Why you should trim brisket fat
41sExplains a common misconception about fat cap, making viewers rethink their technique.
▶ Play ClipThis video provides a step-by-step guide for beginners on how to smoke a brisket. The creator walks through the entire process from trimming and seasoning to smoking, wrapping, and serving, while sharing personal experiences and tips for success. The ultimate goal is to help viewers achieve a tender, juicy brisket on their first attempt.
Trim the fat cap to about 1/4 inch thick to ensure it renders properly and doesn't leave a thick strip on the slices.
The creator is smoking for their neighbor to borrow a Weber Smoky Mountain smoker.
Cut off hard fat and silver skin (translucent film) as they don't render; save fat for rendering tallow.
Place fat trimmings in a slow cooker to render into liquid tallow, used later when wrapping the brisket.
Use a 50/50 mix of kosher salt and coarse black pepper. Apply to both sides and edges, let sit at least 30 minutes or overnight.
Smoker temp between 225°F-300°F. Pellet smokers should be at or below 225°F with fat side down; electric smokers need periodic venting. Cook takes ~14 hours total.
Cook all day Saturday, finish late night, refrigerate, then reheat Sunday for lunch/dinner — avoids early morning starts.
Maintain smoker at 250°F-300°F. Spritz edges every few hours to prevent drying. Cook 6-10 hours until brisket hits 165°F-180°F internal, moisture recedes (stall ends), bark is dark and set.
Place brisket on butcher's paper, spread tallow on paper and brisket to seal moisture and add flavor. Can skip tallow or use foil, but foil gives less crispy bark.
After wrapping, transfer brisket to oven at 300°F (non-convection) for 1.5-3 hours to finish cooking.
1) Internal temp at least 203°F. 2) Probe test: slides in like room-temperature butter. 3) Feel test: brisket bends easily and feels floppy.
Rest 2 hours on counter until internal temp drops to ~150°F. For next-day serving, refrigerate wrapped brisket, then reheat at 250°F-300°F until internal temp 165°F. Slice against the grain in 1/4-inch slices.
Neighbor loved the brisket and lent the Weber Smoky Mountain.
By following these detailed, step-by-step instructions and using the three doneness tests, even beginners can successfully smoke a flavorful, tender brisket. The video provides practical tips and timing strategies to fit a busy schedule.
"The title is mostly accurate: the video is an easy-to-follow recipe aimed at first-timers, though it requires significant time commitment and attention."
What thickness should the fat cap be trimmed to?
About 1/4 inch.
[0:26]
Why must you remove the silver skin from the brisket?
It doesn't render and would be tough to eat.
[2:21]
What is tallow used for in this recipe?
Spread on butcher's paper and on brisket before wrapping to seal moisture and add flavor.
[2:52]
What is the recommended rub for brisket?
50/50 kosher salt and coarse black pepper.
[3:06]
On a pellet smoker, should the brisket be fat side up or down?
Fat side down, to protect from radiant heat of the deflector plate.
[4:00]
What temperature range is acceptable for smoking brisket?
225°F to 300°F.
[3:49]
How long should the rub sit on the brisket before smoking?
At least 30 minutes, or overnight.
[3:23]
What are the three tests for brisket doneness?
1) Internal temp ≥203°F; 2) Probe slides in like butter; 3) Brisket feels floppy when bent.
[8:54]
After wrapping, at what temperature should the oven be set?
300°F, non-convection mode.
[8:21]
How long should the brisket rest on the counter before slicing?
2 hours, until internal temp drops to about 150°F.
[10:10]
What direction should brisket be sliced?
Against the grain, in 1/4-inch slices.
[11:22]
If you finish cooking the brisket the night before serving, how do you reheat?
Refrigerate wrapped brisket, then reheat in oven at 250°F-300°F until internal temp 165°F.
[11:07]
Fat Cap Trimming
Crucial technique for rendering fat and avoiding chewy slices; a common beginner mistake is leaving it too thick.
[0:11]Silver Skin Removal
Explains a frequently overlooked step that prevents tough, inedible parts in the final brisket.
