[00:00]
What is the role of quantum physics in the human brain? We don’t have a good answer to this. It’s a big question because if it turned out that the human brain actually used quantum physics,
[00:13]
like the feeling that a decision we make turns a possibility into reality. It would also give us a new perspective on what artificial intelligence can and can’t achieve.
[00:28]
Most of what gets published on quantum physics on the brain is nonsense. But today I have a new paper that is both more modest and more interesting than anything I’ve previously seen on
[00:40]
the topic. A physicist argues, quite convincingly, that fleeting quantum effects can influence neural activity much longer than we thought, just by standard physics. Let’s have a look.
[00:52]
The major problem with the question of whether quantum physics plays a role in the human brain is not that we can’t answer it. The problem is that the answer is trivially yes. Because everything has quantum properties if you look closely enough. Without quantum effects, atoms wouldn’t exist,
[01:10]
so of course quantum physics plays a role in the human brain! By the same standard, quantum physics also plays an essential role in cheese. I await the conferences. The more meaningful question is therefore whether quantum-typical effects like being in two states
[01:27]
at the same time can affect thought. Can you literally have two thoughts at the same time? And can the power of your will turn one of those thoughts into a decision?
[01:40]
The most famous attempt to connect quantum physics to human thought comes from Roger Penrose and Stuart Hameroff. They proposed that these quantum processes happen inside microtubules,
[01:53]
that are tiny structures in neurons, and that the collapse of their wavefunction produces moments of consciousness. Their proposal connects this collapse to the structure of spacetime
[02:05]
and every physicist I’ve ever talked to about this thinks it’s nonsense. The physicist Matthew Fisher has proposed that nuclear spins in certain molecules could have long-lived quantum states which could eventually influence the release of neurotransmitters and
[02:22]
the firing of neurons. I don’t know anyone who believes this either. There are also a lot of theories about quantum in the brain from non-physicists which I don’t even want to mention The new proposal now comes from a physicist in Istanbul,
[02:37]
and he makes a very interesting point. He says that a quantum state doesn’t have to keep its quantum properties for very long to have a lasting effect. We usually assume that if we have some quantum superposition in the brain,
[02:53]
one of, say, two neurons firing at once or, more ambitiously, two thoughts at once. Then this superposition will at some point collapse and leave only one state. One neuron that fires,
[03:08]
one thought, one moment in which your memory of why you went into the kitchen evaporates. The author of the paper now says, actually, this might not be the case. Because if the superposition existed at some point, even if only briefly,
[03:24]
then what happens at a later time might be different than if the superposition never existed. He takes this insight from a research area called quantum thermodynamics, so he does have a theoretical and mathematical backing. With that, he shows that if you start
[03:41]
with a particular type of superposition, an entangled state, then you are later left with correlations that would not be there had it not been for the quantum effects. The quantum effects leave a physical trace that affects what happens next. As he writes, “functional
[03:59]
relevance need not require the long-time preservation of fragile quantum coherence.” He points to several places where this could happen. One is hydrogen bonds, where protons
[04:11]
can become delocalised between different positions. But he also looks at microtubules and these phosphate groups that I mentioned earlier. And in both cases he says, yes,
[04:23]
actually these might leave an imprint on thoughts. And you don’t need any gravitationally induced collapse or other fancy new physics for it. Which to be honest is slightly disappointing.
[04:35]
Consciousness was much more glamorous when it required the structure of spacetime. The author has no experimental evidence that this actually happens. But he has a concrete
[04:47]
proposal for how to test this, with neural tissue in the laboratory. Basically he says, just look at whether quantum correlations leave an imprint in the neurons later on. If he is right,
[05:01]
this could indeed mean that the human brain relies on quantum effects that a conventional computer does not readily reproduce. This, needless to say, would be a very big finding.
[05:14]
What are we to make of this? I give this a 6 out of 10 on the bullshit meter. Compared with earlier quantum-brain proposals, this one requires much less exotic physics. The core idea seems perfectly
[05:27]
reasonable to me: a tiny quantum effect can leave a big fingerprint in the brain. But it remains unclear whether those fingerprints actually matter in the human brain to process information.
[05:39]
That isn’t a question I would pose to a physicist though, so I don’t want to blame the author too much. I have a good feeling about this paper, I think this might be the point when quantum physics in the brain finally began making sense. If this turns out to be right,
[05:55]
I look forward to blaming quantum mechanics for every bad decision I have ever made. I find it fascinating how much research goes into everyday objects like the razors from today's
[06:07]
sponsor, Henson. This might come as somewhat of a surprise to you, but Henson's team have a background in aero space engineering. They've built parts for the ISS and the ExoMars rover.
[06:20]
They use the same precision to design their razor. They figured out at exactly which angle the blades need to be positioned so as to cut off hairs perfectly and not cut your skin. The pieces
[06:32]
that hold the blades are not plastic, but cut out from metal to a precision of a hundredth of a millimeter. I prefer my husband cleanly shaven out without cuts, and Henson's is by far the best
[06:45]
razor I've seen at work. Also works for women. And of course, I have a special offer. If you buy a Henson razor through my link or use my code, you'll get 100 blades for free along with it.
[06:59]
You've never shaved that scientifically. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.