[00:00]
What happens when you combine a really
[00:02]
bouncy ball with a really bouncy
[00:04]
surface?
[00:05]
It stops dead. But look, if I tweak it
[00:08]
slightly,
[00:09]
now it's a really good bounce. This is
[00:11]
when I realized I don't really
[00:13]
understand bouncing. Because it turns
[00:16]
out if you want to maximize bounce, it's
[00:18]
not enough to just combine two really
[00:21]
bouncy things. But what I found really
[00:23]
surprising was that when I tried to find
[00:26]
the optimum bounce using math, I ended
[00:29]
up generating fractals. First, I want to
[00:32]
be clear about what we're doing in this
[00:33]
video. Like I've shown you really bouncy
[00:36]
things before, like the atomic
[00:37]
trampoline and well, maybe you've seen
[00:39]
an advert for the world's bounciest ball
[00:43]
or whatever, but that type of
[00:44]
optimization isn't what we're dealing
[00:46]
with here. Like those examples are about
[00:49]
avoiding energy loss during the bounce.
[00:52]
So, the atomic trampoline minimizes
[00:55]
plastic deformation, the super bouncy
[00:58]
balls minimize internal friction during
[01:01]
the collision. But the thing is, this
[01:03]
bouncy ball and this bouncy surface are
[01:06]
both really good at retaining energy.
[01:08]
So,
[01:09]
what went wrong here? Well, look at this
[01:12]
ball bearing on this rubber sheet. The
[01:15]
ball is really hard and the surface is
[01:18]
really flexible and that gives you a
[01:20]
really good bounce. And with the super
[01:22]
bouncy ball, the ground is really hard,
[01:25]
but the ball is really flexible and that
[01:27]
gives you a good bounce as well. The
[01:30]
problem seems to arise when you have a
[01:32]
ball and a surface that are similarly
[01:35]
flexible. For example, Orbeez are really
[01:37]
flexible and so is this rubber sheet.
[01:40]
And right now, the combination is super
[01:42]
bouncy. But if I add a little bit of
[01:44]
weight to the rubber sheet, well,
[01:46]
suddenly it all goes wrong. And that's
[01:48]
why I built this contraption to try and
[01:50]
figure out what's going on. See, it's
[01:52]
when I change the weight that it goes
[01:55]
from a good bounce to a bad bounce. It's
[01:59]
weird, isn't it? Actually, this
[02:00]
particular configuration is quite fun
[02:02]
because when gravity pulls the ball back
[02:04]
down, it gets a kind of second kick,
[02:08]
which is such an odd behavior. By the
[02:10]
way, this is somewhat related to how
[02:11]
children typically injure themselves on
[02:14]
a trampoline. A child can often get an
[02:15]
unexpected second kick if there are
[02:18]
other people on the trampoline. Before I
[02:20]
show you what I figured out with this
[02:21]
device, I also had a good chat with the
[02:23]
professor of the author of this paper.
[02:26]
In the paper, they're thinking about it
[02:27]
in terms of a golf ball and a golf club.
