[00:00]
so you're wondering
[00:02]
what is the best tracking option for a
[00:04]
live.tv tuber in 2023 well look no
[00:08]
further in today's video we're going to
[00:10]
be going through all of the different
[00:11]
options that you have in vtube studio
[00:14]
right now so stick around and let's find
[00:17]
out
[00:19]
so here's what we're going to do
[00:23]
we're going to compare these four main
[00:25]
tracking options
[00:27]
and we're going to be comparing them
[00:29]
based on tracking quality
[00:31]
price
[00:33]
and how accessible they are
[00:37]
so here we are with the first tracking
[00:39]
option and this is actually the cheapest
[00:41]
one and this was just a base webcam
[00:43]
tracking
[00:44]
this is done directly through YouTube
[00:46]
Studio using just a webcam any HD webcam
[00:50]
will get similar results to this I am
[00:53]
personally using a Brio 4K stream
[00:56]
Edition webcam so first things first
[00:58]
let's have a quick look at the tracking
[01:01]
quality of the webcam tracking
[01:04]
the first thing I notice is my mouth is
[01:06]
very responsive now this can be tweaked
[01:09]
with your parameter settings
[01:11]
I think this is a pretty nice detail to
[01:13]
have you can really flesh out your mouth
[01:15]
shapes and it tracks it really easily so
[01:19]
you can see how I'm talking and the
[01:21]
mouth is constantly moving
[01:24]
in terms of face angles with the
[01:27]
settings I have it's pretty responsive
[01:28]
however you'll generally find that with
[01:30]
webcam tracking there is a general
[01:32]
stiffness to all of your movements
[01:36]
especially when compared to the higher
[01:38]
tiers of tracking let's give the eyes a
[01:41]
quick little test so let's do a wink
[01:43]
test
[01:48]
it does wink and we need to see how easy
[01:50]
it is to control the eyes on our model
[01:52]
as well
[01:56]
it is struggling a little bit however
[01:58]
it's not the end of the world in terms
[02:01]
of tracking quality let's go ahead and
[02:03]
perform the glasses test alright so
[02:05]
glasses on let's see how this performs
[02:09]
they're obviously the number one thing
[02:10]
with tracking is to make sure you're in
[02:12]
a well-lit area
[02:16]
surprisingly it is doing pretty well
[02:18]
when it comes to blinking however
[02:22]
it is a lot more hard to wink now
[02:25]
and significantly harder to keep my eyes
[02:28]
at a squint
[02:31]
next up we have RTX tracking now this
[02:35]
one is actually a newer feature in
[02:37]
YouTube studio and requires an RTX
[02:40]
series graphics card now this will push
[02:44]
up the price point for this particular
[02:46]
tracking level however if you do have a
[02:49]
more recent gaming PC then this might be
[02:52]
an easier option for you for better
[02:54]
tracking over the standard webcam
[02:57]
you can see that it's projecting my face
[02:59]
a little bit better compared to the
[03:01]
webcam as you can see from this
[03:04]
horrifying image on the left here
[03:07]
but let's see how it tests up so let's
[03:09]
go ahead and give this the Quick Test
[03:11]
through the mouth is moving perfectly
[03:13]
fine we also have an extra option with
[03:16]
the RTX as well because this one can
[03:19]
actually track
[03:21]
mouth X that's right we've got a little
[03:24]
bit more movement on this one
[03:26]
in terms of the face angles and other
[03:29]
bits let's give this a go
[03:35]
it feels a lot more Dynamic and a lot
[03:37]
more smooth in terms of the head turns
[03:40]
compared to the base webcam
[03:42]
mbis are tracking as expected there is a
[03:46]
little bit of
[03:48]
delay to them at some points
[03:51]
and the eyebrows are tracking a lot
[03:53]
better compared to the webcam
[03:56]
let's go ahead and give this the old
[03:58]
glasses test
[04:00]
all right glass is equipped how does it
[04:02]
weigh up
[04:06]
from what I can see the RTX tracking
[04:08]
actually performs better than the webcam
[04:10]
especially if you are a glasses User
[04:13]
it's still not quite perfect there's