[2:21]Rendering Tallow from Trimmings
Shows how to repurpose fat trimmings to enhance moisture and bark during wrapping, a pro tip.
[2:42]Pellet Smoker Specifics
Provides critical guidance for pellet smokers (fat side down, lower temp) to avoid burning due to radiant heat.
[4:00]Three Tests for Doneness
Gives beginners a reliable, multi-sensor method (temp, probe, feel) to ensure perfectly cooked brisket, not just a single temp check.
[8:54]Next-Day Reheating Strategy
Offers a practical solution for busy schedules: cook ahead, refrigerate, then reheat for easy serving without sacrificing quality.
[10:17][00:00] it's a step-by-step video on how to
[00:01] smoke brisket for beginners so let's get
[00:04] smoking okay it's the night before
[00:06] you're going to smoke your brisket let's
[00:07] call it friday so grab your favorite
[00:09] beer open it and have it on standby
[00:11] because trimming is step one get
[00:13] yourself a full packers cut brisket
[00:16] between 10 and 15 pounds the best
[00:19] quality you can afford you'll notice one
[00:21] side has a lot of fat on it that's
[00:23] called the fat cap start by slicing it
[00:26] down layer by layer until it's only
[00:28] about a quarter inch thick you'll need a
[00:30] sharp knife for this now you may think
[00:32] it's strange to carve off all that fat
[00:35] you just paid good money for but there's
[00:36] a good reason for it first we want the
[00:39] fat cap thin so it properly renders and
[00:42] it's nice and soft and juicy when you
[00:44] bite into it
[00:45] second most people don't like a huge
[00:47] strip of fat on their brisket slices and
[00:50] they end up peeling it off if it's too
[00:52] thick so we don't want our guests or our
[00:54] family to have to make that decision now
[00:56] while i'm trimming this fat cap down let
[00:58] me tell you why i'm smoking this brisket
[01:00] because i'm not making it for myself
[01:02] i've been thinking about asking to
[01:04] borrow my neighbor's weber smoky
[01:05] mountain for a long time now i've never
[01:08] used one before and i've heard it's
[01:09] great for set and forget smoking which
[01:12] i'm all about right now because as a new
[01:13] dad i just don't have a lot of time and
[01:16] i finally got the perfect opportunity to
[01:18] ask him because he just asked me to
[01:20] smoke this brisket for him so the plan
[01:23] is to smoke this awesome brisket for him
[01:25] and then i'll ask him to borrow his
[01:27] weber smoky mountain the perfect plan
[01:30] now moving on slice the hard fat off one
[01:32] side of the brisket this stuff doesn't
[01:34] render down at all so you won't want to
[01:37] eat it but make sure you save it because
[01:39] we're going to use it in the next step
[01:42] now i slice the corners off the flat
[01:44] side of the brisket if i don't they'll
[01:46] get really crunchy and dry and we don't
[01:48] want that we want everything to be
[01:50] tender and juicy
[01:52] when you're done with that flip the
[01:54] brisket over and slice off the hard fat
[01:57] on the other side of the brisket again
[01:59] you won't want to eat this stuff so get
[02:01] rid of as much as you can while still
[02:03] retaining the general shape of the
[02:04] brisket you don't need to carve so deep
[02:07] that there's a big crevasse in the
[02:09] brisket if there's a little hard fat
[02:10] left over that's fine you can just carve
[02:13] it off when the brisket's done and you
[02:14] slice it to serve it now moving on to
[02:17] the back side of the flat you'll notice
[02:18] there's fat and a translucent bluish
[02:21] film called silver skin that stuff
[02:24] doesn't render off so we want to slice
[02:26] it off just poke your knife under the
[02:28] silver skin and try to slice it off
[02:30] without taking too much of the
[02:31] underlying meat with it you don't have
[02:33] to get it all off just most of it now
[02:35] you're done trimming and you're left
[02:36] over with a bunch of fat do you throw it
[02:38] out no way we're gonna keep it and we're
[02:40] gonna render it down into tallow so step
[02:42] two is to render down your tallow place