[02:30]
And basically, they do a whole lot of
[02:31]
simulations where they simplify it down
[02:33]
to four things: the mass of the ball,
[02:35]
the stiffness of the ball, the mass of
[02:37]
the golf club, and the stiffness of the
[02:39]
golf club. And when I say stiffness, I
[02:41]
mean in the spring sense. So, like, if a
[02:44]
spring is hard to stretch, then it's a
[02:47]
stiff spring. If it's easy to stretch,
[02:49]
then it's a less stiff spring. And a
[02:51]
golf ball and a golf club are in some
[02:53]
sense springy. So, we talk about
[02:56]
stiffness. Anyway, when they run a whole
[02:57]
lot of simulations where they kept three
[02:59]
things constant and varied the fourth
[03:02]
thing, they discovered something really
[03:03]
surprising. See, in this graph, they're
[03:05]
varying the mass of the golf club while
[03:08]
keeping everything else fixed. And the
[03:10]
height of the curve is how good the
[03:13]
bounce was. Specifically, it's the
[03:15]
velocity of the ball when it leaves the
[03:17]
club. And you can see how the quality of
[03:19]
the bounce well, it goes up and down as
[03:22]
the mass varies. So, you get an optimal
[03:24]
bounce for these masses. But, if you
[03:27]
change the mass of the ball to one of
[03:29]
these masses, well, you'd actually get a
[03:31]
terrible bounce. To see what's going on,
[03:33]
I built this simulation that represents
[03:36]
the model that they were using in the
[03:38]
paper, and it means we can see actually
[03:41]
what's physically going on with
[03:43]
different examples. So, this is the mass
[03:45]
of the ball. This spring represents the
[03:47]
stiffness of the ball. This is the mass
[03:49]
of the club. And this spring represents
[03:51]
the stiffness of the club. Let's see
[03:53]
what happens if we set the mass of the
[03:57]
club to be about twice the mass of the
[03:59]
ball. So, the ball engages with the
[04:01]
club, it starts to squish, but also the
[04:04]
club is being pushed now, so that starts
[04:06]
to squish as well. Crucially, look, the
[04:08]
ball disengages from the club when the
[04:11]
club is at almost maximum squish, but
[04:13]
keep watching because but maybe the club
[04:16]
will catch up with the ball and it'll
[04:17]
give it a second kick.
[04:23]
No, it just missed.
[04:25]
Crucially though, look, see how much
[04:27]
vibrational energy there is in the club.
[04:30]
That vibration is energy locked away in
[04:33]
the club that could have been given to
[04:36]
the ball but wasn't. So, this represents
[04:39]
a bad bounce. Let's compare that to when
[04:42]
the mass of the club is about 2/3 of the
[04:45]
mass of the ball. So, again, the ball
[04:47]
starts to squish, and then the club
[04:50]
starts to squish as well. Right, the
[04:52]
club is now at maximum squish. The ball
[04:54]
didn't disengage this time because the
[04:57]
spring is still compressed. So, as the
[04:59]
club spring is re-expanding, it's
[05:01]
actually working hard against the mass
[05:04]
of the ball because the spring is still
[05:06]
compressed, and that's slowing it down
[05:09]
at just the right rate so that when the
[05:11]
ball finally disengages, look, the club
[05:13]
mass is at rest at its rest length. That
[05:17]
means there's no vibrational energy left
[05:19]
in the club. So, all of the energy went
[05:22]
into the kinetic energy of the ball.
[05:24]
This is a perfect bounce. But if you
[05:26]
look at the graph in the paper, you can
[05:27]
see that actually there are lots of
[05:30]
points of maximum bounce. So, let's also
[05:33]
look at when the club mass is about 1/6
[05:37]
of the mass of the ball. So, really it's
[05:39]
the same situation except if you watch
[05:41]
the club mass, actually it goes through
[05:43]
multiple oscillations before that
[05:46]
perfect separation that we saw before.
[05:49]
And it turns out that when you do the
[05:50]
math, you get quite a simple result that
[05:53]
actually, hopefully, makes some
[05:56]
intuitive sense. So, it's all about the
[05:59]
natural oscillation of the club. See,
[06:01]
the club naturally oscillates like this
[06:03]
over time. But because it's being pushed
[06:06]
by the ball throughout the whole
[06:08]
collision, this graph of position gets
[06:10]
skewed like this. Now, what I'm showing
[06:12]
you is a perfect bounce. Because, look,
[06:15]
the club is back at its rest position at
[06:18]
the end of the collision. That tells us
[06:20]
that there's no energy stored in the
[06:21]
spring at the end of the collision. But
[06:23]
also notice that the graph of position
[06:26]
is flat at the end. So, we know there's
[06:29]
no kinetic energy in the club mass,
[06:32]
either. Now, you'll notice that the club
[06:34]
mass has gone through two and a half
[06:36]
oscillations. But let's stiffen the
[06:39]
spring so it oscillates faster.
