[00:00]
Physicists may just have solved the biggest problem in cosmology for the past decade, the Hubble tension. They say that the tension is telling us something important about the origin of
[00:12]
our universe that we have so far just ignored. And not only this, but their solution also solves a secondary, if more minor mystery. It all seems to fit. Crisis averted? Let's have a look.
[00:27]
I just ruined Christmas for my mother-in-law because I went and bought new socks. I hope she'll forgive me because they come from today's sponsor, Bombas. Bombas is a brand with a mission. For every item you buy, they give one to homeless people. They have socks,
[00:44]
underwear, t-shirts, and slippers, and all have been thoroughly tested for comfort and quality. And they have a 100% happiness guarantee. You can return your item or exchange it for any reason. I
[00:57]
go running every morning, so I'm somewhat special about socks, and the ones from Bombas are, in one word, perfect. Soft where they need to be soft, tight where they need to be tight, and not too tight where they shouldn't be. My daughters now want the same socks,
[01:13]
so I have an idea what they'll get for Christmas. If you feel like you have use for a pair of socks that also helps the homeless, use my link in the info below. and the code SABINE at checkout for 20% off. And now back to the science news.
[01:29]
The Hubble tension is a discrepancy between two ways of measuring the same quantity, that is, the current expansion of the universe, usually denoted H₀. Astrophysicists can do this either by using stars and supernovae in our vicinity,
[01:44]
or by inferring the constant from the cosmic microwave background. Problem is, these two measurements give different numbers, a discrepancy that is now larger than 5 sigma. In the past decade the discussion of this tension has markedly shifted. Initially,
[02:00]
most astrophysicists assumed it’s a measurement problem, some sort of systematic bias, calibration error, that sort of thing. But over the years they’ve double-checked all of these
[02:12]
and the tension hasn’t just remained, it has gotten larger. Something clearly isn’t right. One of the most widely discussed resolutions has been that dark energy may not be this
[02:25]
entirely inert and constant substance that mysteriously fills the universe, but actually be dynamical so that it changes in time. This could also help explain other, Others have claimed that the problem is at the basis of the entire data analysis, that we have
[02:43]
the supernova results wrong to begin with, and the Hubble tension is just the tip of the iceberg. If this camp is right, we might have to throw out pretty much everything we believe to have learned about the universe. And the Nobel Prize in Physics from 2011 might have been awarded in error.
[03:00]
This group now says, actually yes, we might have gotten the data analysis wrong, but not that of the supernovae. Instead, they say, it’s the data of the cosmic microwave background that we have misunderstood. And the reason, they say,
[03:14]
is that astrophysicists have underestimated the relevance of magnetic fields. According to the press release, “these magnetic fields could resolve the Hubble tension.”
[03:26]
Yes, there are magnetic fields out there in the universe because they are created everywhere that electric charges move. Neutron stars, for example, contain plasma where the electric charges can move around a lot. This is why neutron stars
[03:40]
can have very strong magnetic fields. This is actually quite well understood. But the authors say, look, maybe the universe was just born with magnetic fields in place. These are called “primordial magnetic fields”. And the authors of the new
[03:56]
paper have now calculated what those fields would do to the cosmic microwave background. The cosmic microwave background is a very low-temperature radiation that
[04:08]
is everywhere around us. It was created about 380,000 years after the Big Bang. Until then, the universe was filled with a hot plasma, which means that electrons were not bound
[04:20]
to atomic nuclei. In this plasma soup, light couldn't travel far because it was constantly bumping into some other particles. But the universe keeps expanding and eventually the atomic nuclei trap the electrons for good. Then suddenly, the light that was around
[04:36]
at this time can travel freely. That’s the cosmic microwave background, CMB for short. If there were any primordial magnetic fields, they would move around the charged particles in the plasma. The authors say that this
[04:51]
helps the atomic nuclei to find atoms. As a consequence, the CMB light can escape earlier. That seemingly minor change has a big consequence because it changes how we extract the Hubble rate
[05:04]
from the CMB data. If magnetic fields allow the light to escape earlier than we thought, that changes the Hubble rate we infer, and that fits better to the data from the supernovae. And their idea has a good motivation, which is that astrophysicists have also observed magnetic
[05:20]
fields in galaxies that they have no idea where they come from. These, too, could be primordial magnetic fields. If that was so, this would be very odd. It’d mean basically that our universe
[05:33]
was born being magnetic. Magnetism suddenly seems even weirder than it’s already been. That said, the claim in the press release that this could “resolve the Hubble tension” is somewhat of an exaggeration. The issue is that if one takes magnetic fields of a strength compatible
[05:49]
with the observations from galaxies, then that weakens the Hubble tension, but it doesn’t make it go away. Just to give you numbers. Their idea would increase the Hubble rate inferred from the CMB from about 68 to about 70, but to remove the tension it’d have to be about 73.
[06:08]
I give this a 5 out of 10 on the bullshit meter. Primordial magnetic fields would be very interesting, but I am not convinced they solve the Hubble tension. Then again, please keep in mind that the bullshit meter is merely the summary of my gut feeling,
[06:24]
not a scientific device. We’ll need an independent gut to reproduce the result.