[02:45] your fat trimmings in a slow cooker and
[02:47] just let it slow cook for the whole day
[02:49] stirring it occasionally eventually
[02:52] it'll render down into liquid fat that
[02:54] you can strain into a container we're
[02:56] going to use the tallow when we wrap
[02:58] this brisket later on and it'll make it
[03:00] super tasty and juicy now while that
[03:01] tallow is rendering we're moving on to
[03:03] step three
[03:04] rubbing your brisket i like to just use
[03:06] a really simple rub of 5050 kosher salt
[03:09] and coarse grain black pepper i shake it
[03:11] onto the back side of the brisket then i
[03:13] flip it over and i do the top sides and
[03:15] the edges then i flip it over again and
[03:18] i give it another coating and then a
[03:20] final coating on the top side now i'm
[03:23] going to let it sit for at least 30
[03:25] minutes so that salt can penetrate and
[03:27] season the brisket you can even do this
[03:29] the night before so all you have to do
[03:31] the next day is wake up and throw the
[03:32] brisket on the smoker okay it's saturday
[03:34] and it's time to get excited because
[03:36] it's time to smoke the brisket that's
[03:38] why we're all here now prepare to drink
[03:40] from the fire hose of knowledge because
[03:41] we're going to talk about time and
[03:42] temperature now but don't think you have
[03:44] to retain it all i'm still gonna cover
[03:46] everything later in this video step by
[03:48] step now you can set your smoker
[03:49] temperature between 225 degrees
[03:51] fahrenheit and 300 degrees fahrenheit it
[03:53] doesn't matter as long as you're in that
[03:55] zone you're fine there are two
[03:57] exceptions the first one is if you're
[03:59] smoking on a pellet smoker you always
[04:01] want to go fat side down to protect the
[04:03] rest of the brisket from the radiant
[04:05] heat coming off of that deflector plate
[04:07] and the burn pot and you want to be
[04:09] below or at 225 degrees fahrenheit you
[04:12] don't want to go much higher than that
[04:14] because again that deflector plate can
[04:16] get really hot gives off radiant heat
[04:18] and it can actually cook the brisket
[04:20] really fast and it can burn it if you're
[04:22] not careful and two if you're cooking on
[04:24] an electric smoker then make sure every
[04:25] few hours you're cracking the door open
[04:28] to let that steam out because if too
[04:29] much steam builds up then it can ruin
[04:31] the bark and cook your brisket way too
[04:33] quickly now whatever temperature you
[04:35] choose the cook is gonna take about 14
[04:37] hours to complete that means six to ten
[04:40] hours of smoking it about two hours
[04:42] after you wrap it and up to two hours of
[04:44] resting so if you wanna serve your
[04:46] brisket for dinner on saturday then that
[04:48] means you're getting up at around four
[04:50] a.m on saturday morning if you're not
[04:53] into that i definitely am not into that
[04:55] i wake up around 8am on saturday so i
[04:57] have a decent sleep i get up i casually
[05:00] cook my brisket all day have a couple
[05:02] beers enjoy it and then i finish
[05:04] sometime late at night before midnight
[05:07] usually and then i just pop it in the
[05:09] fridge i take it out the next day on
[05:10] sunday reheat it for a couple hours and
[05:13] then i just have it for sunday lunch or
[05:15] dinner that's pretty much how i cook all
[05:17] my briskets these days okay make sense
[05:19] probably not but we're gonna cover
[05:20] everything step by step later in this
[05:22] video so don't worry about it i'll cover
[05:24] it all now we're still on step four
[05:26] smoking so i'm putting my brisket on the
[05:28] smoker and i'm maintaining temperatures
[05:30] between 250 and 300. every few hours i'm
[05:34] opening the smoker and spritzing the
[05:36] edges of the brisket to keep them from
[05:38] drying out you'll probably run into
[05:40] issues during this portion of the cook
[05:42] in my case i had to look after my son
[05:44] for most of the day so it was
[05:46] challenging to run to the smoker every