[06:41]
It's still a perfect bounce, but now
[06:43]
it's gone through three and a half
[06:45]
oscillations.
[06:47]
And there's a perfect bounce at four and
[06:49]
a half oscillations, and so on. And
[06:51]
look, if you go through a whole number
[06:53]
of oscillations, that's when you get a
[06:54]
perfectly bad bounce. How does that
[06:57]
compare to the natural oscillation of
[06:58]
the ball? Well, the ball always goes
[07:01]
through exactly half an oscillation
[07:03]
during the collision because
[07:05]
well, it's not sticky. So, here's the
[07:07]
simple rule. The club needs to go
[07:09]
through a whole number of oscillations
[07:11]
plus a half in the time it takes the
[07:13]
ball to go through half an oscillation
[07:16]
if you want to get a good bounce. If you
[07:18]
want a bad bounce, just go for a whole
[07:20]
number of oscillations. In general,
[07:22]
though, the surface needs to jiggle
[07:23]
faster than the ball for interesting
[07:26]
things to happen. But in reality, it's
[07:28]
hard to find a combination of ball and
[07:31]
surface where the surface vibrates
[07:33]
faster than the ball, but not loads
[07:36]
faster. In my setup, the ball always
[07:38]
vibrates faster than the surface.
[07:40]
Doesn't matter what I tried in terms of
[07:42]
springs and everything, but clearly
[07:44]
interesting things still happen. I think
[07:46]
that's because we made some simplifying
[07:49]
assumptions, but actually there is
[07:50]
another issue. See, in the simulation
[07:53]
some energy can be left behind in the
[07:55]
oscillating surface as we've seen, but
[07:57]
you can see in this footage that you can
[07:59]
also end up with oscillation energy left
[08:02]
in the ball. But actually because of the
[08:04]
way this simulation is put together,
[08:06]
there's no way to account for
[08:08]
oscillation energy left behind in the
[08:10]
ball because the spring doesn't have any
[08:12]
mass, so it can only oscillate when it's
[08:15]
in contact with another mass. In other
[08:17]
words, during the collision. So I
[08:19]
decided to make my own simulation. In
[08:22]
this version, the mass of the ball is
[08:25]
split in two. So the ball can now
[08:29]
oscillate on its own. Honestly, I'm not
[08:31]
sure whether it's a reasonable model of
[08:34]
reality, but I just want to show you
[08:36]
what happens when you explore it because
[08:39]
some of it's really interesting. So
[08:40]
yeah, I can vary the stiffness of the
[08:43]
springs and the masses or I can sweep
[08:47]
through one of those values to get a
[08:49]
plot. So look,
[08:51]
you can see here this is a lot like the
[08:53]
graph from the paper. So look, I can
[08:55]
select a maximum and then play that.
[09:02]
Oh. [sighs]
[09:03]
That's satisfying, isn't it? Let's look
[09:05]
at a bad one. Actually, look at the
[09:06]
worst one over here.
[09:10]
Oh, that's awful.
[09:13]
In the plot, you can also see the number
[09:15]
of collisions. So it's interesting,
[09:16]
isn't it? The collisions go up and up.
[09:18]
This is the internal vibrational energy
[09:21]
of the ball after the collision. It
[09:23]
doesn't actually get that high. So what
[09:25]
we can do is sweep two things at once if
[09:28]
we want to try and say optimize the
[09:30]
amount of jiggle in the ball after the
[09:32]
collision. We'll vary the mass of the
[09:33]
golf club and the spring constant of the
[09:37]
golf club. So, here's a heat map showing
[09:39]
how good the bounce is. If I go here,
[09:42]
this is a good bounce. See what that
[09:43]
looks like.
[09:47]
That's getting it. And then here's a
[09:49]
really bad bounce, let's say.
[09:54]
And if we switch to the internal energy,
[09:58]
there's a high point right here. So,
[10:00]
this is where we end up with lots of
[10:03]
internal energy in the ball at the end.
[10:05]
Look at that.
