see, I prefer reading them in print. I just feel like I can think better that way. I'm not so secretly convinced that engineers are really running the world. And if you want to
[01:14]
know what the future will bring, then you should definitely get a subscription to it e Spectrum. All you need to do is use my link in the description. And now back to the science news.
[01:26]
Nuclear fission power doesn’t create carbon dioxide. This makes it the best currently available technology to replace the baseload in electric grids. Unfortunately, nuclear power plants have historically been more expensive
[01:40]
and took somewhat longer to build than modern gas power plants. were supposed to solve this problem. They should be small enough so that they can be mass-produced in a factory and then transported to the desired location. It’d
[01:56]
be a great solution not just for communities but also for large factories or data centres. Superficially, it looks great and especially the current president of the United States, Donald
[02:08]
Trump, has pushed for their rapid deployment. Just in June, the “Trump Administration celebrated achieving President Trump's ambitious goal” of having 3 small nuclear reactors reach criticality
[02:20]
and announced that “The Golden Era of American Nuclear Energy Has Arrived”. The US government just put another billion dollars into the startup X-energy that is also backed by Amazon. Enthusiasm over small nuclear reactors isn’t just to be found in the United States. The British
[02:37]
government announced a few months ago that they’re putting two point six billion pounds to its SMR programme. The Russians have two operating ones and just started preparing the site for another
[02:50]
one in Uzbekistan. A Finnish company wants to build the first AI data centre powered by SMRs in Idaho. And the EU has announced yet another strategy, structured around nine key actions,
[03:02]
whose central pillar is an alliance. You get the picture, small modular reactors are sexy. The problem is… all of this is very heavily subsidized by governments. And when you look at the companies that weren’t part of the financial windfall,
[03:17]
it’s not going great. The French SMR startup Naarea filed bankruptcy in January. The US company Ultra Safe Nuclear Corporation filed for bankruptcy a few months earlier, and NuScale has
[03:29]
dropped its original plan. The UK company Moltex Energy is insolvent and close to bankruptcy. Now you may say, okay, but startups fail all the time, the fittest will survive. I agree but it
[03:43]
drives home the point that small modular reactors haven’t yet proved their supposed main advantage, which is that they’re supposedly cheaper. A group of nuclear engineers just published a paper in Nature communication in which they analysed the expected costs of small modular reactors.
[04:00]
Even taking into account that the costs are expected to fall if the technology matures, they still find that, quote “SMRs are not competitive in current U.S. electricity markets” and “dedicated power production is uneconomic.”
[04:15]
And the French government has actually cut back on their small modular reactor program, while a committee of the senate has warned that as things currently go we might see “a series
[04:27]
of bankruptcies among nuclear startups” unless there’s more governmental backup. The problem is that while it’s reasonable to expect that small nuclear reactors, once a technology is established, could be rolled out faster,
[04:42]
it isn’t all that clear they’d also be cheaper, per energy produced. The issue is that the smaller the actual nuclear reactor, the more shielding you need relative to its size. And if you stack several of them you’ll basically be duplicating efforts. For most
[04:57]
products you get a cost advantage when you make them bigger, not smaller. Add to this that much of the delay with building nuclear power usually isn’t the actual construction, it comes from safety and environmental regulations that small modular reactors will not circumvent.
[05:13]
My takeaway from all this is basically, if you want to make nuclear power cheaper, start with large power plants, and then try to make the economics work out for the smaller ones. In practice what we might be seeing though is a sort of hybrid,
[05:27]
in which the reactors are small and parts of it are factory produced, but not the full thing. In summary, the golden era for nuclear power may have arrived, alright,
[05:39]
but a lot of this gold is coming from your taxes.