[05:47] 15 minutes to add a split of wood and
[05:49] also look after my son
[05:51] luckily i had an extra baby monitor in
[05:53] the nursery so i installed that next to
[05:55] the smoker that way i could wash the
[05:57] smoker while i was looking after my son
[06:00] and watch my son while i was looking
[06:01] after the smoker
[06:03] now i'm going to keep smoking the
[06:05] brisket like this for six to ten hours
[06:07] until i see four things one the brisket
[06:11] has reached a temperature of 165 to 180
[06:14] internal two there was a bunch of
[06:16] moisture pooling on top of the brisket
[06:18] but now there's not so much anymore that
[06:20] means it's dumped its excess moisture
[06:23] and coming out of what's called the
[06:24] stall
[06:25] three the brisket has a nice dark bark
[06:28] if you're burning charcoal or wood it
[06:30] would be really dark like this if you're
[06:32] using a pellet smoker it might just be a
[06:34] kind of mahogany red because pellet
[06:37] smokers burn really clean without a ton
[06:38] of smoke and that's fine and finally
[06:40] when you scrape your finger along the
[06:42] bark of the brisket it shouldn't come
[06:44] off easily that means the bark is set
[06:46] and you're ready to move to the next
[06:48] step step five is to pull your family
[06:50] into the backyard and mansplain about
[06:52] everything you're doing be sure to make
[06:54] it all really complicated and let a
[06:56] family member do something like spritz
[06:58] the brisket or throw a split on the fire
[07:00] so they feel like they're doing
[07:01] something this will elevate you in the
[07:03] eyes of your family and give them the
[07:05] impression that what you're doing is
[07:06] quasi-magical and they could never
[07:08] replicate it now once everyone is
[07:10] gathered around the smoker you want to
[07:12] take it off the smoker and tell them
[07:14] you're getting ready to wrap it and then
[07:16] pray to barbecue jesus because we're
[07:18] about to wrap our brisket and this is a
[07:20] super important part of the cooking
[07:22] process now for step six we're wrapping
[07:24] our brisket place the brisket on a sheet
[07:27] of butcher's paper now take that tallow
[07:30] you prepared and spread it over the
[07:31] paper so it soaks in and then pour some
[07:34] on top of the brisket as well the tallow
[07:37] is doing a couple things it's soaking
[07:39] the butcher paper in fat so it seals in
[07:42] the moisture it's adding flavor fat is
[07:45] flavor and it's adding moisture without
[07:47] dissolving the bark you can also skip
[07:50] the tallow if you want to you can even
[07:51] wrap it in foil but then you won't get
[07:54] that really crispy sugar cookie bark
[07:56] once the bark is wrapped up tight put it
[07:58] in an aluminum pan or on a deep tray
[08:01] with some foil to hold the drippings in
[08:03] then we're moving on to the next step
[08:04] for step seven the brisket goes into the
[08:07] oven on the middle rack that's right
[08:09] we're using the oven the brisket isn't
[08:11] gonna absorb any more smoke being on the
[08:13] smoker so you don't have to waste your
[08:14] charcoal or your wood splits on your
[08:16] smoker anymore just pop it in the oven
[08:19] and that's how we're gonna finish it off
[08:20] i'm setting my oven to 300 degrees
[08:22] fahrenheit it's in non-convection mode
[08:25] the brisket can take a higher heat at
[08:27] this point because it's protected by
[08:29] that butcher's paper so don't worry too
[08:31] much about burning it or overcooking it
[08:33] this step is going to take between about
[08:36] an hour and a half to three hours so
[08:38] after about an hour and a half we'll
[08:40] move on to step eight step eight is the
[08:43] most important step because we need to
[08:45] do our tests to make sure that the
[08:47] brisket is finished properly a perfect
[08:49] brisket is cooked enough so that it's
[08:52] tender and pulls apart easily but not so
[08:54] cooked that it's dry and crumbly so how
[08:57] do we know when we get it to exactly
[08:59] that point well there's three tests you
[09:02] start doing these tests around an hour