[10:07]
That is a terrible bounce. Most of the
[10:09]
energy is in the ball. But
[10:11]
interestingly, there's some structure
[10:14]
down here. Let's do a different sweep
[10:16]
with the mass of the club and the
[10:19]
stiffness of the club.
[10:21]
Look at that. Almost like a fractal.
[10:23]
Maybe it is a fractal. Like if I zoom in
[10:25]
here,
[10:26]
isn't that weird?
[10:28]
But anyway, an unexpected fractal
[10:31]
appears. Something else I discovered
[10:33]
that matches real life. Like if there
[10:36]
are several collisions within a bounce,
[10:38]
are you only looking at what happens
[10:40]
after the first collision, or do you
[10:42]
count all the collisions? This is a
[10:43]
perfect example.
[10:45]
It stops dead. It's a terrible bounce.
[10:47]
But then on the second kick, it's an
[10:48]
amazing bounce. And I got something like
[10:50]
this in my studio. Look at that. It's a
[10:53]
terrible bounce. The ball stops dead,
[10:56]
but moments later it gets a second kick.
[10:59]
So, how does this compare to reality? To
[11:01]
compare to the model, I don't need to
[11:02]
worry about weighing things or
[11:05]
calculating the stiffness, because I can
[11:07]
just measure the period of oscillation
[11:10]
from the video. Okay, so we're
[11:11]
interested in how many times does the
[11:13]
surface oscillate during half an
[11:15]
oscillation of the ball. The model from
[11:17]
the paper predicts good bounces at 1 and
[11:20]
1/2, 2 and 1/2, 3 and 1/2, and so on.
[11:23]
But I was never able to get the surface
[11:24]
to oscillate fast enough to explore
[11:27]
that, though I did get quite close. In
[11:28]
our data, the surface only ever goes
[11:30]
through a fraction of an oscillation
[11:33]
during the collision. This is where the
[11:34]
model from the paper predicts the good
[11:36]
and bad bounces will be, and these are
[11:37]
our good and bad bounces marked in green
[11:40]
and red. We never get into the
[11:41]
interesting region because my surface is
[11:43]
too slow. But clearly the data doesn't
[11:45]
match what's going on at the boring end
[11:47]
either. But here's the cool thing. In my
[11:49]
version of the simulation, interesting
[11:50]
things can happen when the surface
[11:53]
oscillates slower than the ball. In
[11:55]
fact, it's basically a mirror image when
[11:57]
you look at it on a log scale so that
[11:59]
you get bad bounces when the surface
[12:01]
oscillates faster than the ball and good
[12:04]
and bad bounces when the ball oscillates
[12:06]
faster than the surface. In reality,
[12:08]
it's more complicated than that for
[12:09]
several reasons, and our data doesn't
[12:12]
really fit this model either. But what's
[12:14]
clear is the model is very spiky. Like,
[12:17]
you don't have to change very much for
[12:19]
the quality of the bounce to change
[12:21]
drastically. And our data is also very
[12:24]
spiky. So our data has roughly the right
[12:27]
character, but I'm not sure we can claim
[12:29]
much more than that. One cool thing
[12:30]
about both of these models is they
[12:32]
predict what should happen for a really
[12:35]
bouncy ball on concrete or a steel ball
[12:38]
bearing on a rubber sheet. See, this is
[12:40]
a plot of how good the bounce is as the
[12:42]
stiffness of the surface increases. And
[12:45]
the line still goes up and down in that
[12:48]
counterintuitive way, but as the
[12:50]
stiffness increases, actually that
[12:52]
effect gets less and less until it
[12:55]
eventually just flattens out. In other
[12:57]
words, if you've got a squishy ball and
[12:59]
a concrete floor, you don't need to
[13:01]
worry about comparing their periods of
[13:04]
oscillation. And then you're back to
[13:06]
just worrying about dissipation through
[13:09]
internal friction and things like that.
