[00:00]
The Apothecary Diaries isn't a romance
[00:02]
anime, but it might be the one that
[00:04]
fixes romance anime. Instead of chasing
[00:06]
shojo tropes and dramatic love
[00:08]
triangles, this show goes the other way.
[00:11]
It's slower, it's weirder, but its
[00:12]
success gravels even bigname shownen.
[00:16]
So, today we are breaking down three
[00:17]
ways the Apotic Diaries flips ramen
[00:19]
storytelling on its head and make it
[00:22]
better through psychology, history, and
[00:24]
the subtle role Romans plays in Nachi
[00:26]
Huga storytelling. And through that
[00:28]
we'll see that we don't necessarily need
[00:30]
more love stories but we need stories
[00:33]
that make us better at
[00:35]
loving. Technically the apothecary
[00:38]
diaries is a san aimed at adult men but
[00:41]
you wouldn't be wrong for thinking it
[00:42]
borrows a few tricks from shojo
[00:45]
especially when it comes to mama and
[00:46]
jinshi's relationship. Just look at this
[00:49]
bishodon. androgynous, impossibly
[00:51]
pretty, wanted by women, men, and
[00:53]
because he's that special, he's
[00:55]
hopelessly drawn to a flat gremlin that
[00:57]
looks at him like looking at a corrupt
[00:59]
politician. Normal Shojo stuff right
[01:01]
there. But we really need to start
[01:03]
thanking Nachu Huga. Because while she
[01:04]
bothers the surface appeal of shojo, she
[01:08]
completely one of its most brain melting
[01:11]
tropes. To understand what I mean, let's
[01:13]
talk about episode 36. Yeah, it's the
[01:17]
frog scene. In that episode, the mama
[01:19]
falls on top of Ginhi. Nice. But Mama
[01:22]
then realizes something horrifying.
[01:24]
Gingshi is not a new nuke. He is in fact
[01:28]
packing substantially big trouble. But
[01:31]
Gingshi is fully enjoying the moment
[01:33]
because one nice and two he has been
[01:36]
preparing to tell Mama who he actually
[01:38]
is. So he thinks this is the best
[01:40]
chance. And just right when Jyn is going
[01:43]
to say it, Mama stops him. The worst she
[01:46]
can say is no. And mama be like, "Bet."
[01:48]
Mama can even commit ethical war. She'd
[01:51]
rather say someone's frog is okay.
[01:53]
Detonate a man's soul, possibly stops an
[01:56]
entire lineage to be born than
[01:58]
succumbing herself into something she
[01:59]
doesn't want to know. The burn is so
[02:01]
bad. Jini is mad at her for like three
[02:04]
episodes. But again, we should be
[02:06]
grateful because thank god in the frog
[02:09]
scene, they didn't go with the most hair
[02:11]
pulling trope in ramen's anime,
[02:14]
miscommunication.
[02:16]
Ginshi knows exactly why Mama crushed
[02:18]
his confidence. Mama knows exactly what
[02:20]
Ginshi was trying to do. No one's
[02:22]
clueless here. Look, miscommunication,
[02:24]
it can work when done right. It can be
[02:26]
funny and can make a somewhat meaningful
[02:29]
conflict. The apocators also used it,
[02:31]
but the tone was more comedic than
[02:33]
anything. But if they were to use it
[02:36]
here, it would ruined everything.
[02:40]
Because this isn't a story about high
[02:42]
schoolers not getting each other. It's
[02:44]
about what happens when you do
[02:46]
understand someone and still clash.
[02:49]
Ginhi is ready to close the distance.
[02:51]
He's been hiding behind layers of
[02:53]
secrets. His name, his status,
[02:55]
everything about himself except a couple
[02:57]
of slip-ups are a lie. But now he's
[02:59]
decided. No more hiding. He wants to be
[03:02]
honest. The motive is clear for us to
[03:04]
see. But on the other hand, Momo, she
[03:08]
wants the opposite. She's in denial. She
[03:10]
wants plausible deniability more than
[03:12]
anything. She's chasing survival.
