[00:00]
Strange things are happening in physics. It seems that physicists can't agree what's up with the expansion of the universe. Last year, a group claimed that the expansion of the universe does not, as we thought, speed up. That would mean that the 2011 Nobel Prize in physics was awarded in
[00:18]
error. The Nobel Prize winners have now pushed back, but their rebuttal was also rebutted, and it's somewhat of a mess really. But here's the brief summary. The universe is currently
[00:30]
expanding. This part everyone agrees on. It expands simply because it contains matter and energy. However, in the 1990s, observations of supernovae seem to show something more. The universe doesn't just expand. The expansion is getting faster. Normal matter and energy does not
[00:46]
do it. This why physicists had to introduce energy with negative pressure which is called dark energy and not small amounts of it. 2/3 of the energy in the universe would have to be dark energy to
[00:58]
fit the observations. The physicists who made the discovery were awarded a Nobel Prize in physics in 2011. This Nobel Prize has been controversial for several reasons. One reason is that at the
[01:10]
time many thought it was awarded prematurely. The evidence was not particularly strong back then. And that's true. But then again, the statistical significance has much improved since then and the results seems to have held up. Or maybe it's just confirmation bias. Another reason is that
[01:27]
the results partly looked convincing because the discovery was made by two different groups. However, if you do as much as read the author lists or the acknowledgements of the papers, it's
[01:40]
obvious that the two groups were in contact with each other and shared results. These were clearly not independent analyses. This doesn't mean the results are wrong, but it's a way that biases can
[01:53]
enter. Then last year, a completely different group looked at the supernovi data again, and they said there's a serious systematic mistake in both of the data analyses. You see, the way that
[02:06]
one usually infers the accelerated expansion is to look at how supernovae look different depending on how far away they are. And since light moves well with the speed of light, the more distant the
[02:19]
supernovi, the further back in time they happened. Looking at supernovae at different distances then tells you how the expansion of the universe has changed. The paper from last year then
[02:32]
said actually the different appearances of the supernovae have nothing to do with the accelerated expansion. It's just that the further away the supernovae are the younger the galaxies where the
[02:44]
supernovi happened on average and the age of the galaxy influences how the supernovae look. They redid the analysis and found that if one properly removes the effect from the age of the galaxy, the
[02:58]
expansion of the universe no longer accelerates and dark energies are necessary. Bold, because unnecessary is not a word physicists usually apply to invisible things that explain everything. The news is now that a group which includes two of the original Nobel Prize winners say that the
[03:16]
argument fails. They say that the New Dark Energy paper overestimated how much the age of the galaxy affects the supernova and that whatever's left is accounted for by standard corrections. The bottom
[03:29]
line is they say the expansion of the universe is still speeding up. The university put out a bombastic press release that was widely picked up. According to the press release, lead author Dr.
[03:41]
Phil Wiseman said, "The previous and well-accepted measurements were in fact fine and our current understanding of the page of the universe remains robust. Thankfully, we have averted this crisis, but the mystery about why the universe is still accelerating in size remains." A press release
[03:58]
does not mention that this rebuttal was rebutted already in March by the authors of the original paper who well defend their own analysis. At the same time, another paper was published by
[04:10]
a third group which redid the analysis using a different data set of supernovae and found again that the acceleration is not there. This did not get a press release because that would have made
[04:24]
the Nobel Prize winners very unhappy. This isn't a joke. It's almost certainly what happened. There's a lot of infighting in departments about whose research will be publicly mentioned and scientists
[04:38]
who question the status quo are usually on the losing end. What are we to make of this? These aren't calculations you can check with a pen on a paper. So I can't tell you whose analysis is wrong
[04:50]
or right. But I want to offer a general comment about the existence of this discussion. Obviously, the result depends on what you assume happens in the environment of the supernovae and how that enters the observations. This in return depends on how you think galaxies form and develop,
[05:07]
which in return depends on our model for the universe. We know that these galaxy formation models are difficult to get right. They have loads of parameters to twiddle that'll give you whatever you want. And still, they somehow managed to screw up the predictions for the earliest galaxies. My
[05:25]
takeaway here is therefore that the data is simply insufficient to make a strong case one way or another. Galactic environments are not well understood enough. Not today, and they certainly were not in the 1990s. So those papers all get a five out of 10 on my [ __ ] meter. But thankfully,
[05:44]
the crisis was averted by the people whose Nobel Prize depended on averting it. Always reassuring when the universe checks with the committee first. I'm always looking for new product recommendations
[05:57]
that you might find useful. And today I have one that's made my travel experience much more convenient. The electronic SIM card or e-SIM from Saily. What's it good for? If you're traveling,
[06:11]
you can avoid roaming fees just by switching to a local e-SIM. That can save you a ton of money. Something else that I found it useful for is to keep on using an old phone which no longer has a
[06:24]
SIM card. You can also use it to set a virtual location. How does it work? It's super easy. Download the app, select a country and a plan. And don't forget to enter my code SABINE before
[06:38]
checkout because that'll get you 15% off. Download the e-SIM and switch it on. And that's it. I swear you don't need a PhD to figure it out. Saily has 24/7 support and if the eim doesn't work on your
[06:53]
phone, a money back guarantee. So if you have a trip coming up or an old phone lying around, I say go and have a look at s.com. It's a really useful service. Thanks for watching. See you tomorrow.