[13:10]
And the same is true if you've got a
[13:12]
stiff ball and a squishy surface. So if
[13:15]
you want to find the bounciest
[13:17]
combination of ball and surface, you
[13:20]
can't just combine the two bounciest
[13:23]
things you own. You have to tune their
[13:25]
vibrations as well. Otherwise, you could
[13:28]
end up with a dud. I messed up while
[13:31]
making this video and I want to share
[13:33]
the story with you as a cautionary tale.
[13:35]
So, I wanted this surface to vibrate
[13:37]
faster than the ball vibrates. So, I end
[13:40]
up buying like stiffer and stiffer
[13:42]
springs, but nothing was working. The
[13:46]
frequency of this thing barely shifted
[13:49]
at all. It got to the point where I had
[13:50]
to print this part in a stronger plastic
[13:54]
and I was using these nuts to tension
[13:57]
the springs, which just took ages. I
[14:01]
eventually realized the problem. The
[14:03]
stiffer springs were heavier and so
[14:05]
adding mass to the oscillator, which was
[14:09]
counteracting the additional stiffness
[14:12]
of the oscillator. The thing that
[14:14]
eventually worked was ungluing this part
[14:16]
so I could slide it up and down and then
[14:18]
clipping it in place at different spring
[14:21]
extensions. But, the surprising thing is
[14:24]
that this is an almost perfect analogy
[14:26]
for cartridge razors. I want to be clear
[14:28]
that's a segue, not a crowbar. The
[14:30]
difference being that the link is
[14:31]
actually really strong. It's a good
[14:33]
link. It's a strong link. I mean, you be
[14:35]
the judge. Okay, here's the thing. The
[14:37]
problem with plastic cartridges is
[14:38]
there's always going to be a little bit
[14:40]
of give in the blade, so you get an
[14:42]
inconsistent shave. To counteract that,
[14:44]
manufacturers just add more blades in
[14:47]
the hope of catching more hairs during
[14:50]
each pass. But, the first blade will cut
[14:52]
some hairs, so the subsequent blades
[14:55]
will be scraping against skin in certain
[14:57]
places leading to irritation. So, then
[15:00]
they have to make the blades
[15:01]
deliberately more springy, which makes
[15:03]
the shave worse. So, they add even more
[15:05]
blades. Gets to the point where there
[15:07]
are so many blades, you have to add a
[15:09]
lubricating strip to overcome the
[15:11]
friction and people over time learn to
[15:13]
press really hard and so you also have
[15:16]
to add a post-shave balm and things like
[15:19]
that. Complexity piled on top of
[15:20]
complexity just because the
[15:22]
manufacturers weren't able to implement
[15:25]
the simple fix at the very beginning of
[15:28]
just holding a single blade really
[15:31]
family because you can never do that
[15:33]
with plastic. The solution is to not buy
[15:36]
cartridge razors. Instead, buy a
[15:38]
precision engineered aluminum handle
[15:41]
that holds a single blade firmly in
[15:44]
exactly the right position at exactly
[15:46]
the right angle. And if you're going to
[15:48]
do that, may I humbly suggest the
[15:50]
sponsor of this video, Henson Shaving.
[15:52]
With a Henson AL13, the training wheels
[15:54]
are off. You don't press hard. You can
[15:56]
learn the shape of your face because you
[15:58]
can actually feel it.
[16:00]
And you end up with an actually
[16:02]
enjoyable shave. No lubricating strip,
[16:05]
no aftershave balm. The handle is more
[16:07]
expensive, but you only ever buy it
[16:10]
once. And the blades are pennies. So, it
[16:14]
actually ends up being cheaper after
[16:15]
just a few months. Go to
[16:17]
hensonshaving.com/steve
[16:18]
mold and use code steve mold at checkout
[16:21]
to get 100 free blades with your
[16:23]
purchase of a Henson AL13. That's
[16:25]
equivalent to about 3 or 4 years of
[16:27]
irritation-free shaving. The link is
[16:29]
also in the description, so check out
[16:31]
Henson Shaving today. I hope you enjoyed
[16:33]
this video. If you did, don't forget to
[16:35]
hit subscribe. And the algorithm thinks
[16:37]
you'll enjoy this video next.