[03:14]
Emotional distance is how she stays
[03:17]
safe. But both of those conflicting
[03:20]
attitudes. They're both right in their
[03:22]
own way. And that's what makes this frog
[03:25]
scene moment a real crossroads. Either
[03:28]
Momo opens the door and lets Gingi in or
[03:31]
Jini gives up, realizing that for
[03:33]
obvious reasons, they're just not meant
[03:36]
to be. Juni thinks if he just explains
[03:38]
himself, things will work out. Mama
[03:41]
thinks if she stays irrational, she
[03:43]
won't get hurt. But here's the thing.
[03:45]
It's really obvious that emotions don't
[03:47]
care about your logic. And that's where
[03:49]
the real story between these two begins
[03:52]
that can encapsulate the bigger picture
[03:54]
of Momo and Gin's romance
[03:58]
story. So the Apocaris is blowing up
[04:01]
right now, bigger than ever. So
[04:03]
naturally, the other Natu Huga is also
[04:06]
getting her moment in the spotlight. She
[04:08]
gave this really thoughtful interview
[04:10]
with Duffini magazine. It was translated
[04:12]
to English by Twitter user Kayuzuki. The
[04:15]
interview was pretty extensive as far as
[04:17]
I know, but I want to focus on just one
[04:20]
line that perfectly captures how she
[04:22]
fused the romance in her story. In my
[04:25]
opinion, they don't even have time for
[04:27]
romance. So, it's not just will they or
[04:30]
won't they. The bigger picture of Mamo
[04:32]
and Ginhi's romance is why would they
[04:35]
when everything say don't. So the
[04:38]
biggest hurdle in their romance isn't
[04:40]
Mamo's reluctance but the logic behind
[04:42]
it. And that logic is heavily inspired
[04:45]
by the real world history of love. You
[04:49]
see love is such a central topic in our
[04:51]
modern lives. But historically we only
[04:53]
started appreciating love around the
[04:55]
17th century. Before that love wasn't
[04:58]
something you chased. You made it.
[05:00]
Loving your spouse was considered
[05:02]
immoral and stupid. Sounds familiar?
[05:05]
Well, yeah, because in the Apothecary
[05:07]
Diaries, although it's not that extreme,
[05:09]
love is a liability and is especially
[05:12]
apparent in episode 12 when Ginshi is
[05:15]
supposed to fire Mama from the inner
[05:17]
court, we got to see Ghanian's take on
[05:20]
Ginsi and Mamo's
[05:26]
relationship. Even when Gausan finally
[05:28]
admits that, okay, Ginsi is too far gone
[05:31]
to treat her like a toy or a pawn
[05:32]
anymore, he's not thrilled, but he knows
[05:35]
there's no going back. Poor guy is just
[05:37]
watching his boss simp himself into
[05:39]
career threatening chaos. That also
[05:40]
includes his own career, by the way.
[05:43]
That's Gaus. Also, look at Momo. Momo
[05:46]
gets it. Rationally speaking, it's just
[05:48]
dumb. We talked about it before. So,
[05:50]
what's the answer to that? What actually
[05:52]
moved the ramens here if the setting
[05:54]
itself is against it? What they need is
[05:57]
a bit of insanity. The Romance works
[06:00]
because it's Ginshi and Ginshi is a
[06:02]
train wreck. He's childish. He's
[06:04]
problematic. He's the inner court's
[06:05]
poster boy. But he's also the kind of
[06:07]
guy would lose two of the emperor's
[06:10]
favorite concubines to poisoning if Mama
[06:12]
wasn't around to save his ass. But it's
[06:14]
because he's such a mess in the first
[06:16]
place that this love story can even
[06:18]
happen. Because everyone else in the
[06:20]
story, they put duty first, interest,
[06:23]
and affection last. So the only people
[06:25]
who dare take love seriously in this
[06:27]
world are the insane ones. You know who
[06:30]
else that dare take love seriously?
