[00:00]
Nuclear fusion startups are postponing and postponing their completion dates. This unfortunately isn't surprising. More interesting is that it's becoming increasingly clear who's doing well and who isn't. In particular, the outlier approach helium fusion has encountered
[00:18]
some problems recently. Today, I want to look at what happened with Helon, but also give you an assessment of how I think it's going with the different approaches. Make sure you stick around till the end. I've got a great offer from today's sponsor, Outskill. In the past decade,
[00:36]
private investment in nuclear fusion technology has exploded. Fusion companies raised an record $4.48 billion in the past 12 months. The total investment since 2021 now sum up to more than
[00:51]
$14 billion. These investments show some of the same circularity that we're seeing for AI. The companies giving money to nuclear fusion startups are also signing contracts to buy the electricity
[01:06]
that may or may not one day come in. Google, for example, has invested into Commonwealth Fusion and also said they'd buy back from them. Microsoft has invested into openai and openmeai CEO Sam
[01:19]
Alman has invested into Helium's fusion machine which Microsoft said they want to buy from. The American steel manufacturer new car invested into Helion and also said they'll buy back
[01:31]
electricity if that electricity ever comes into being. There's nothing legally wrong with this, but it's certainly part of the reason why Helium was recently valued at a staggering 15 billion,
[01:44]
three times as much as January last year. That's despite the harsh criticism they've received earlier this year. As a reminder, Helon Energy works at a particularly innovative approach
[01:56]
to nuclear fusion called a field reversed configuration. They want to accelerate two blobs of fuel particles with magnets. The fuel forms rings which then collide and get compressed
[02:09]
in the middle. The compression increases pressure and temperature and fuses the nuclei. The magnetic field inside the few rings is reversed, hence the name. One of the appeals of Helen's approach
[02:21]
is that they want to extract electric energy directly rather than using the fusion to create heat and then extract energy from that. Now, when I first heard about this, I thought it's basically
[02:33]
a particle collider. There's no way this thing will break even faster than a celerator. But okay, not my research area. What's happened now though is that three groups independently have come forward and said this isn't going to work. First, there is one of the researchers whose
[02:50]
work led directly to the helion machine, John Slow. He said in an interview with Scientific American that helon's machine would never work. They have quote run up against a fundamental
[03:03]
aspect and that he can't see anything in the physics. Slow has proposed a different approach in which there's only one plasma ring that gets gradually squeezed until fusion sets in. Second,
[03:15]
a group from the Max Plunk Institute for Plasma Physics have looked at Helon's proposed mechanism and they say that it just doesn't work. You see, Helon says that they have a good chance to produce
[03:27]
net energy because when the two pulses collide, most of the kinetic energy goes into the heavy particles that are the nuclei, not the electrons. So, you have the energy where you want it. But
[03:40]
the Maxplank group says that while this might be the case immediately after the collision, the energy gets redistributed extremely quickly, meaning helium will never get anywhere close to nuclear ignition. They write, quote, only for very small values of gain which are of
[03:56]
no practical interest for power production with the initial temperature differences result in the improvement predicted by helium. [clears throat] Then third, we have a paper from a group in France which has found that only a small fraction of the magnetic field energy in the range of 1% actually
[04:14]
goes into the plasma which is a huge energy loss. They conclude for the realistic case net energy is never achieved even at a magnetic field strength of 50 Tesla. Helon has basically
[04:28]
addressed this criticism by saying yes, yes, but the critics are looking at an old design plan. We now know how to fix the problem, but we won't tell you how. Meanwhile, they have silently
[04:41]
moved their plan for net power from 2028 to maybe 2029 or 2030. As you probably guessed, personally, I wouldn't invest into helium. We've also seen in the past year that inertial confinement fusion
[04:54]
like it was pursued by first light fusion hasn't been going very well. Basically their progress stored. The approaches that have made steady if incremental progress are the more traditional
[05:06]
ones. Tokma accelerators and I'll count open stars levitating dipole among those. There are also a few hybrid approaches still out there such as the Zet pinch from Z Energy or Pacific Fusion,
[05:19]
but the pulsed version of magnetic confinement. The physics of the hybrid approaches is generally not as well understood. So, the risk that they fail is much higher. On the other hand, if it works, they might get the job done faster. Either way, though, at this point, it seems very unlikely
[05:35]
we'll see anyone producing net power from nuclear fusion before the end of the decade. In summary, understood physics is slow, poorly understood physics is fast, right up until you understand
[05:48]
it. Artificial intelligence is developing rapidly and open eyes GPT6 Astra's closer to AGI than ever. Are you keeping up? Are you sure? Today's sponsor, Outskill will bring you up to speed. Outskill is
[06:03]
offering a GPT6 Astra crash course. It's 3 hours long and it'll teach you how to build your own Astra workflow hands on. Outskill is an official OpenAI partner, so their team has exclusive access
[06:17]
before anyone else. They've tested it upside down and had time to figure out how to get the most out of it. In the workshop, you'll learn, for example, how you can use Astra to find jobs that are tailored to your skills or how to alert you of information concerning your stocks. When you
[06:34]
sign up, you'll also get the Astra Power Playbook with prompt formulas and workflows ready for you to plug and play. The link to sign ups in the description, or you can scan the QR code on
[06:47]
screen. I've signed up for it because it's an easy way to stay up to date. So, go ahead, sign up for this and learn what less than 1% on this planet know. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.