[00:00]
That there’s a link between quantum physics and consciousness is an idea that dates back to the very early days of quantum physics, a century ago. Most physicists today don’t believe this link exists and I understand the reservation. Then again,
[00:14]
it’s true that we don’t actually know how the human brain creates conscious experience so it is possible that quantum effects do play a role. Interestingly, we’ve recently seen new evidence supporting this idea, and no it’s not microtubules. Let’s have a look.
[00:30]
This idea goes back to physicist Matthew Fisher. In 2015, he proposed that the brain might use nuclear spins for quantum information processing. A nuclear spin is a quantum property of an atomic nucleus, different from the electron spin. Concretely,
[00:46]
Fisher thinks the spin relevant for consciousness is that of phosphorus-31. In the human body, some phosphorus appears in clusters called Posner molecules. These are
[00:58]
interesting because they can protect the nuclear spins from the noisy biological environment. This means they could maintain their quantum properties, which is usually difficult in warm, wet, and messy environments like living tissue.
[01:14]
This is the major issue with all these ideas that consciousness has something to do with quantum effects: That you need a way to explain why the quantum effect can be present in the first place. Roger Penrose and Stuart Hamaroff say the microtubules do it.
[01:30]
Fisher has the idea it’s the nuclear spin of these molecule groups. That, I have to admit, is a much cleaner way to encode quantum behaviour. And in contrast to Penrose and Hameroff, he also has an idea for what it’s got to
[01:44]
do with consciousness. Fisher says that if two of these molecules carry entangled spins, and later break apart in different places, they could release calcium ions in a correlated
[01:56]
way. Calcium is important for signaling between neurons. So, in principle, quantum correlations could influence neural activity. In principle, ok, but what about reality?
[02:08]
In one recent paper, a group of scientists did a calculation for how long these phosphate molecules can retain quantum properties in the brain. Fisher himself estimated about 3 weeks
[02:24]
which seems somewhat ridiculous. A different group later corrected this to half an hour. The new calculation now says something in the range of a few hundred seconds. So this is not
[02:38]
proof that there is a link between quantum effects and brain activity in general or consciousness in particular, but that maybe the idea is not as crazy as we once thought. Stop losing money on a pile of separate AI tools. Quick pause because today's video sponsored by
[02:55]
Nexus.AI. And unlike a lot of AI sponsors, this one's actually useful. If you use AI, you're probably paying for ChatGPT and Claude and Gemini and that can cost up to
[03:07]
$200 a month and you still only ever get one model's answer at a time. Nexus.AI puts over 200 models in one place under one login and you pay only once. It runs in Europe
[03:20]
and your content is not used to train anything without your permission. What I genuinely use though are the agents. You describe a task in plain words, no code, and it builds an
[03:33]
agent that does what you want. I have one, for example, that scans press releases to look for topics for my science news. It knows what I typically talk about, what I'm interested in, and what I need in the summary. So, stop paying $200 a month for separate tools, and switch
[03:50]
to Nexus. It's 50% off through my link, which doesn't last forever. And if it's not for you, there's a 14-day money back guarantee. Links in the description. Now, back to the science news.
[04:04]
In another paper, a group of scientists found that chemical reactions of this phosphate molecule with lithium isotopes depend on the nuclear spin. The relevance of this is not directly about brain signalling, but it lends credibility to the idea
[04:20]
that the nuclear spin plays a role, probably because it interacts with the electron spin. And then there is a third paper whose authors conjecture that these phosphate molecules are the reason why psychedelic drugs act the way they do, which would basically be a
[04:37]
direct link to consciousness. They have no direct evidence for this, but they argue that the drugs generate the right conditions for these particular molecule clusters to form. What are we to make of this? Ok. Let me be honest. I think this is 100% bullshit. The problem is,
[04:55]
I can’t tell you why. I just look at these papers and think it sounds like bullshit. And then I think this is not a very scientific reaction is it? So I try to be open minded and tell you about it. But well, this is what I think: It’s bullshit. There is also the issue that so far no one
[05:12]
has actually established that these particular molecules are present in the human brain to begin with. This isn’t as easy to find out as you’d think. We know that they exist in human bones, but in the brain they would be produced temporarily to take part in some signaling
[05:28]
process. So you can’t figure out whether they were present from, you know, slicing up people's brains after they’ve died. Also kind of raises the questions why my bones aren't conscious.
[05:40]
So is the origin of consciousness in some quantum processes? Probably not in this simple sense. But is the brain doing chemistry we still do not fully understand? Absolutely. And if phosphorus turns out to be important,
[05:54]
I apologise in advance to everyone who thought the soul would be made of something more poetic. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.