[06:32]
Lakan. Think about it. Also, Lady Fuo
[06:35]
from episode 3. If Natsu Huga played it
[06:38]
100% realistic, this romance wouldn't
[06:41]
survive episode 20. There's no happy
[06:43]
ending there. Just Mamo and Ginsi
[06:45]
growing more and more distant every
[06:47]
single episode. Or maybe she would try
[06:50]
to salvage it by turning Ghi into one of
[06:52]
those stereotypical male leads. Super
[06:54]
aloof but somehow only emotionally
[06:56]
vulnerable to the female lead types. You
[06:59]
know the kind. Cold Duke of the north,
[07:01]
black hair, never smiles. His mother's
[07:04]
name is Martin. Inside we get Gingshi, a
[07:06]
multi-layer childish, conflicted
[07:08]
personality which opens up nicely to the
[07:11]
opportunity of a romance with MMO. I
[07:14]
know it sounds like I'm roasting Gingi
[07:16]
right now, like this romance is just a
[07:17]
childish love. But plot twist, this
[07:20]
chaotic man might actually be the
[07:22]
perfect blueprint for real love. Not
[07:25]
because of the wealth, not the looks,
[07:26]
even the frog's eyes, but it's because
[07:28]
Ginshi's love is emotionally risky,
[07:31]
weirdly modern, and actually backed by
[07:33]
actual relationship
[07:35]
psychology. So, we already touched on
[07:37]
the history of love before, how love
[07:39]
used to be treated like a disease, but I
[07:41]
left out the next part of it because
[07:43]
honestly, it's just depressing. So the
[07:46]
story is in the 1800s people were like,
[07:49]
"Hello, we have toilets now." And
[07:51]
weirder than that, we also have this
[07:53]
human rights thingy. So maybe we can
[07:56]
like marry people we actually love now.
[07:58]
And so after that, marriage for love
[08:00]
started to become the trend. It made
[08:02]
sense, right? Until we realized that we
[08:04]
screwed up because we didn't just start
[08:07]
valuing love, we started worshiping it.
[08:09]
We made love into this divine fantasy
[08:12]
and marriage because of that become less
[08:15]
and less stable because it doesn't
[08:17]
fulfill all of society's crazy wish list
[08:19]
and all people marry less than ever. One
[08:22]
obvious reason is because as individuals
[08:25]
people fantasize about love too much. So
[08:28]
lots of people just wing it because we
[08:30]
don't study fantasy. So love become this
[08:33]
DIY thing with no manual whatsoever. But
[08:36]
the problem about love, especially
[08:38]
marriage, is once it breaks you, you're
[08:41]
less happier than ever. But somehow in
[08:44]
the middle of all this, Gingshi is out
[08:46]
here being a better partner than half of
[08:48]
us. Yes, he's dramatic. Yes, he's
[08:50]
emotionally unwell. But here's the
[08:52]
thing. First, look at the ancient love.
[08:54]
Compared to the ancient love where
[08:56]
couples act like polite co-workers, the
[08:58]
childish Gingi is far better at love.
[09:01]
What quote unquote rational love means
[09:03]
is distance and suspicion. And now
[09:06]
compared to modern love, Chini commits.
[09:09]
He knows that for him to go further with
[09:12]
Momo, he has to work for it. No
[09:14]
fantasizing about happily ever after,
[09:16]
it's not going to be pretty. And that's
[09:18]
really clear from his side. If we look
[09:20]
at the actual relationship psychology,
[09:22]
that's exactly how we make love works.
[09:25]
This entire video is backed by research,
[09:28]
even from the first section. Look,
[09:29]
section one, hiding stuff from your
[09:31]
partner kills relationship. And then we
[09:33]
look at Gingi. Jinshi is literally
[09:35]
risking his identity to get closer to
[09:37]
Momo. Correct move. But what about his
[09:40]
childishness? The second point,
[09:42]
ironically, that's also a green flag
[09:44]
because love needs insanity. Not
[09:47]
full-blown, but if people want
[09:49]
long-lasting love, I'm talking about
[09:50]
like 50, 60 years of love. It's
[09:53]
possible. And that insanity actually has
[09:56]
a name. positive sentiment override. It
[10:00]
means you assume the best of your
[10:01]
partner even when they miss up.
[10:03]
Honestly, that's such a green flag for a
[10:05]
partner. The biggest green flag you
[10:07]
could ever ask. So yeah, this entire
[10:09]
video is secretly researchbacked. I just
[10:12]
didn't tell you earlier because oh yeah,
[10:14]
research. Oh yeah, studies. I want to
[10:17]
see people fight. And maybe, just maybe,
[10:19]
that's what Natihuga meant by this. In
[10:22]
the interview we talked about before,
[10:24]
she said that she picked ancient China
[10:26]
setting because of its romantic allure.
[10:29]
And what's more romantic than loving
[10:31]
someone in a place where you're not
[10:33]
supposed