AI Summary
A new Princeton study suggests global warming could lead to fewer tropical cyclones, the seeds of hurricanes. The video explains the research methodology, regional variations, and the scientific consensus, concluding that while the number of storms may drop, their intensity could increase.
Chapters
A Princeton University analysis concludes that global warming means fewer tropical cyclones, the seeds of hurricanes.
This year, there have been only 5 storms in the Atlantic, and no hurricanes. Meteorologists attribute this to the El Niño phase, which dampens hurricane activity.
Climate models disagree widely: at 2°C warming, predictions range from 20% fewer storms to 10% more. The authors instead compared warming predicted by each model with cyclone numbers, finding more warming leads to fewer cyclones.
Globally, the number of tropical cyclones decreases, but in the Northern Hemisphere it increases, while in the Southern Hemisphere it decreases. Hurricane numbers are also likely to decrease.
Hurricanes need warm water, moist air, favorable winds, and rotation. Global warming changes these factors in opposite directions—warmer air carries more moisture, but circulation changes work against formation.
A 2020 WMO assessment of 27 studies found 22 predicted a decrease in global tropical cyclone numbers. The IPCC also concluded, with medium confidence, that frequency would decrease or stay unchanged, but intensity (average and peak wind speeds) and the proportion of very strong hurricanes would likely increase.
The prediction is robust because it doesn't depend heavily on model details; the growth of tropical cyclones is a simpler phenomenon than regional drought or heat domes.
Mentioned in this Video
💡 Key Takeaways
Surprising decrease in tropical cyclones
Challenges common assumptions about climate change effects, sparking interest in the evidence.
Model-relative analysis method
Offers a solution to the problem of model disagreement, making predictions more robust.
01:43Majority of studies support decrease
Shows the finding is not isolated but backed by a scientific consensus (22 of 27 studies).
03:24Fewer but worse hurricanes
Nuanced conclusion that balances frequency decrease with intensity increase, critical for risk assessment.
03:52Full Transcript
[00:00] Global warming means fewer tropical cyclones, that are the seeds of hurricanes. That’s the conclusion of a new analysis from researchers at Princeton University. Yes, you heard that right,
[00:12] fewer. Finally some good news from climate change? Let’s have a look. Hurricanes and typhoons form near the equator from small circulations called tropical cyclones. Hurricanes and typhoons are really the same thing,
[00:26] just that the former is in the Atlantic, the latter in the Pacific Ocean. An average year has about 8 tropical cyclones by this time of the year, 3 of which grow to hurricanes. This year, there have only been 5 growing to the size of storms in the Atlantic Ocean,
[00:42] and not a single hurricane. Some have thanked Donald Trump for this achievement. Meteorologists have said that the reason is most likely the current climate phase called El Niño,
[00:54] which tends to dampen hurricane activity. But of course this raises the question of whether we are seeing some long-term changes here. the more the climate warms, the fewer tropical cyclones form.
[01:10] The climate models all make widely different predictions. Depending on which model you pick, at 2°C of global warming you could get anything from about 20% fewer storms to 10% more.
[01:27] But, the authors say, it makes no sense to just compare models this way. This is because the models themselves disagree about how much warming a given amount of greenhouse gas emissions will produce, and we still don’t know which one is right. So
[01:43] they did something else instead. They looked at how much warming each model predicted by the end of the century, and what happened to the number of tropical cyclones. And they found that the more warming a model predicted, the more their numbers fell.
[02:00] That’s the global average. In the Northern Hemisphere, the number actually increases, whereas in the Southern Hemisphere it decreases. So how many of them grow to hurricanes? Again, model
[02:12] evaluations suggest that the number of hurricanes is likely to decrease, rather than increase. Now you may wonder why that is, but as so often with climate models, it’s complicated,
[02:24] it’s not one single factor. Hurricanes need several conditions to come together. They need warm water, moist air, favourable winds, and enough rotation in the atmosphere to get going. Global warming changes all of these things, but not in the same direction. Warmer air carries
[02:42] more water and greater humidity favours hurricane formation. But changes in atmospheric circulation work against it. Still, the models indicate that hurricanes are likely to become less common.
[02:55] So finally a good result from climate change? What are we to make of this? This result isn’t as controversial as it may seem. That global warming could mean fewer tropical cyclones has been suggested before, but the results have been
[03:11] rather mixed. An assessment from the World Meteorological Organization in 2020 looked at 27 studies and found that the overall range of projections was huge. But the majority of studies,
[03:24] 22 of them, predicted a decrease in the global number of tropical cyclones with warming. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change also concluded,
[03:36] albeit only with medium confidence, that the global frequency of tropical cyclones would decrease or remain roughly unchanged with increasing global warming. They also found, though, that the average and peak wind speeds are likely to increase,
[03:52] and that the proportion of very strong hurricanes is likely to increase as well. In a nutshell: more warming means fewer hurricanes,
[04:04] but worse ones. OK, but how far can we even trust these models? Well, you know that I am not a climate scientist, and I have said previously that
[04:16] I have limited faith in the exact predictions of these models. The predictions for just how much warming we might see differ by several degrees, and most of the models are bad with predicting the frequency of extreme weather events anyway, so why would you trust anything they say?
[04:34] I predict some extreme events coming up in the comment section, but I think that in this case it is a fairly robust prediction exactly because it doesn’t depend all that much on the details of the models. The growth of tropical cyclones is a simpler phenomenon than, say,
[04:50] regional drought or heat domes. This is why the models almost all point in the same direction. Will we see hurricanes in Europe as well? Almost certainly not. We’re just too far away from
[05:02] the equator. Even if there is a tropical storm headed our way, by the time it has reached us, it has lost much of its strength. It can still be a severe storm though, and it’s likely that Europe will see more of these in the future. Americans meanwhile will have
[05:18] to wait for President Trump’s upcoming executive order on atmospheric circulation. I spend a lot of time online, and I haven't always been careful. It's happened repeatedly
[05:30] that some of my private data leaked. This is why I'm now signed up to Incogni. You see, the problem is that big companies called data brokers make money from collecting and selling
[05:42] your private information. So, each time you open a website, it'll try to collect data about who you are and where you are and what other websites you've visited. Most countries have laws
[05:54] against that and you can ask for your data to be removed, but doing this takes up a lot of time. Incogni will do it for you. They now cover more than 420 brokers and will get you out of their
[06:07] databases. They'll keep on doing that and if you want send you a monthly risk assessment report. They now also have a custom removal feature where you can submit specific websites and I've used that a lot. Incogni has made my life better in a simple and straightforward way. If
[06:25] that sounds like something you could need too, use my code SABINE or the custom link in the info because that'll get you 60% off. Stay safe. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.