[04:16]
Parts where it's making my eyes go a
[04:18]
little bit funky when I'm looking in
[04:21]
specific directions
[04:23]
especially with the glasses on so one
[04:26]
next tracking method is the one and only
[04:28]
Iphone tracking this uses the vtube
[04:30]
studio app on my phone
[04:33]
and connects to the vtube studio app on
[04:36]
bpc now this is one of the pricier
[04:39]
options as it does require a iOS device
[04:42]
with a true depth camera so if that's
[04:46]
generally iPhone x or above however I
[04:49]
will provide a link down below with the
[04:51]
full list of Apple devices that you can
[04:53]
use for this type of tracking
[04:55]
let's go ahead and do our tracking test
[04:58]
so we've obviously been talking for a
[05:01]
little while
[05:02]
but how does it
[05:06]
match up
[05:09]
so you might notice that this is a lot
[05:12]
smoother compared to the webcam options
[05:14]
that is because the iPhone has better
[05:16]
capability of mapping our face
[05:19]
and you might notice that it's finding
[05:21]
it easier to track things such as my
[05:23]
eyes like when my eyes widen like this
[05:28]
the mouth X is a lot smoother
[05:33]
and in general I find my eyebrows track
[05:36]
a lot better with the iOS
[05:39]
alright glasses on let's give this a go
[05:43]
move my eyes around
[05:49]
you can see that the iOS handles glasses
[05:53]
uses a lot better than webcam
[05:55]
my eyes on basically moving the same way
[05:58]
they were with the glasses off
[06:02]
I can lower my eyes a lot easier
[06:07]
and winking is no issue either but wait
[06:10]
what if I told you there was an even
[06:13]
better option for tracking that's right
[06:15]
the coup de gras of tracking
[06:18]
it's V1 V only it is V Bridger if you
[06:23]
don't know what this program is it is a
[06:25]
plugin that goes alongside of YouTube
[06:27]
studio and allows for a lot better
[06:29]
control over your tracking how does it
[06:32]
do this you might ask it allows for
[06:34]
better use of your iPhone's true depth
[06:36]
camera to basically translate all of
[06:39]
those extra blend shapes that you
[06:41]
sometimes see on 3D models onto your
[06:43]
live 2D model
[06:45]
unique tracking parameters such as a
[06:48]
more complex mouth with funnel and press
[06:51]
as well as puckering
[06:53]
as well as better control over your eyes
[06:55]
such as squinting
[06:57]
so let's go ahead and give this one a
[06:59]
test run too we have our mouth
[07:02]
obviously there is a lot more that you
[07:03]
can do with your V Bridger mouth
[07:05]
compared to any of the other tracking
[07:07]
options
[07:11]
such as chewing as well as our face
[07:15]
angles
[07:19]
end up blinking and eye movements
[07:27]
overall V Bridger feels the most fluid
[07:29]
out of all of the tracking options that
[07:31]
I've tried so glasses on let's give this
[07:34]
a quick go
[07:38]
so V Bridget handles glasses the best
[07:40]
however it's not too much of a step up
[07:43]
from base iOS tracking so in general iOS
[07:47]
is better when it comes to glasses users
[07:49]
however the RTX tracking was close
[07:53]
let's go ahead and have a quick overview
[07:56]
of all four tracking types and how they
[07:58]
match up
[08:15]
let's also do a quick little price
[08:17]
comparison between all four tracking
[08:19]
options let's pop them up on screen
[08:21]
right here here here and here
[08:25]
and you can see that there's a bit of a
[08:27]
price disparity between all four options
[08:30]
what really matters is what's going to
[08:32]
work for you within your budget
[08:35]
if you're enjoying today's video don't
[08:37]
forget to hit that like button and
[08:39]
consider subscribing to our Channel with
[08:41]
that big old Bell notification on to be
[08:44]
notified of our future uploads related
[08:46]
to live2d and V tubing
[08:51]
and if you are interested in getting
[08:53]
into live TV for the very first time
[08:55]
please check out this video right over
[08:57]
here to get started
[08:59]
see you next time bye bye