[00:00]
Our galaxy contains about 10 times as much dark matter as normal matter. That’s what we thought. But a team of astrophysicists just found that new data about the Milky Way isn’t compatible either with dark matter or its biggest competitor,
[00:16]
modified gravity. Ok now then what? Let’s have a look. Stay around until the end for a special offer that will bring your coding skills to an entirely new level with boot.dev. Dark matter
[00:30]
is a supposedly invisible substance that fills up the universe and makes itself noticeable only through its gravitational pull. Astrophysicists believe that it makes up about 85% of matter, on average. But it is not evenly distributed and clumps in galaxies where it forms big,
[00:46]
mostly spherical, halos that usually extend far beyond the reaches of the galaxies’ visible stars. think that dark matter exists is that galaxies rotate too fast.
[01:00]
Going by standard gravity, one expects that as you move away from the centre of a galaxy, the gravitational pull gets weaker. And if you do the math, this means that the stars out there should orbit slower around the centre. This relation between the star’s distance from
[01:16]
the galactic centre and its orbital speed is called a ‘rotation curve’. In reality, the speeds of stars don’t drop as fast with the distance from the centre as they should. Instead, they become almost constant, leading to what is called a ‘flat rotation curve’.
[01:32]
This means the gravitational pull of the galaxy is stronger than we think. Hence, dark matter must do it. It’s not just that, from the rotation curves one can extract an approximate
[01:44]
distribution of the dark matter. And the huge spherical dark matter halos fit the data best. This is also where the estimate for the amount of dark matter in the Milky Way comes from, from the rotation curve of the stars around us. But a new paper that now appears says
[02:01]
that actually the rotation curve beyond the approximate location of our own solar system drops in a “Keplerian” way, that is, with the slope you get from standard gravity. You see the issue in this figure. This blue line is what dark matter predicted. This data
[02:16]
here doesn’t fit. The dark matter halo that we’ve been told surrounds us doesn’t seem to be there. If nothing else, it’s the largest missing-object report ever filed. It’s not just that the dark matter hypothesis fits badly with the data. The data are also
[02:33]
incompatible with the alternative explanation, modified Newtonian dynamics, MOND for short. In MOND, the gravitational pull in the outer parts of galaxies is stronger than what Einstein’s
[02:46]
general relativity predicts. Dark matter and MOND disagree about the reason, but both explain why the rotation curves are almost flat. The new Milky Way measurements say that the curve just isn’t
[02:58]
flat. As they write in the paper, if correct, this would “challenge both ΛCDM and MOND”. Though really it is a bigger problem for MOND. Because the data do not say that dark matter is
[03:10]
absent in the Milky Way. It still seems to be there near the centre. It’s just that if you go further out, away from the centre, then the supposed halo doesn’t seem to be there. If the data and its interpretation are correct, then the Milky Way would only
[03:25]
be about three quarters dark matter, which is less than the cosmological average. This is hard to explain with dark matter because it has it that galaxies form because dark matter clumped there. However, dark matter is such a flexible and underdetermined theory I am sure
[03:42]
one can explain it somehow. It’s more difficult for MOND exactly because MOND is more predictive. That said, as you may have noticed, the error bars on these data points are quite
[03:54]
large. You’d think that the data from the Milky Way would be the best rotation curve data that we have but in reality that’s not the case. This is because if we look at other galaxies we preferably look away from the Milky Way and that gives a quite
[04:09]
clean measurement. If we look at the Milky Way itself we have to figure out where all these stars in the foreground are and where they’re going. It’s actually much harder. On the flip side though, once the observations become better and the error bars shrink,
[04:23]
there is less to argue about. If you are looking at a distant galaxy you can always say, oh, maybe we’re looking at it from a weird angle, or maybe it’s actually two galaxies, or maybe we have the distance entirely wrong. With the Milky Way there are no such excuses.
[04:38]
I give this paper a 3 out of 10 on the bullshit meter. It is actually very nuanced and doesn’t oversell the results as much as I did. It’s a 3 because I think astrophysicists
[04:50]
should acknowledge that the flexibility of the dark matter hypothesis is a problem, not an asset. The good news for dark matter is that it can probably survive this. The bad news for dark matter is exactly the same. In the end though, it may be good for astrophysics.
[05:07]
Because finally dark matter and MOND may have something in common: they’re both wrong. Young people in science frequently ask me what they should learn to improve their career options. And I always tell them, no matter what area of science you work in,
[05:24]
learn to code. And today's sponsor, Boot.dev, is a great place to get started. If your research is any good, spreadsheets just won't be enough. You'll have to figure out how to manage your
[05:36]
data and how to write a user interface so that other people can use it. And that's exactly what you'll learn on boot.dev, backend development, database management, user interfaces. They have hands-on lessons in which you write code directly in the browser
[05:52]
and you solve challenges to level up. They also have what they call the training grounds where you can figure out things without pressure. This is knowledge which will come in handy in pretty much any career. If you decide to go for the full experience, use my code SABINE
[06:09]
to get 25% off your first year. So, go and check this out. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.