[00:00]
The Guardian recently published an article with one hell of a headline: “We economists have done the maths: growth is a doomed strategy.” One of the authors is Joseph Stiglitz, who has won a Nobel Prize in economics. This is
[00:16]
a group of “degrowthers”. I think these people are dangerous. Let me explain. Degrowth, in a nutshell, is the idea that economic growth is not sustainable and societies must stop aspiring to it to save the environment and with that,
[00:32]
themselves. The thought is by no means new, it goes back to the early 70s when the Club of Rome published its now famous “Limits of Growth” report that said basically: Our planet is finite, resources are finite, therefore economies can’t keep on growing forever.
[00:48]
I’ll tell you in a moment why that’s wrong. More important is that in the past decade, the “degrowth” movement has merged with other weird ideologies. I stumbled onto this coincidentally some years ago when I made a video explaining why putting
[01:05]
a price on carbon is the only chance we have to stop climate change. In response I was educated that this is bad because capitalism isn’t about capital, oh no, capitalism is the patriarchy.
[01:20]
I looked at what these people were onto, and I fell into a rabbit hole of ideological mush. The website Degrowth.info says that it’s a “field of academic research“ which “exposes
[01:32]
the interconnection of systems of domination such as capitalism, extractivism, colonialism, and patriarchy”. Some examples of titles that have been published in this research area are “Towards a Feminist Decolonial Degrowth Approach” and “Why degrowth needs Black ecology.”
[01:49]
The Degrowth Journal expects prospective editors to commit to anti-capitalism and to embrace intersectionality because we don’t want to spoil peer review with objectivity.
[02:02]
You get the picture: It’s the loony end of woke academia. A review article from 2024 found that 90% of papers on the topics are opinions. That number might be somewhat of an exaggeration, but
[02:14]
there’s no doubt that a lot of what gets published under the name of degrowth is not proper science. The recent piece in the Guardian, in comparison, is fairly reasonable. The
[02:26]
authors argue that “Growth has become decoupled from shared prosperity” which is largely wrong. Poverty has declined dramatically globally in the past 50 years thanks to economic growth,
[02:39]
and the countries where poverty rates are still high are mostly those where growth has been slow. Capitalism has led to dramatic progress, better nutrition, better medicine, better education. And
[02:51]
yet in some countries, like the United States, we see a persistent income inequality that keeps a large share of the population in poverty. The authors of the Guardian piece also write that
[03:03]
growth is “ecologically unsustainable” because you can’t have endless expansion on a finite planet. This is the basis of the degrowth idea. But this isn’t true. For one thing,
[03:15]
we are using a ridiculously tiny part of Earth’s resources at the moment, we have literally barely scratched the surface, so even if resources are theoretically finite in practice we long haven’t reached the end. But more importantly, economic growth doesn’t measure
[03:30]
expansion or even the amount of resources used. It can come about by a more efficient or smarter use of resources. And of course you can beat the limits the Elon way by going off the planet.
[03:42]
The authors then conclude that “Poverty is manufactured” which isn’t totally wrong but it’s idiotic to exclusively blame capitalism for the remaining poverty. Governmental policy obviously
[03:54]
affects poverty. But so does war, debt, natural disaster, and ideological drivel like “degrowth.” enough. But at least I know how to look at scientific journals and I can tell you
[04:10]
that there is basically no serious research on degrowth. There are at most a handful of semi-serious papers that investigate degrowth scenarios and vaguely conclude that they’re kind of possible if you try really hard and no one chops off your head while you try.
[04:26]
The most closely related reasonable economics literature is instead about “decoupling”, that is the idea that you can continue growth without exploiting the environment. And there are
[04:39]
some hopeful examples for this, such as multiple countries that have decreased carbon dioxide output despite maintaining economic growth. But decoupling is about maintaining growth.
[04:51]
If that still doesn’t convince you, here are some reactions of economists on X to the Guardian piece. Here we have Vincent Geloso, a professor for economics who writes “I have written papers
[05:03]
debunking the works of half these authors… All three for being sloppy and/or outright incompetent.” There is Pedro Santa Clara professor of finance, who points out the problems with the article and concludes “Growth is the only anti-poverty program that has ever worked.”
[05:20]
And then there’s assistant professor Andrew Jonelis who points to a paper whose authors have “done the maths” showing that, quote “any cross-national measure of human material wellbeing … will have a statistical relationship with country GDP per capita”.
[05:37]
So why am I telling you about this? Because I feel like I’ve been too quiet about all the craziness that I’ve seen in academia in the past 10 years. And this particular ideology is outright harmful.
[05:50]
Capitalism is the most important emergent feature that the human species has produced, yet, right after languages. It’s a decentralized self-organized system to distribute resources that works whether or not people understand how it works,
[06:06]
which is its beauty. Maybe it’s not the best system, but so far we haven’t found a better one. And “make everyone poorer on purpose” strikes me as an unusually aggressive beta test. I read a lot of news every day and that used to be really tedious because a lot of headlines
[06:23]
repeat and it's difficult to tell what quality the articles are. But today's sponsor, Ground News, has really made my news reading so much better. Ground News is a news platform that collects
[06:35]
news from all over the world. It really saves me a lot of time because I don't have to sort through a dozen headlines on the same story. I can just get a quick summary and fact check for all the coverage. And ground news also gives you a lot of extra information at one glance. An
[06:53]
interesting recent example is the press coverage of California's new AI laws. Ground news gives you a comparison of what the political left and political right focuses on. In this case,
[07:06]
interestingly, while there are nuances in the focus, pretty much everyone agrees that voluntary commitments are insufficient and mandatory standards are needed. This summary is super
[07:18]
useful and really saves me a lot of time. Ground News also gives you a factuality check for each news item, tells you who owns the media outlets and where the news has appeared. Ground News also
[07:30]
has this interesting feature called blind spot. This collects news which has been covered only on one side of the political spectrum. I found ground news super useful for putting news into context
[07:43]
quickly. And of course, I have a special offer for you. That's a 40% discount on the Vantage plan which gives you access to all their features. All you need to do is use my link ground.news/sabine
[07:57]
or use the QR code so they'll know I sent you. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.