[09:04] and a half after the brisket is wrapped
[09:06] and you keep doing them every 30 minutes
[09:08] until you pass all of the tests
[09:10] test one the brisket should be at least
[09:13] 203 degrees fahrenheit internally you
[09:16] can use an instant read or probe
[09:18] thermometer to monitor this we want that
[09:20] temperature high enough so it can render
[09:22] the connective tissue in the meat
[09:24] otherwise it's going to be tough test
[09:26] two the probe test just because it's 203
[09:29] degrees fahrenheit doesn't mean it's
[09:30] done you need to probe into the thickest
[09:32] part of the flat in the middle of the
[09:34] brisket and make sure it probes tender
[09:36] like butter if you pull your probe out
[09:39] and it gets a lot of resistance and by
[09:41] that i mean it drags the brisket with it
[09:43] as you pull it out then it's not done it
[09:45] should slide in easily and slide out
[09:47] easily as if you were probing a stick of
[09:50] room temperature butter test three is
[09:52] the feel test you'll need cotton gloves
[09:54] underneath waterproof rubber or nitrile
[09:56] gloves for this you should be able to
[09:58] pick up the brisket and it should bend
[10:00] in on itself easily and it feels really
[10:03] floppy like jello if it's stiff keep on
[10:05] cooking once your brisket passes all
[10:07] three finishing tests remove it from the
[10:09] oven and place it on the counter for two
[10:11] hours to rest it needs this time to come
[10:13] down in temperature and reabsorb some of
[10:15] the moisture before you slice into it i
[10:17] like to wait until it comes down to
[10:19] about 150 internal before slicing now if
[10:22] you're three to five hours away from
[10:24] dinner time when you need to serve your
[10:26] brisket and the brisket is done you can
[10:28] put it into a cooler and that will keep
[10:30] warm and food safe for up to five hours
[10:34] just make sure before you put it in the
[10:36] cooler after you take it out of the oven
[10:37] you open up the butcher's paper or the
[10:40] foil whatever you wrapped it in and you
[10:42] let the steam vent out for about 15
[10:45] minutes otherwise
[10:46] when you put that brisket into the
[10:48] cooler right after you take it out of
[10:49] the oven it could continue to cook and
[10:51] it will overcook and if you're like me
[10:53] and you don't eat your brisket until the
[10:55] next day then just pop it right in the
[10:57] fridge i don't even leave it out on the
[10:59] counter or anything i just take it right
[11:01] out of the oven and i put it right into
[11:03] the fridge in the aluminum tray with the
[11:05] butcher's paper i don't touch it at all
[11:07] and then the next day i take it out of
[11:09] the fridge pop it in the oven at about
[11:12] 250 300 degrees fahrenheit leave it in
[11:14] there for about four hours until the
[11:16] internal temperature comes up to
[11:18] around 165 degrees fahrenheit and
[11:21] finally step 10 slice your brisket
[11:23] against the grain in quarter inch slices
[11:26] and serve it up to your family or in my
[11:28] case my neighbor
[11:35] [Music]
[11:42] [Music]
[11:44] so in this case i got to serve up my
[11:46] brisket to my neighbor and he loved it
[11:48] his family loved it and i actually got
[11:50] the opportunity to ask him if i could
[11:52] borrow his weber smokey mountain and he
[11:54] let me so i was really happy
[11:56] because i'm going to be able to do a
[11:58] video on uh the weber smoky mountain now
[12:01] and i'll be posting that in the next few
[12:03] months for you guys and if you end up
[12:05] screwing up your brisket then watch this
[12:06] video on a hundred brisket mistakes that
[12:09] you probably made and also join my
[12:12] patreon i'll link that in the
[12:13] description section below you can ask me
[12:15] any questions you want get access to a
[12:16] private discord channel and i'll give
[12:18] you all the tips you need to nail your
[12:20] next brisket all right guys happy
[12:22] smoking
⚡ Saved you time reading this? Transcribe any YouTube video for free — no signup needed.